Former Alberta Party leader Greg Clark is emerging as an effective opponent of the United Conservative Party’s plan to gerrymander Alberta electoral districts in a scheme to win the next general election in spite of growing voter disapproval.

UCP Government Whip Brandon Lunty is chair of the government-stacked committee expected to publish the UCP’s gerrymandering scheme next week (Photo: Facebook/ Brandon Lunty).

Mr. Clark, who served as Alberta Party MLA for Calgary-Elbow from 2015 to 2019, is ideally positioned for the role as a well-informed member of the 2025 Electoral Boundaries Commission, whose work was tossed out by the UCP last spring for being too fair, and because he is not associated with the Opposition NDP, so his objections cannot be dismissed as mere partisanship.

“Major changes to electoral boundaries mean the next battle is likely in court, and I don’t think anyone wants judges imposing new ridings,” Mr. Clark wrote on social media yesterday morning. “The govt can avoid this by implementing the majority maps from last spring, or simply adding two rural seats to that map.”

“In Canada, we don’t want elected officials drawing their own election maps,” he wrote as part of a thread on X last April soon after the UCP spiked the majority report of non-partisan Electoral Boundaries Commission, telegraphing the intention of the Danielle Smith Government to gerrymander urban and rural ridings to give itself an unfair edge in the next general election.

“Instead, governments give independent commissions the job of drawing maps that reflect population trends while also respecting the challenges of representing diverse, rural and remote communities,” Mr. Clark said in that post.

Well, the chances appear to be vanishingly small that the UCP will decide to do the right thing. While we won’t see the electoral maps ginned up by the UCP-stacked MLA electoral boundaries committee chaired by Leduc-Beaumont MLA and Chief Government Whip Brandon Lunty until Monday, it’s already becoming clear what we’re going to get.

NDP researcher Trevor Scott Howell (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

“Some pretty wild takeaways from today’s electoral boundaries committee meeting,” NDP researcher and former journalist Trevor Scott Howell posted on Wednesday. “Lethbridge would be split into FOUR ridings instead of its current two urban ones,” he wrote. “Three would combine city neighbourhoods with surrounding rural areas.”

“Three urban-rural hybrid ridings are proposed along Calgary’s northwest and western edges. Springbank gets split up,” he said, noting that the committee cites golf courses as logical riding boundaries. “Okotoks and Diamond Valley would be split apart, with Diamond Valley paired with Banff. The panel’s dissenting members say public submissions overwhelmingly favoured keeping them together.”

Mr. Howell goes on to say Calgary and Edmonton ridings would average 7,000 more residents per MLA than ridings outside those cities, a 14-per-cent difference. This kind of urban-rurban-rural gerrymandering, the UCP reasoning obviously goes, should prevent any more unexpected urban embarrassments like the Sept. 14 by-election victory of the Alberta NDP in the usually dependably Conservative Calgary-Shaw riding.

There’s more, but that gives a strong indicator of what were likely to see on Nov. 2.

Observed University of Alberta law and economics professor Andrew Leach on X Wednesday: “If it turns out that Edmonton and Calgary residents are under-represented vs the rest of Alberta by 14% (# of residents per seat), that’s far larger than the degree to which Alberta residents are under-represented relative to Quebeckers in the House of Commons.”

NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi warns that the Opposition party will go to court to block unconstitutional gerrymandering (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

For its part, though, the UCP strategic brain trust has obviously decided that it would have trouble winning another general election, but that’s not going to be a problem as long as they can get away with cheating.

A lot of Albertans – especially supporters of our MAGAfied provincial government – like to think of this province as Texas North. In reality, as I’ve often argued in this space, it’s closer to being a northern version of Oklahoma. Regardless, the UCP is obviously thinking, why not import Texas-style gerrymandering to win the 2027 election if they can’t win it honestly?

“UCP gives up on winning elections in Alberta,” wrote Deirdre Mitchell-MacLean in her Women of AB Poli Substack Wednesday. “That isn’t ‘strong and free,’ it’s weak and grasping.”

If the UCP proceeds with this scheme, it’s likely to quickly end up in court.

“This is Trump-style, MAGA-style gerrymandering,” Opposition NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi told a news conference on Wednesday. “We’ve never seen it in Canada before. And one of the reasons we haven’t seen it in Canada is because it’s probably unconstitutional.”

“We will absolutely take it to court,” Mr. Nenshi was quoted saying in a CBC story. “The Supreme Court, and various courts across Canada, have been really clear that U.S.-style gerrymandering is not constitutional in Canada.”

