That didn’t take long.

In a snippy letter posted to social media yesterday afternoon, Justice Minister Mickey Amery blew off Chief Electoral Officer Gordon McClure’s suggestion of a graceful exit from the legal and administrative problems likely to flow from the United Conservative Party’s scheme to gerrymander the results of the next provincial election.
Mr. Amery picked the less likely exit ramp of the two suggested in Mr. McClure’s Oct. 30 letter to all members of the Legislative Assembly to focus on first. “Alberta’s government has no intention of changing the date of the next provincial general election,” he stated, predictably enough.
“Alberta’s fixed election date is established by law and provides Albertans with certainty and predictability concerning the democratic process,” Mr. Amery piously added. (Unless, of course, the government decides to change the date for its own convenience, as it has already done once before.)
Albertans are entitled to expect that their provincial election will be conducted freely, fairly and on schedule,” the justice minister continued, which is not exactly what a lot of Albertans in fact expect. “Elections Alberta is entrusted with ensuring that those expectations are met.”
In other words: Drop dead!
Moving on to the possibility of legal proceedings to deal with the constitutionality of the UCP’s scheme to gerrymander ridings in Lethbridge and south Calgary to cheat the Opposition NDP out of a potential election victory, plans for which are expected to be made public by the government later today, Mr. Amery said: “We see no value in considering hypothetical judicial outcomes at this time.”
He went on to lecture Mr. McClure patronizingly about provincial elections law, with which the chief electoral officer is most certainly familiar, and remind him of the agency’s (inadequate) budget.
“While Elections Alberta operates independently of government, that independence carries significant responsibilities and corresponding expectations of accountability,” Mr. Amery huffed. (Translation: Don’t you go getting too independent!) “Independence does not diminish the duty to administer elections in accordance with the law, nor does it relieve the Chief Electoral Officer of responsibility for the effective management and performance of the organization entrusted to his leadership.”
Therefore, Mr. Amery concluded, as was predicted in this space, “Elections Alberta must undertake preparations necessary to administer the October 18, 2027, provincial general election under the final electoral boundaries enacted by the Legislative Assembly.”
That is, presumably, the gerrymandered version of the provincial electoral map that the government is determined to pass and that is likely to be challenged in court.
No doubt someone in the Premier’s Office is asking right now, Who will rid us of this turbulent chief electoral officer?
Mr. Amery’s letter appeared to have been composed in haste. At least, that is, unless Alberta’s capital city has been renamed Eddmonton in the past 48 hours or so.

It will be interesting to see if Amery’s riding of Calgary-Cross is gerrymandered to include rural portions of Rockyview County. Amery narrowly won the riding in the 2023 election by a margin of 3 per cent.
Didn’t Mickey Amery grant himself immunity from the law? Yes, he did that.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/mickey-amery-alberta-kaycee-madu-rakhi-pancholi-9.7008961
How self-righteous of him to preach “the law” only when applied to others. Rules are for thee. Policies are for me.
Now please disregard everything that’s going on in Alberta and pay attention to the U.S. midterms, people. Especially don’t notice:
1. The premier speaking at a separatist fundraising event on the weekend and sponsored by a gun lobby group; or
2. Various current and former UCP luminaries gathering with Wilberforce anti-abortionists (we see you all); or
3. UCP gerrymandering of electoral boundaries; or
4. Drew Barnes starting his own separatist party, called Alberta Now Party.
That’s all for now. Disregard!
@John
A very good question.
I suspect the gerrymandering will do exactly that; ridings in Calgary that the clown party barely won will be screwed with.
There is the possibility that Smith will change course today; a “delay” announcement will be the harbinger. Not holding my breath.
Personally, I would like to Nenshi or Clark to go proactive; there is a perfectly good majority report, take the government to court, asking for that report to be implemented.
Truly wonders of nature! Your top picture once again reminds us of how remarkably well UCP Ministers resemble their names. (Although that Glubish guy is still at the head of the pack.)
