On Halloween, Premier Danielle Smith was caught on video musing about how Alberta is going to set up a northern version of Donald Trump’s so-called “Department of Government Efficiency,” or DOGE, run by the American president’s weirdo Svengali, the trillionaire man-child Elon Musk.

Never mind that DOGE is an obvious catastrophe for the United States, Ms. Smith’s ramblings on a far-right videocast about setting up an AI-driven cost-cutting initiative called Taxpayer Revenue and Cost Effectiveness, with TRACE for a cutesy acronym, prompted one of Postmedia’s stable of right-wing columnists to protest that the premier was almost sounding too MAGA to get re-elected.
Lay off the MAGA vibe, Lorne Gunter pleaded on Nov. 3. “If the premier has a political tin ear bad enough to think comparing her cost-cutting plan to DOGE is a good idea,” he wondered, “can we really rule out a made-in-Alberta ICE if she thinks that will appeal to her hardcore base?”
Of course we can’t. Indeed, what were her five Oct. 19 referendum questions on immigration but thinly veiled advocacy of that very same odious MAGA policy?
The chances Ms. Smith will pay any attention to Mr. Gunter’s counsel, of course, are essentially nil. Anyone who has listened to what Ms. Smith has to say when she is among friends, as well watched what she does, understands that there’s never been a MAGA policy she doesn’t want to imitate.
It’s important to add here that it doesn’t really matter if Ms. Smith is truly a deep believer in MAGA ideology, insofar as it deserves the dignity of such a description, or just a craven opportunist who advocates such policies to keep the UCP’s radicalized base in line. The impacts of her choices are the same. What’s more, we can be confident this nonsense isn’t going to go away after the UCP AGM ends on Nov. 29.

That said, it’s not entirely clear whether or not TRACE actually exists or was just a Danielle Smith hallucination summoned up to please her far-right audience. It’s not mentioned in the 2026 Alberta Budget.
Why bring this up now? Well, the DOGE disaster is on a lot of minds right now south of the Medicine Line, thanks to the mysterious Friday the 13th air-traffic-control “ground stop” that disrupted commercial air travel across the United States and for which a lot of explanations have been offered, none very convincing. A strand of copper wire?
But it’s hard to believe that the crude chainsaw cuts to the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration, driving experienced personnel out the door, didn’t play a significant role in this disaster.
Writing yesterday in his often sharply worded Substack column, Tufts University political scientist Daniel Drezner concluded from Friday’s air-travel chaos that “the more we learn about what DOGE hath wrought the bigger the shitstorm that emerges.”
Dr. Drezner’s analysis of the impact of DOGE is directly applicable to the magic MAGA mirror we must gaze into here in Alberta under the UCP with Ms. Smith at the party’s helm.

Under the headline, The Revenge of the Shallow State, Dr. Drezner continued: “A reformer genuinely interested in improving government efficiency would have found ways to eliminate cumbersome regulations while maintaining the workforce to adroitly administer the remaining rules and services,” he wrote. “DOGE did the exact opposite, firing employees without simplifying government tasks.”
The results are, he concluded, “kinda like a Bizarro second half of Atlas Shrugged. In this scenario, however, the country starts to fall apart because all the best government employees go away.”
Realistically, as the recent experience of the Unites States shows, this is a much more likely way to bring the American Union to its knees than what might happen if all the tech bros and billionaires suddenly bugged off to Galt’s dystopian Gulch.
Readers will recall that when answering questions about her government’s book ban polices in August 2025, Ms. Smith crankily suggested to a reporter that perhaps Alberta should consider making Ayn Rand’s notorious screed to greed “mandatory reading in high school.”
“Maybe, when you get to be in junior high or high school, the level of understanding about the concepts in there are absolutely appropriate for school children of that age,” Ms. Smith said, defiantly.
Concerned readers should note that Ms. Smith is not yet finished tinkering with Alberta’s once excellent public education system, always seeking MAGA-motivated ways to make it worse.
For readers fortunate enough to be unfamiliar with the late Ms. Rand’s tiresome doorstopper, here is the famous analysis of American screenwriter John Rogers: “There are two novels that can change a bookish fourteen-year old’s life: The Lord of the Rings and Atlas Shrugged. One is a childish fantasy that often engenders a lifelong obsession with its unbelievable heroes, leading to an emotionally stunted, socially crippled adulthood, unable to deal with the real world. The other, of course, involves orcs.”
Have no doubt, despite the AI hype, Ms. Smith’s instinct to imitate anything MAGA does ensures that TRACE – if, God forbid, this Muskian pipedream is ever realized – would suffer from exactly the same flaws as DOGE, only with the 21st Century version of the Nuremberg plea tacked on. No longer will it be, “I was only following orders,” but, “the AI made the decision.”