After the 2025 Electoral Boundaries Commission, led by retired Court of King’s Bench justice Dallas Miller, was established on March 25, 2025, it held more than 30 public hearings throughout Alberta, in person and online. It received close to 2,000 written submissions.

However, after supporting an interim report with a new electoral map, the two UCP-appointed members of the five-member commission came up with a minority report that would slice the province’s cities into pizza pies of “rurban” ridings, diluting the Opposition NDP’s vote.

The government then used that as an excuse to deep-six the commission’s majority report.

The three majority members of the 2025 Electoral Boundaries Commission warned that if the government were to implement the minority report, “it risks significant legal consequences by way of a court challenge that is likely to be successful. Even more importantly, it risks jeopardizing faith in Alberta democracy.”

It would be naïve, though, to imagine the UCP cares much about Albertans’ faith in democracy.

As Canadian-American conservative commentator and speech writer David Frum famously observed, “If conservatives become convinced that they cannot win democratically, they will not abandon conservatism. They will reject democracy.”

Join the Conversation

26 Comments

  1. A total lust for power. The UCP wants to rule in perpetuity. The courts should shoot this gerrymandering garbage down.

  2. The last provincial election was already uncomfortably close for the UCP. At that time Smith was running as a new candidate who could at least claim to try fix the problems that dogged her predecessor.

    This coming election she will have to defend her own record, which includes mamy problems such as with the health care system, both old ones that she has failed to fix and new ones she has created such as cozy deals with private vendors, unnecessary restructuring and so on. The separation referendum was mean to be a distraction from all this, but it is over now and has not turned out how many in the UCP wanted. Others are also upset how Smith handled it.

    You can see how we get to this point, where gerrymandering becomes the last refuge of scoundrels, like what was attempted in Texas and elsewhere in the US. A party that was more confident of staying in power wouldn’t need to go here. Smith and the UCP can feel their grip on things slipping away.

    The good news is this type of gerrymandering does not seem to be helping the party in power in the US, particularly as those people in areas that used to strongly support it are also starting to question its performance more. The battle of the maps is important, but the battle for the hearts and minds of Albertans is too. However, it is also good to have a credible person like Clark, who can be seen as non partisan, to raise this issue so it can’t be dismissed by Smith, who has a tendency to try gaslight us about things like this. She is trying to manipulate riding boundaries because she is desperate to win. It is certainly unfair, probably illegal and should be stopped.

  3. There just is not a single human I hate more than I loathe Daniel Smith and her crooked policies and seditious behaviour. I will be in one of those gerrymandered Calgary rural seats seats. I used to live in Calgary elbow. I haven’t moved in 33 years but here we are. When will the madness ever end?

    1. Alex: As a curiosity, during my family’s years in Calgary we lived in Calgary-Varsity, Calgary-Beddington and Calgary-North (if memory serves, three of ’em, anyway) without ever moving. Since I’ve lived in the little dormitory suburb of St. Alberta, I’ve been a resident of two ridings, one definitely rurbanized for gerrymandering purposes). TIA. DJC

      1. Is that Morinville-St.Albert, represented by the odious Dale Nally? I live there too.

        I’m astonished that this is getting so little news coverage and attention.

        Maybe everybody’s just exhausted by the referendum, but this is probably the scariest thing — on a long, long list of scary things — that Smith et all have done.

        Thomas Lukaszuk is floating the idea of a new political party, but I worry that it could split the NDP/anti-UCP vote.

    2. Not until we make it clear that the ongoing madness won’t be tolerated and we put in the work to get rid of Dani and the UCP ‼️

  4. Once again, Smith and the UPC demonstrate how short-sighted, ignorant and power hungry, they really are.

  5. What are progs to do once the Drumpfster finally fails to wake from one of his many nod-offs? How to carry on pretending that the stable genius is the at the root of nearly six decades of assault on the population in the imperial core by the rentier class? Lewis Powell issued his infamous manifesto in 1971 and the legati of the corporatocracy have been working their permanent revolution ever since. Progs will reject political democracy just as quickly as Kons if that is what is necessary to snuff out any whiff of economic democracy. Absurd allegations about the wicked Pewtins aside, the Democrats stole the nomination from Sanders and then promoted the Drumpf for free because in their deluded prog mental state, they believed that Hillary Clinton could defeat ol’ Grab ’em by the Kitty easier than she could Jeb “Swamp Trash” Bush. For all the claims of Russians warping people’s minds with Facebook posts, the Drumpf was promoted relentlessly by the prog media machine, in both traditional forms and in silica, allowing him to overcome Bush’s vastly superior war chest. Progs never seemed much bothered with the question of how the Drumpf managed to defeat the money in 2016 within the GOP. As far as democracy and reality-based programming goes in this province, the Neoliberal Deception Program is the Musical Ride on Unicorns.