Here’s another chance for the UPC to listen to logic and the Alberta Justice Minister, carrot top only cares about retaining power. How much more money is this government going to waste trying to force their incompetence down our throats? The Smith government, is without a doubt the worst Alberta has had to endure and the list of their greed and stupidity goes longer everyday. Also, how much fun was that…, re-setting the time on all all your devices at home and at work. I know I certainly enjoyed it. LOL
It would appear that despite swearing an oath to uphold the law in both his current and former career Mickey Amery seems more interested in the accumulation of wealth and power. Ironic that he inherited his riding from Tyler Shandro, and a reminder that he is also a nepo baby just like many members of Danielle Smiths cabinet of traitors liars and thieves. These children of former MLAs seem to think they own the province and the rest of us just live here. Self appointed redneck royalty. See you in court barrister; likely for more than one reason.
Corrupt care scandal anyone ?
How desperate must things be at Alberta Elections for Mr. McClure to so publically communicate?
Just ask the 8 health care public servants (2026), Jill Clayton (2022), Athana Mentzelopoulos (2025), Lorne Gibson (2019), etc.
Because it’s almost impossible to see parliament as the nonpartisan body that it actually is, some in the UCP –likely a unanimity in cabinet–think it’s as okay to burden the assiduously impartial Electoral Office and electoral boundary commission with as much partisanship they can get away with in their swooning emulation of Maple MAGA idol Donald F tRump.
The Westminster parliament is the instrument by which the Sovereign’s guarantee —that Canadians have popularly-elected governments which can act at all times— is made good.
Each of our ten-member federation is appointed a governor to make good the Sovereign’s guarantee. Voters residing in one of a jurisdiction’s ridings elect a representative to the provincial legislative assembly (in Canada a unicameral parliament) and the governor recognizes a subset of the total as government without concern which party or parties that might be, instead concerned only with the passage of bills into law by a majority vote, regardless what if any party affiliation comprise the majority vote. As such the governor is a totally nonpartisan, impartial, unbiased, and nonpolitical officer of parliament.
The governor makes only two particular distinctions among members parliament: the “first minister” of cabinet, or the “premier” who advises on the maintenance of parliamentary confidence; and the leader of the loyal opposition who advises that alternative policies the opposition thinks cabinet should consider have been spoken in the House, and assures that the opposition is ready to assume power as the government in waiting at a moment’s notice (in the event the governing group is incapacitated). In the event a single party wins every seat, one of its caucus must be designated opposition leader for the governor’s satisfaction.
Even the Speaker—usually but not always selected from the governing group or party— must be nonpartisan for the purpose of parliamentary procedure. No member of a parliament is recognized as a party member, only as the representative of such-and-such riding. Our Constitution does not mention anything about parties at all.
But we are constitutionally free to associate with and assemble political parties (party-abolitionists ignore this fact), and we prefer to cast for parties. Although Independent candidates appear on most ballots, they rarely get elected. Moreover, voters most often cast for party leaders even though for most that person does not appear on their ballot–that is, party overrides the quality—and often the name, too–of the actual riding candidate (it’s been shown that most voters cannot connect a candidate’s name to the correct party unless the party name is written beside it). It’s fair to say we have become much more partisan than we used to be, the descriptor “polarized” now blithely attributed to all partisanships despite the fact that only some are vehemently so. Some of our elected politicians’ parliamentary performances these days would suggest the forum is meant to be as vehemently partisan as possible. How, then, is the governor and Speaker to maintain the nonpartisan nature of parliament when most citizens think its purpose is to be as partisan as possible?
One way is to hold free, fair and trustworthy elections using the secret ballot so that nobody be coerced into voting one way or the other (indeed, in Canada we are free to not vote—and usually over one-third of the eligible electorate doesn’t). But it matters not to the governor whether voters mistakenly believe they are not represented if the candidate for whom they cast did not win the riding —in fact, an elected parliamentarian is duty bound to represent all constituents, regardless for whom they cast or if they voted at all (remind that children under the age of majority may not vote but have every right to be represented like everybody else). Neither does it matter to the governor what electoral or voting systems were used so long’s every eligible voter is not impeded from casting a ballot. Another way is to have a subsequent election in about 4 years when riding voters can hold their representatives responsible for their performance thus far.
