Guest Post: Tales from the annals of inevitable right-wing political victories in Western Canada

Posted on October 27, 2017, 1:07 am
3 mins

PHOTOS: Parliament Hill in Ottawa, whence he came to save his province from socialism … Below: Guest post author John Ashton, Jason Kenney (Photo: Creative Commons, Michał Józefaciuk, Senat Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej), and Elwin Hermanson (Photo: Twitter).

“It’s my belief that history is a wheel. ‘Inconstancy is my very essence,’ says the wheel. Rise up on my spokes if you like, but don’t complain when you’re cast back down into the depths. Good times pass away, but then so do the bad. Mutability is our tragedy, but it’s also our hope. The worst of time, like the best, are always passing away.” – Boethius, The Constellation of Philosophy, AD 524

Guest Post by John Ashton

The idea found him, while he sat in the House of Commons.

He had been sent there, originally, by constituents who wanted a hard-core conservative MP to represent them. Born of the Reform Party, he had left his western home to in the 1990s to shake up Ottawa.

But while he sat in Ottawa, he felt the problem was far greater back home.

Socialism, a set of values that he abhorred, was the dominant approach to governance in his home province. He feared it would remain so, for many years to come.

Those that opposed socialism in his home province were divided into two camps. He envisioned a dystopia, where the socialists would keep defeating these divided camps for an eternity.

He returned home to join those opposed to socialism and call for unity. In this, he and his like-minded allies succeeded with ease.

Furthermore, this new cadre of opponents of socialism chose to advocate for strong conservative values. This prompted him to seek to lead this group, this new united party, even though he had come from Ottawa, and had never sat in the provincial legislature.

In this, he was again successful. And while the socialists sought to smear him by association with disgraced predecessors, his followers eagerly anticipated an inevitable victory.

Gentle reader, you may think you’re reviewing the recent history of Jason Kenney. And you would be wrong.

This is the story of Elwin Hermanson, and the province was Saskatchewan. The time was the late 1990s.

As a former Reform MP, Mr. Hermanson would take his new party to election twice. He would lose to the NDP twice, under Roy Romanow and Lorne Calvert, albeit narrowly on both occasions.

In spite of his conservative credentials, he would be deemed as too extreme, too dangerous to the province, and would be forced in 2004 to give way to someone perceived as more moderate, more centrist.

And that was his end.

This endeth the lesson. John Ashton is a former NDP Caucus director. In case you’re thinking of calling or emailing, don’t bother. AlbertaPolitics.ca only publishes guest posts by people the proprietor knows and respects, and sometimes not even then. DJC

4 Comments to: Guest Post: Tales from the annals of inevitable right-wing political victories in Western Canada

  1. Simon Renouf

    October 27th, 2017

    Great post, John. When I was a boy, around the time it was published, that work by Boethius was entitled “The Consolation of Philosophy.” Or perhaps consternation.

    Reply
  2. David

    October 27th, 2017

    This is an interesting story, with some parallels to Alberta. Mr. Kenney could end up being the Alberta equivalent of Mr. Hermanson. Kenney certainly doesn’t have the folksy style of the more successful Mr. Wall.

    As we have also seen before in Alberta with Mr. Prentice, Unite the Right is not a fool proof mix. In order for it to work, it also needs a very appealing leader and policies that appeal to enough voters. I think the UCP in Alberta has serious problems in both areas.

    As the saying goes, those that do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.

    Reply
  3. Paul Zuck

    October 27th, 2017

    So Elwin Hermanson was left to commiserate via Facebook posts with recently retired Saskatchewan CON MP Gerry Ritz who no longer has time for EL as Ritz is busy cozying up to Ezra Levant and Rebel Media

    Reply
  4. Jack K

    October 28th, 2017

    Brad Wall won because he was more of a conservative, selling off wasteful spending crown corporations like STC for one. This is a lesson for whoever wins the UCP leadership – do not waver on your strong conservative principles or you will be unelected like red tories like Jim Prentice. Stay blue and win, go red and lose.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

  • (not be published)