  6. Elbows up moment of the day: “Canada lost 68,000 jobs in September, according to Statistics Canada, marking a second straight month of losses…Statistics Canada says job losses were split between full- and part-time work and were concentrated in the public sector, which dropped 70,000 roles in the month. The number of public sector employees is down by 119,000 compared to the same time last year.” That’s one scrumptious helping of austerity as we prepare for the last stand against Russia on the English Channel. Typically, the CBC goes to a broad spectrum of viewpoints, asking bankers from both BMO and CIBC what’s happening: “BMO chief economist Doug Porter said job figures are often volatile, and have been especially so in recent years. Still, he noted it’s rare to see two months in a row of job losses of this size.” No doubt, job figures are often volatile during a guns-for-butter military buildup. “CIBC senior economist Andrew Grantham says despite volatility playing a factor, the drop in the number of jobs will likely keep the Bank of Canada from making any interest rate moves in the near future.” Man, them bankers is some kind of smart!
    https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canada-jobs-numbers-september-2026-9.7375345

  7. In David’s October 27th column, he blamed the BC NDP’s recent election loss on calling the election early. Personally, I don’t think the loss was a result of going early, but rather it was voters feelt disgusted with the blatant political opportunism displayed by the NDP in calling the election right when the BC Conservatives were in turmoil. I am a progressive voter, but if I lived in BC I don’t know how I would vote. I suspect a lot of BC residents felt the same way, so they just stayed home on voting day. A CBC story after the election showed how vote for both the NDP and Conservatives was down from the previous election (some Conservatives also stayed home – did the Conservative follies that led up to the leader stepping down make them stay home too?). The NDP lost because more of their supporters did not show up.

    It is my hope that, if the gerrymandering we expect does come to pass, enough residents of the gerrymandered ridings who normally vote UCP will similarly be disgusted by the UCP shenanigans (on top of the other ones we have seen) and either vote against the government or just stay home.

    It will be interesting to see what the urban/rural split will be in the gerrymandered ridings. That is, which demographic will be the majority? If it is the urban segment, rural voters really should ask themselves how their new MLA, Jerry Mander, will act if their is an issue that pits urban against rural interests.

    1. My work has found me spending the majority of my time these days in Vancouver, including both pre and post election. The sense I get from even die-hard NDP supporters was that both frustration and fatigue for the Eby government had taken over, which led to its downfall. People didn’t vote for the Conservatives, they voted against the NDP. Once you lose the base, well….

      Alberta of course is a political anomaly. Time heals all wounds, and by the time of the next AB election my bet is the present dissatisfaction for the UCP will dissolve away and lead into yet another majority win for Fraulein Schmidt and her merry band of Brown Shirts.

  8. It’s so obvious that Danielle Smith doesn’t care about democracy. That’s why after getting a definitive referendum vote against separation, she’s giving the keynote speech on Halloween at a separatist fundraiser in Calgary. She also snubbed two federal invitations this week because she doesn’t care about getting a seat at the table. She wants to knock it over. She’s looking like the premier of Quebec.

    She’s also trying to get rid of federal pharmacare and dental care programs and take the money instead, in direct contradiction to the referendum vote by the people of Alberta, who said “no” to this idea.

    So how are things going in Texas?

    https://abc13.com/amp/post/female-voters-could-decide-tight-texas-midterm-races-experts-say/19996639/

    Smith’s so busy “protecting” women from sports, public washrooms and driver’s licences that she hasn’t noticed how angry she’s making them. Nothing is worse than a woman in sheep’s clothing.

  9. The smell of desperation surrounding the unhinged chaos party is transitioning from a localized funk to a pervasive miasma.

  10. It never ceases to amaze me to what lengths and how low and unethical the UCP will stoop to keep power. Smith has basically pissed off everyone and yet wants to twist things in her favor to maintain power. We all have what happens to those who stand in her way. Even though her referendumb was shot down she carries on as if it didn’t happen. Hopefully the UCP will self destruct from within.

  11. David Frum should know that the radicalized far-right has already abandoned conservatism —and that’s a significant reason why it has abandoned democracy—already.

