Sunday morning, Mount Royal University Professor Duane Bratt took to the social media site previously known as Twitter to observe, “There has been some snap election speculation in Alberta (as there always is).”

Dr. Bratt, who is probably Alberta’s best known and most frequently quoted political scientist, went on to add, rhetorically, I presume, “Hopefully the events in BC show the risks in that strategy.”
The events in B.C. referenced by Dr. Bratt, in case any of you slept through the weekend, involved that province’s NDP premier, David Eby, foolishly having called an early election and paying a steep price for it at the polls on Saturday. A Conservative named Lorne Doerkson is now the premier-elect of our westernmost neighbour, and since I have paid very little attention to British Columbia politics for the past several years, I am going to resist the temptation to bloviate at length about how that may have come about.
Still, tired as we all have grown of Alberta Premier Danielle Smith’s separation neverendum and its collection of cartoon-like supporters, someone in a field like political science shouldn’t be hopeful that there won’t be a new political drama in our neighborhood. For those who must publish in order not to perish, topics for new scholarly papers should always be welcome.
Surprisingly, some commenters took issue with Dr. Bratt, pointing out that Alberta has a fixed election date enshrined in law. Alas, as we have already seen with Ms. Smith’s government, that doesn’t mean very much. This is especially true, now that we Albertans are staying in Canada, in a Parliamentary system required by the nation’s fundamental law to have “a Constitution similar in Principle to that of the United Kingdom.” (It was written in the 19th Century, so of course they capitalized every third word or so.)
That means, as Dr. Bratt patiently pointed out to one of his critics, “Alberta has a fixed election law which is meaningless to prevent a snap election.” What’s more, he continued with another argumentative tweeter, Alberta’s legislation is “a law which says that the election date is fixed but nothing precludes the LG from calling an election. Either because the govt lost a confidence vote or based on the advice of the Premier. We had a similar law when Prentice went early in 2015.”

Indeed we did, and that is something with which Premier Smith should be familiar, even if she happened to sleep through the events in British Columbia over the weekend. After all, as the floor-crossing leader of the Wildrose Opposition in 2014, she played a key role in the circumstances that led to premier Jim Prentice’s disastrous early election call in 2015.
That, in turn, resulted in the election of an NDP majority government led by Rachel Notley, something that came as a surprise of virtually everyone in Alberta, including the NDP.
British Columbia also had a fixed-election date law at the very moment Mr. Eby asked the Lieutenant-Governor of that province to call an unfixed election, thereby unmooring his NDP from government two years before he was required to do so.
Despite all this history, I can confirm that I too have heard the buzz Dr. Bratt referenced, although it might have been better described as a low hum.
It does seem apparent, as Dr. Bratt suggested, that an early election in Alberta would be an extremely bad idea for Ms. Smith’s government just as it was for Mr. Eby’s, notwithstanding their ideological differences.

It could also be argued, though, that Ms. Smith would have a slightly better reason, given the need to heal the rifts in her own ruling coalition caused by the recent referendum campaign and her sinking personal approval levels. An early election just might be the Hail Mary pass that could unite her fractious supporters and nail down another mandate now that she’s just blown to smithereens the one she was trying to get by using a referendum.
Premier-elect Doerkson has reportedly promised that one of the first telephone calls he makes after being sworn in will be to Premier Smith to tell her that he supports the Pacific Link Pipeline project.
Pipeline supporters in Alberta are entitled to take hope from this, but it pays to remember we live in an era when politics is no longer the art of the possible, but the art of the confrontational. It is not difficult, therefore, to imagine a scenario in which, given the makeup of his party and caucus, Mr. Doerkson might be tempted to pick a fight with First Nations over treaty negotiations about B.C.’s vast swathes of unceded territory.

As Vancouver-based economist Jim Stanford observed on social media Sunday, “The BC NDP govt supported the pipeline (since a big quid pro quo deal with Ottawa in July). First Nations are the most consequential opponent. The new Conservative govt’s attacks on DRIPA & other Indigenous issues make a deal with them less likely.”
It would be ironic indeed if the election in British Columbia of a government on the same ideological wavelength as Alberta’s UCP resulted in a situation that led to the demise of the Pacific Link plan.
If nothing else, this should be a reminder to those in UCP circles who have grown impatient with long-ago-established Treaty obligations, that there are advantages to the fact all of us here in Alberta live on Treaty land, where the pathway to agreements is settled, even where that presents a legal risk to a government’s policy.
For her part, Premier Smith was apparently too busy to attend the historic meeting of Canadian first ministers and First Nations leaders in Ottawa yesterday.
The Canadian Press reported Sunday that Alberta’s premier “said she will not be attending because the meeting overlaps with the resumption of question period in her province as well as the aftermath of a historic referendum on separation.”
That statement may be half true. After all, Ms. Smith does have work cut out for her to repair the crumbling UCP coalition in the face of her foolish referendum. However, she certainly hasn’t been unwilling in the past to head to another jurisdiction to evade difficult questions in QP. As we say here in Alberta, when the going gets tough, the tough get out of town.

