Justice Minister and Attorney General Mickey Amery introduced Bill 40, the United Conservative Party’s No More Fair Elections Act, in the Alberta Legislature yesterday.

Alberta NDP Opposition Leader Naheed Nenshi (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

While the bill once passed will actually be known as the Electoral Divisions Act, basically everybody involved in any way in Alberta politics understands that the sole purpose of this legislation is to ensure that there are no more fair elections in the province because the UCP now fears that Premier Danielle Smith’s separation referendum fiasco last month means it can’t win one.

I mention this because I can, whereas the authors of many news accounts you may read in media are required by journalistic tradition and managerial diktat to pretend that any public dispute over a policy that is self-evidently underhanded is only an honest disagreement between two equally reasonable sides operating in good faith with the best of intentions.

This is known in journalism as “balance.” Alas, the result of “balanced coverage” in circumstances such as the introduction of Bill 40 is to tilt the contest in the so-called marketplace of ideas steeply in favour of scoundrels and habitual liars. No names, of course.

Notwithstanding the gaping omissions in the potted history of what led up to the introduction of Bill 40 in the government’s news release yesterday, the facts are widely known and well understood.

First, the UCP’s intention to find a way to dump the entire report of the 2026 Electoral Boundaries Commission was obvious as long ago as last spring. They didn’t like the interim conclusion reached unanimously by the commission’s members, or the majority recommendation it made after its two UCP members had a Road-to-Damascus moment and suddenly changed their minds about what they’d earlier recommended.

Alberta Chief Electoral Officer Gordon McClure (Photo: Legislative Assembly of Alberta).

The UCP moved ahead with its unprecedented plan to circumvent the boundary commission’s recommendations because the majority of the commission’s members did their job and proposed riding boundaries that properly reflected changes in the population of Alberta since the last official electoral map was drawn in 2017.

This would have ensured that, as much as possible given the limit of 89 seats imposed on the non-partisan commission by the government, a general election would have reflected the wishes of Albertans.

But the UCP and the cabal of ideological Americanizers that leads it obviously intend to win the next election whether or not the results reflects the will of the people of Alberta, and Texas-style gerrymandering is the way they expect to achieve that goal.

As shown by the new electoral map that is now part of Bill 40, which will roll parts of Calgary and Lethbridge in particular into huge rural ridings larger than some countries to dilute the impact of urban voters who polls suggest are growing tired of the UCP’s antics. There they can be swamped by the UCP’s loyal rural base.

The bill would also raise the number of seats in the Legislature by two to 91, but not to accommodate the increase in Alberta’s urban population, which is why more seats were needed despite the government’s initial opposition.

The matter was handed off to a committee of the Legislature dominated by UCP members, and then to a so-called Independent Advisory Panel on Electoral Boundaries that delivered the gerrymandered riding map the UCP had obviously wanted from Day 1.

When Alberta’s Chief Electoral Officer, Gordon McClure, pleaded with the government in late October not to proceed with its gerrymandering scheme because there was too little time and the government faced the possibility of having its changes challenged in court, Mr. Amery told him, in effect, to drop dead.

The advisory panel’s report formed the basis of the No More Fair Elections Act – pardon me, the Electoral Divisions Act – which the UCP majority will ram through the Legislature in jig time. It will be law before the end of the year. That process began yesterday.

At every step since the introduction of the interim report of the Electoral Boundaries Commission last April, the heavy hand of the UCP has been obvious.

As the CBC put it in its story yesterday, “this go-around has been marked by accusations of U.S.-style ‘gerrymandering’ — a process in which politicians redraw voting lines so as to provide a boost to their own electoral chances — and threats of a possible court challenge from the Opposition NDP on constitutional grounds.”

The scare quotes in the story and its reference to accusations were necessary for the reasons explained above. Naturally, the UCP will insist that they are only acting in the interests of all Albertans.

NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi immediately told reporters yesterday that the Opposition party will challenge the constitutionality of Bill 40 as soon as it receives Royal Assent. “If this passes, we’re challenging it in court,” he asserted.

In a more cautiously worded news release, Mr. Nenshi called on dissident UCP members to “do the right thing and stop this undemocratic and rights-violating attempt to gerrymander the election by voting down this bill.” That, of course, is unlikely to happen.

“Albertans must choose their politicians, politicians cannot choose their voters,” Mr. Nenshi said in the news release. “That’s simply not allowed in Canada.”

Well, we’ll see about that, I guess, if this actually goes to court … and the courts find a way to act before the UCP bulldozes ahead with a gerrymandered election.

Bill 40 says the new gerrymandered electoral divisions will take affect when the next election is called, currently scheduled under the province’s amended fixed-election-date law to happen on Oct. 18, 2027.

It’s worth remembering that on Nov. 3, Texas-style gerrymandering didn’t even work in Texas. In the event polls start to suggest that might happen in Alberta too, who knows what the UCP will get up to?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.