    It’s a matter of course that the UCP would dive deep into gerrymandering because that’s what tRumpublican MAGA does and what the UCP copies, remarkably consistently and with, in my opinion, reckless psephological abandon. The (hopefully) delicious irony is that both kinds of MAGA are compelled to cheat electoral processes precisely because of their mutual psephological abandonment . The only way it’s logical is that these kissing cousins have already rejected democracy.

    They’ve been giving each other the tongue for some time now; I’m old enough to remember how traditional conservatives used to warn where “heavy petting” often leads—-although it’s hopeful that so far who, in the British sense of visiting, “knocks up” whom has remained as yet visits to Florida but not the other way around.

    Since aspired elopement is carefully timed ( at least diurnally) , it is illuminating to watch out for the most likely crescendos of partisan ardour to inform why certain business has to get done in a hurry. From the UCP point of view the approaching US midterms is critical: if, as it seems, tRump will be rendered a limped duck by Odin’s Day next, it will very probably by osmosis render UCP emulation of the presidunce’s dirty political pool a disgusting hot-tub God-fearing conservatives would want to leap out of and head straight for the showers for a thorough scrubbing. Oughtta be plenty a that after the approaching drubbing , and that even in the GOP’s best-case outcome.

    In any case, it’s gonna be near impossible to scrub contact-orange spray-tan off exposed skin before the UCP’s approaching AGM at the other end of November (which would have been the Ides of the ninth month in the Ancient Roman calendar). MAGA ardour is already slackening and if tRump loses Congress ( and the party a number of gubernatorial races) , the right’s tawdry love nest—already substantially demolished—will be drenched in something more than a lovers’ spat. After Danielle Smith’s tepid emulation of MAGA bigotry on half her recent referenda questions, and of course her total face-plant on the separation referendum part, they’s bound to be a right Donnybrook . On neither side of the border will mortifying riots of recrimination consider anything but their own fates, but assuredly nothing of the fate of our respective democracies.

    High above, surveying all, one can only conclude that Albertans did their beautiful province and world-envied country proud — and sure a lot weller ‘n’ my own province’s electoral misadventure last week (holy moly!)

    Heartfelt congratulations and appreciation, my Alberta compatriots! Don’t worry about us out to BC: David Eby just demonstrated that democracy is alive and well—-if not weller—-by handing Conservative premier-designate Lorne Doerkson a sackful of steaming-hot brown potatoes with which any association with tRumpublican MAGA over the next two years oughtta make some pretty fine dining.

    Thank you very , very much!!

  12. What could also dilute the vote is the formation of other right-of-centre and conservative political parties in Alberta. There appears to be indications that the “innards ” of the UCP are in disarray. Time will tell……

  13. The will reject democracy.
    Typo there, David.
    As this is the only worthwhile thing that Frum ever said, it’s important to quote it accurately.

    1. Two points:

      Wild tangent, but David Frum actually did say something worthwhile the night of the 2016 US election as part of the CBC panel. To paraphrase, he said people think that institutions will save them, but they don’t realize that those institutions are just people. That is kind of the story of Trump’s railroading of democracy, even if Frum was part of the Bush administration that laid the groundwork for it.

      On topic, Saskatchewan actually made the opposite change a few election cycles back. Both Saskatoon and Regina used to be cut into pies that radiated out into rural areas. Several of those former constituencies actually bordered on one another, even though Regina and Saskatoon are 270 km away from each other.

  14. So it has come to this. Do rural residents have any sense of fairness about equality of representation based on representation by population, as opposed to acres of land?

    If they do, then these voters will protest this piracy. If they do prefer to destroy democracy, then they will opt for these gerrymandering operations by Premier Slime Bucket. This they may do out of ignorance, or fear of the unknown.

    But better to challenge the entire operation in a court. It may be imperfect, but then as a certain person observed, only a sick person neeeds a lawyer, (like Danni) to set her straight. Democracy once lost is difficult to restore.

  15. Interesting Friday afternoon news dump; they are decreasing the education property tax rate, making Farkas happy. Are they looking to court Calgary voters now? Is this strategy in place of gerrymandering, or in addition to it?

    1. They loaded us up with $340MM increase and are giving $40MM of it back. And we’re supposed to feel good about it?

  16. Ha, just heard the end of the above presser, and Jeff Rath has been kicked out of the UCP. Smith says it’s not a separatist party.

  17. The Alberta NDP raised $155,427 more than the UCP in 2026 Q3. Another hopeful sign that the UCP will get the boot in next year’s election despite the electoral boundaries gerrymander.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.