I’ll leave the last Alberta word on B.C.’s election to former Alberta NDP leader Brian Mason, an experienced politician who is in retirement a permanent resident of the beautiful Okanagan Valley.
“I said at the outset that David Eby was running a big risk by calling an election half way through his term,” Mr. Mason wrote on Facebook not long before the polls closed.
“Eby has shown bad political judgement throughout his Premiership,” Mr. Mason continued, “including the hard drug policy, wanting to scale back DRIPA, support for Carney and Smith’s pipeline, and ultimately calling a snap election that nobody wanted.
“Many excellent NDP projects remain incomplete, affordable child care being the most obvious example. Now we face a Conservative government that will inevitably roll back many of the gains made by the NDP over the years.”
Mr. Mason summed up: “I’m pretty discouraged by the B.C. NDP to say the least. And don’t get me started on the NDP in Alberta and Nenshi’s liberal party. I still have high hopes for Avi Lewis and the federal party though. We will see. But from now on, my support for the NDP will no longer be automatic. They will need to win it each time. They can start by electing a new and progressive leader in B.C.”
I’m sure a lot of New Democrats in British Columbia feel the same way. Good luck to them with that.

I also doubt that Smith is planning an early election, particularly after what just happened in BC. This may have reminded her of the 2015 PC debacle in Alberta as well, which she had a supporting role in, although not the main deciding one.
Of course the timing may not be up to her, she already lost 1 MLA and there are rumours there could be more. It is probably one reason, maybe the reason, why she was sticking so close to home today rather than going to the First Ministers and First Nations meeting.
I don’t know if Smith would be punished as harshly if she called a spring election rather than a fall one, as perhaps it would be close enough. However, it could also be a sign she was not confident in waiting until the fixed date.
In any event, I also agree with Mr. Mason’s assessment of the timing of the too early BC election and feel it was actually shared by many in the NDP there. If only it was listened to. At least I hope the new Premier’s somewhat moderate style so far will prove to be accurate and carry through in how he approaches relationships with First Nations in BC, rather than following some things said by others in his party. This would be better for Alberta and Canada as well.
No matter how you look at it, Danielle Smith will not endure a full term as premier of Alberta. The separatists avowed to have her turfed. It’s their revenge for her betraying them. With the UCP, they also will not last. So many Albertans are not too happy with the UCP, and you can’t blame them. Next door, in British Columbia, they elected more pseudo Conservatives and Reformers, and they will end up being very sorry for that big mistake. They didn’t learn from the major mistakes of Gordon Campbell and Christy Clarke, who had to use the Liberal name, because if they called themselves Conservatives, they would have faced defeat. Premier David Eby took a foolish gamble, and the voters there who bothered to vote, didn’t like an early provincial election. Now they have to live with the consequences of these pseudo Conservatives and Reformers. In Alberta, if the Lt. Governor doesn’t like what the UCP is doing, they may dissolve the provincial government, and force a provincial election. If they don’t, time is still running out for the UCP and Danielle Smith.
Dave, I’m hesitant to offer corrections where non-words are concerned, but shouldn’t ‘nevendum’ be ‘neverendum’?
Jim: Yes, it should … and now is. Thanks. DJC
I suspect that the “at” in the “That means, at Dr. Bratt” also needs a little ‘DJC’ love.
John: Fixed. Thanks. DJC
Smith is now talking about another referendum next year, possible topics including bike lanes, photo radar, infills and MAID. Sure – waste more or our $$ and time for your direct “democracy” Smith, the one just weeks ago was SO popular that we are all sickened by it
Break out the Cheezies! MLA Shane Getson has resigned, effective immediately. MLA Jason Stephan has announced that he will not run in the next election. One out, another with one foot out the door.
How many more separatist and separatist-adjacent UCP MLAs will quit? Will Danielle Smith call a by-election for Getson’s former seat? Will the dominos continue to fall? Will she be forced into calling a snap election by her own caucus?
A few days ago I thought she’d stick around for maximum havoc and revenge on the people of Alberta who failed to support her referendum. It might be out of her hands. The supposed plot to toss her by separatists in UCP constituency associations might not matter. Apparently the chief seppie has made up with his ill-wishers. United the right is.
Wait and see. Her referendum handed the answer key to flipping constituencies to the NDP, who won the Calgary-Shaw by-election last month. They know where the weak spots are. Maximum gerrymandering of electoral boundaries and who knows what other tinkering is expected soon. She holds the cards unless her caucus revolts.
I am still of the opinion, that Nenshi and Pancholi need to switch roles. Also, I am concerned with the Cons in B.C., cutting red tape and plowing ahead, with forestry, mining and gas. I understand the need for financial growth, but at what cost? There are a number of endangered species in B.C. that rely on old growth forests. How are the B.C. Cons going to balance the environment and industry? Are they going to take a page from the Alberta UPC and charge ahead and destroy everything that gets in their way, or are they going to be smart about it? I guess time will tell.