Because elections often result in a single party holding a majority of seats, the governor is often mistakenly seen as a “rubber stamp.” However, often enough we elect hung parliaments (6 of last 8 elections produced hung federal parliaments, only Martin’s Liberal minority was toppled by non-confidence on the CPC’s 2nd attempt in 2006—although Harper’s CPC bullied the GG to avoid a confidence vote he would have otherwise lost in 2008). Westminster tradition has developed ways for the governor to obviate any hint of partiality in such cases. For example, if the incumbent governing party wins less seats than the official opposition party in a hung result, tradition holds that it will remain government—this in order it may try to cobble together a parliamentary alliance with enough smaller parties’ votes to get bills passed. It remains that whatever alliance or coalition must maintain confidence, the real acid test which absolves the governor of any risk of looking biased in any party’s favour.
If such a governing party (with less seats than the official opposition but supported with supply-and-confidence agreement with other parties) loses a subsequent confidence vote, the governor is tradition bound to explore the hung parliament for another group which can commit to passing bills –and would not accept an alliance between the opposition and any one of the parties which was allied to the toppled governing party. If no alternative group (whatever its partisan composition) can convince the governor of its commitment to pass bills, the governor uses exclusive authority to dissolve the parliament and call an election to replace it.
Thus parliament is as nonpartisan as either the Speaker or governor must always demonstrate. The Speaker is responsible for procedure that respects only the representative nature of MLAs, not their partisanship, and the governor for the continual passage of bills into law without—or as little—interruption as possible, and the dissolution of parliament upon the first ministers advise that cher party has lost confidence, is asking for new mandate early for some reason, or has completed a statutory term.
The Electoral Office is of paramount importance in fulfilling the Sovereign’s guarantee, in filling the legislature with elected representatives. If the Office is impaired in any way, it is the governor’s business and authority to remedy; if the parliament cannot agree about adequately funding the Office, it seems to me the governor has a case to dissolve it without compromising requisite impartiality.
The governor may of course seek advice from any competent agency chi wants. Surely the Chief Electoral Officer’s concerns about underfunding, especially in the face of extraordinary—or extraordinarily irregular—burdens placed upon the Office (neither governor nor Chief Officer need to judge whether UCP meddling in electoral affairs is partisan or not, just that the burden is not adequately funded–which appears to be irrefutable fact).
Finally, the boundary commission should obviously be a nonpartisan body. A parliamentary committee might serve but only if the decisions it makes are by consensus: if a consensus cannot be reached, partisanship is evidently to blame. This dissenting opinion of two partisans on the committee is only more evidence that impartiality has not been achieved as required for setting riding boundaries —and for free and fair elections. There is no such thing as a dissenting opinion in a consensus body.
The UCP’s attempts to subvert democracy —that is, cheating to avoid losing—starts with gerrymandering (we have as yet no evidence of ballot-stuffing or vote-rigging) and slithers its way to the very heart of Westminster. But can the governor act or remedy without perceivable conflict or partisanship?
One more gate has to be kept: courts of law. It should be of supreme interest to judges that the governor’s impartiality is not unduly questioned just because a radicalized governing party has lost its way. It seems impossible to me that any judge would not toss this bogus “dissenting opinion” to allow blatant gerrymandering that is obviously intended to favour one party over others. The original map is adequate for a fair and democratic election.
Here’s the question of the day. There’s all this talk of legal action BUT what kind of time frame are we looking at from when the gerrymandered boundaries become established to when the first legal action occurs to a final judgment that could change the course of the election. With the glacial pace of legal action against governments my guess is nothing will be resolved in a timely fashion. Those hoping a court order will save the day are likely in for some severe disappointment.
Considering this letter, perhaps the UCP should be renamed the UPP (United Petty Party) or the UGP (United Gerrymandering Party).
If the Chief Electoral Officer really is independent, he could just ignore Amery’s snippy letter, as he has already made his point, clearly. Of course, there may be consequences to that.
Also, it would be reasonable not to plan for different boundaries until it is known if there are any court challenges and until their outcome is resolved.
Smith and her angry minion would probably not like that much either, but in a battle for public support an independent election official probably has much more credibility than either of them.
Smith has a history of questionable judgements on big issues, most recently with her referendum initiative. So I would not be surprised if she keeps digging a bigger hole for herself here.
I can’t wait for Mickey Amery to have his butt walloped, while the entire UCP goes the way of the dodo bird.
Given the tone and tenor of Amery’s letter to McClure, one should not be surprised if McClure resigns. In fact, one should be surprised if he doesn’t.
What assurances are the UCP receiving from their dark money donors that make them believe they will be rewarded after leaving office, despite their incompetence and abuse of power?