Alberta Chief Electoral Officer Gordon McClure has just offered Premier Danielle Smith and her MLAs a graceful exit ramp from the embarrassment of having a court overturn a shameless scheme to gerrymander their way to an election victory.

Chances are that Ms. Smith and her United Conservative Party Caucus won’t take it, so off to court they’ll go, using Albertans’ tax money to defend their planned attack on Alberta democracy. That would be on brand.
Still, it’s said here the UCP might be smart to agree to Mr. McClure’s suggestion that they stick to the currently established electoral boundaries for the expected 2027 general election, assuming it goes forward on the legislated Oct. 18 fixed-election date.
After all – their unpopular recent separation referendum vote notwithstanding – voters’ memories are short and Alberta’s traditional voting habits are tribal enough in nature that it’s well within the UCP’s grasp to win the 2027 election honestly.
The question: Do they have it in themselves to take the chance on doing the right thing?
In a letter sent to all members of the Legislative Assembly on Friday, Mr. McClure gently reminded them of the legitimacy of the process that led to the report of the 2025 Electoral Boundaries Commission, which last April recommended a new electoral map for the province.
Sometime shortly after the non-partisan commission’s members appointed by the UCP and the Opposition NDP unanimously recommended the new electoral map, the two UCP members on the commission for some reason changed their minds and published a dissenting report with a map of their own that telegraphed the intention of the Smith Government to gerrymander urban and rural ridings to dilute urban votes and give itself an unfair edge in the next general election.
It’s not hard to imagine what happened behind the scenes to lead to this situation.
Using the rift on the commission as an excuse, the government tossed the commission’s report – the product of more than 30 public hearings throughout Alberta, in person and online, and close to 2,000 written submissions – and struck a UCP-dominated committee to come up with a hurried do-over more acceptable to the government.
Those new electoral maps are expected to be published Monday, but they are widely understood to show heavily gerrymandered ridings in south Calgary and Lethbridge clearly intended to dilute the NDP vote inside those cities by shuffling many voters off into large hybrid ridings covering vast swaths of reliably conservative rural territory.
Both the majority of the original Electoral Boundaries Commission, which was headed by a retired Court of King’s Bench justice, and the Opposition NDP have warned that if the UCP tries to implement the new gerrymandered map, the result may be a legal challenge, which could well succeed.
Now Mr. McClure’s letter has entered the debate.
“Recent media reports have raised the possibility the proposed boundaries could be subject to legal challenge,” Mr. McClure diplomatically noted. “While Elections Alberta takes no position on the merits of any potential legal proceedings, the prospect of a court challenge introduces additional uncertainty into an already compressed implementation schedule.”
“The challenges presented by further delay in settling electoral boundaries are compounded by Elections Alberta’s limited organizational capacity,” he continued. “Elections Alberta is already the leanest electoral management body in Canada on a per voter served basis. In the last 24 months we have been increasingly required to do more, with less resources.”
He noted, although not in quite these words, that work required to run Premier Smith’s ridiculous separation referendum and its nine noxious policy referenda, plus dealing with numerous petitions under the Citizen Initiative Act, hasn’t left his understaffed and underfunded agency in any position to plan for two election scenarios in the face of a court challenge to the government’s gerrymandering scheme.
He offered, therefore, two ways out of the dilemma:
- Let Elections Alberta hold a provincial general election event with the existing electoral boundaries.
- Extend the fixed-election date so that Elections Alberta has time for “orderly establishment, mapping, implementation, and operational preparation of the electoral boundaries.”
“These requests are not intended to influence the substance of the Legislature’s deliberations or any judicial determination,” Mr. McClure wrote, rather plaintively. “Rather, they reflect the practical requirements of election administration and the need to ensure that decisions concerning electoral boundaries are accompanied by a realistic and achievable implementation schedule.”
The UCP won’t like Option 1. They’re going to be anxious to get on with their gerrymandering before the public, tired of politics after the referendum campaign, starts to notice. It’s not just progressive city voters that will be unhappy, though. Some residents of rural ridings are sounding almost as unhappy about being forced into such unnatural pairings.
But the party isn’t going to like Option 2 either, because they know that the longer they wait, the worse their chances may get. You can call an election too soon in Canada’s Parliamentary system, as we’ve just seen in B.C., but you can call one too late too. Four years is the sweet spot. They’ve also moved the date once before to improve their electoral chances, or so they thought. There’s always a risk voters will cotton on to what they’re up to.
Mr. McClure has offered them a way out. Alas, this lady’s not for turning, even when it’s the smart thing to do.

