It’s hard to know whether United Conservative Party’s school flagpole fiasco or its bizarre decision to dumb down high school graduation requirements better illustrates its modus operandi on education policy.

Alberta School Boards Association President Shali Baziuk (Photo: Canadian School Boards Association).

Either way, a picture emerges of ideologically motivated decisions made on the spur of the moment with little or no thought about the consequences.

As a result, such whimsically made decisions, even if insignificant in their own right, are doomed to become expensive failures – all the more so because the UCP will rarely admit to having failed at anything, thereby making it both difficult and even more expensive to remedy mistakes.

The revised flag regulation – probably first run up the pole by some bright spark during the leadup to Danielle Smith’s secession referendum on Oct. 19 – says that starting next fall all Alberta public schools must fly both Canada’s Maple Leaf Flag and Alberta’s pedestrian blue provincial banner, now forever tarnished as a symbol of separation, on separate flagpoles.

The government’s principal motivation, obviously, was to telegraph the party’s base that rainbow flags or any kind of acknowledgement of diversity would be henceforth and forevermore verboten – and you’d better not vote NDP or that could change the next morning! With a dash of lingering separatism tossed in for good measure.

Apparently, though, it didn’t occur to any of these brainiacs that flagpoles cost money – quite a bit of it, it turns out, in this inflationary era. Well, maybe the great minds of the UCP didn’t care, since they were bound to dump such expenses on school boards and local taxpayers anyway.

NDP Opposition Leader Naheed Nenshi (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

Still, with suggestions a single pole could cost something in the order of $10,000 to acquire and install, the Alberta School Boards Association phoned up the CBC to complain and ask the government to hold off on this dumb idea. “This would allow boards to continue responding to community needs while ensuring education resources remain focused on supporting students,” ASBA President Shali Baziuk told the CBC’s reporter.

So this nonsense has the theoretical potential to cost taxpayers as much as $27 million, assuming all the schools in the province have only a single pole. Hopefully some schools already have dual poles, or someone can come up with a cheaper flagpole. A news report Tuesday suggested the UCP might be willing to make some changes to the regulation, though it remains to be seen just what they might be.

Meanwhile, moving on to the matter of high school graduation requirements, voters should always be suspicious about what the UCP is up to when they promise students that a new policy will deliver “more choice and better prepare them for life after high school,” as the government’s news release put it on Friday the 13th.

“These changes will give students more choice to explore their interests, develop real-world skills and choose a path that prepares them for a career, post-secondary education and success in life,” chirped Education Minister Demetrios Nicolaides in the government’s news release.

Cutting to the chase, after Grade 10, students won’t need to take many boring old courses like math, sciences, English or social studies, which will be reduced to electives.

Alberta Teachers Association President Jason Schilling (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

But then, as Dr. Nicolaides explained, “the world students are graduating into has changed significantly over the past 30 years, and our graduation requirements need to keep pace.” Critical thinking? Between AI and the depredations of late capitalism, I guess it’s no longer required.

Apparently the government proposes to keep high school students busy instead by tripling the number of physical education classes. Characteristically, as NDP Opposition Leader Naheed Nenshi marvelled earlier this week, no one seems to have given any thought to where the money’s going to come from to triple the number of gyms.

“English language arts and social studies at the Grade 12 level are an integral part of Alberta’s high school graduation requirements,” said Alberta Teachers Association President Jason Schilling in a news release on the 13th. “Together, these subjects help students communicate effectively, evaluate information and understand different perspectives, preparing them not only for further education and employment but also to participate as informed citizens.”

“Removing these requirements risks leaving students less prepared for the opportunities and responsibilities ahead of them,” said the leader of the ATA, which the UCP distrusts both because it’s a union and because it represents pedagogical expertise. “Flexibility in course choices should expand students’ futures, not weaken the foundation they need in order to succeed.”

“Once again, the government is bringing forward a fundamental change to education on a Friday afternoon without meaningful consultation with education partners,” Mr. Schilling noted. (And a Friday, as it happened, that a lot of attention was being paid to some other stories.)

“Decisions with lasting consequences for students deserve an open, informed discussion before they are announced,” he continued. “The government needs to explain whose advice informed this proposal, what evidence supports it and how it has assessed the long-term implications for students’ access to further education, career opportunities and civic participation.”

Well, that’s true, but don’t expect anything like it to happen.

All that said, probably a little more thought went into the graduation decision than the one about the flagpoles. For one thing, as Dr. Nicolaides told reporters on Monday at the Legislature, the changes may discourage students from dropping out. So that, at least, should allow the government to post slightly better graduation statistics while decreasing the danger that a new cohort of voters will enter the workforce in possession of critical thinking skills.

In a statement on social media, Mr. Nenshi noted that “teachers have not been consulted, parents have not been consulted, students have not been consulted, educational experts have not been consulted.”

“So it’s fair to ask,” he continued, “who asked for this and why?”

“In a world where the nature of work is changing because of AI and automation, we’re telling students to take fewer STEM courses rather than more, fewer science and math courses? In a world where you need critical thinking skills more than ever, we’re telling students to take fewer English and social studies courses? You only need one diploma exam to graduate?”

“The UCP seems to think that public schools are factories for workers for jobs of the past,” Mr. Nenshi concluded, “instead of preparing students to be great citizens, and preparing students to be able to work in the workplaces of the future.”

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.