It has been said many times that Smith leaves chaos in her wake. She has done this already with health care, more recently with all her referendums and now she seems to be messing with the next election.
Unlike some of her other past distractions, this is one that she likely wants Albertans to pay less attention to. However, Elections Alberta just shone a huge spotlight on it. Smith could have just gone along with the new boundaries proposed and Elections Alberta would have had enough time to implement things. However, yet again she is trying to manipulate a process for her political benefit and it could again come back to bite her.
She is stubborn and overconfident, at times so she may feel she can be persuasive or voters will just not care about her continued attempted gerrymandering. In a battle of credibility perhaps she could also survive if it was just the opposition and other partisans against her, but now this is becoming a battle with impartial Elections Alberta. This is an important and material change.
As much as she likely still wants to try manipulate riding boundaries it is time for her to recognize the political danger of doing so has just gone up considerably.
Given Dingy Smith’s dictatorial style and actions, in my view there is no way she will back down with the gerrymandering and will simply charge ahead. Again it will be another exercise in pissing away millions of taxpayer dollars to try and assert her hold on the reins.
She’s no lady.
Option one: existing boundaries. Option two: delay the next election. Option three: new boundaries with no time and lawsuits.
Since she’s foisted non-stop 24-hour online gambling on us, and with it a barrage of non-stop gambling commercials, why doesn’t she settle this by trying her hand with Lady Luck: play craps to decide? Nobody wants an extension of the already-extended Smith term in power. Nobody wants her dog-leg constituencies. Nothing she does is about Albertans or for the for betterment of Albertans, Alberta or Canada. Smith is for Smith. Smith will choose option three, maximum chaos.
I wouldn’t put it past her to refuse to leave when she’s voted out. People call her Trump in Pumps for a reason.
Has anyone heard how things went at her little seppie monsters’ shindig on Halloween?
Smith’s ego won’t allow her to accept either the 2025 report, or option one. She is all about absolute power and she’ll fight to the end to get her way. The November AGM can’t come fast enough.
It’s time for Nenshi & ABNDP to get proactive. There is perfectly good report that Smith wants to ignore. Take the UCP to court and force them to accept & implement it for the next election.
I wrote to Brandon Lunty ( he is my MLA) and asked him to stop this gerrymander mess. There is a part of me that feels the electorate has had enough of corruption and the gerrymandering could backfire
In addition to the blatant gerrymandering, the UCP map will add four more seats to the Legislature. All in an effort to preserve the representation of the UCP’s shrinking population base in rural and small town Alberta.
Best to keep the existing electoral boundaries for the 2027 election. Hopefully with the election of an Alberta NDP government, the Legislature can be capped at the current 87 seats while equalizing populations between electoral divisions. The loss of some rural seats is necessary when 90% of the population growth is taking place in greater Edmonton and Calgary.
I was watching the Calgary Flames/Carolina Hurricanes game on Sunday Oct 17. During the game there was 1 ND ad featuring Nenshi advocating for staying in Canada on question 10 of the upcoming referendum. There were also no less than 6 UCP attack ads casting aspersions on ND MLAs Dave Eggen, Janis Irwin and Naheed Nenshi for not being unequivocal in their support for pipelines. Looks like desperate times for the UCP even before the referendum results were known.
I hope to move to BC to be closer to my son and his family before an election, I have never voted for UCP and never will
Come on down Alice. We could use your help. Living in a lonely NDP riding on Vancouver Island makes me sad.
Not sure things will be much better in BC considering who just got elected there.
Alice, I too am with the NDP. Don’t worry you won’t be lonely. There are still lots of us. Based on past history its going to be a gong show with the right wingers back in office. In 1956 Robert Summers a Socred Cabinet Minister was arresed, tried, convicted and sentenced to jail. Things did not get better in BC. The right wing in BC like to make money, not for the province but for themselves. el gordo sold B.C. Rail and that was a mess and there were trials. the suddenly privatized cleaning in hospitals and some one made money, those contracts were entertaining. The run of the river projects, some one will be making money and then the contract to replace all the electric meters on homes I do believe it was a billion dollars and the lucky winner was a one person company. Christy, well she managed to expense a breakfast for $700 at a hotel with room service. don’t know what she ordered but I do know how that can happen. All of those people liked to travel on the taxpayers’ dime. When the drug crisis started old christy did nothing. just sat on her hands. At least Alberta banned pill presses. Oh I do think her gang cut funding for the gang unit, you know the cops who try to get rid of gangs and slow down their drug business. this new bunch of cons will be doing their con bit so please do move to B.C. You will love vancouver island. Less snow, less cold