I fully expect an vote in the next 6 months. Earlier if Smith thinks it’s her only option to shake loose her seperatists; later if they punt her and the new fool goes for another referendum.
One of the great mysteries of politics. Why do people, in large numbers, vote against their best interests? BC voters will be paying a high price for their choice last week.
Hello DJC and fellow commenters,
I would say that Duane Bratt in this instance is the master of understatement. And, is she kidding, Premier Smith caring about question period? She, like so many Con politicians, seems to think that First Nations don’t matter at all. Although, come to think of it, P M Carney doesn’t seem to think they do either.
Will newly minted Premier Lorne Doerkson care about species at risk or the risks of indiscriminate logging, including logging of actual old growth, which was permitted by former Premier David Eby’s government, or any other environmental issue? All designed to make money, uncaring of the actual results. I would guess that Premier Doerkson doesn’t care either.
At least Lula da Silva who was re-elected president in Brazil, will, hopefully, be able to prevent some of the worst environmental excesses that Bolsonaro jr, presidential hopeful now defeated, would have perpetrated on the Amazon and its peoples.
I don’t under why we all can’t just get along the way we did before all this confrontational business. I miss the days, before all this divisiveness, when a great man like Ralph Klein could just demolish aspects of the Welfare State, or Brian “Don’t Mind if I Do” Mulroney could hand the country to international finance in the name of free trade, and people happily bent over, grabbed their ankles, took a deep breath and said, “I love you too’. Those were heady days, vastly better than the era in which working class people actually clashed with the rentier class that owns them. First Nations folks are lucky to have to these treaties that enshrine the rights of the Bank of Montreal to drive them onto tiny, remote pockets of land while stealing the rest for capitalism. Prog World is just like Care-a-lot, land of the Care Bears. I hope I run into Tyler Shandro or Jeremy Nixon on the street so that we can have big hugs!
Murphy: You should get together with B Burnsides and chat! DJC
Just think. Canada has abandoned reasonable trade talks with the U.S. and an upwardly growing economy simply to join the Islam-ridden, downward spiraling, financially strapped EU. Little man’s complex, b.s. artist and economics-incompetent Mark Carney is leading the country into a major depression from which it will NEVER recover. That’s what we get for putting an idiot in charge, going “elbows up” and thumbing our noses at the U.S.
B: You should get together with Murphy and chat! DJC
;o}
Thanks, DJC. Nice guffaw there for me. ;o}
It was refreshing to get Brian Mason’s wise perspective on the BC election. Like for him, my support for the NDP has to be earned. As the provincial sections are now mostly a de facto farm team for the federal Liberals, I’m happy to divert my financial support to the federal party and the BC Greens, whose leader actually sounds like a New Democrat!
Ironically the Alberta NDP is, I think, the victim of its own success. Thanks to Rachel Notley and her team it was seen by others as a possible path to power where before they had none.
In her farewell speech Rachel said that her legacy would be that Alberta is now a two-party state. But there’s a vast difference between being a government in waiting, as the NDP should be, and the eternal opposition, a foil for the natural governing party, as conservatives like to see themselves.
I’d like to see the NDP stop waiting for Danielle Smith to do something outrageous that will cause voters to reject her with disgust. It doesn’t work. Smith has normalized outrageous. Like the whole referendum thing. The outcome could not be any clearer, the NDP was on the right side of the question and yet at the end of the day they are not the triumphant heroes. I’d like the NDP to be the heroes of health care, fighting the UCP in the courts and in the streets. I’d like to see the NDP embracing hospitals. Forget Question Period.
The most recent provincial election was on May 29, 2023. So holding an election in spring 2027 isn’t early. It’s more in keeping with a four year election cycle than waiting until October 2027.
John: My point was that the premier had her government change the date, to deal with the exigencies of the day. DJC
Constitutionally, the maximum life of a Parliament or a provincial legislature in this country is five (5) years. See Part I, Section 4(1) of the Constitution Act, 1982, and Section 50 of the Constitution Act, 1867.
But the convention that a majority government should serve about four years before once again going to the people has evolved, albeit with quite inconsistent application, some decades ago, since the end of the Second World War. In fact, governments that have sought to continue to the five-year mark have often gone down to defeat — such as Pierre Trudeau’s, 1974-79, and Brian Mulroney’s, 1988-1993.
But going early, in the absence of a legislative defeat on a confidence matter, seems to rewarded by the voters as often as it is punished. Look at Doug Ford in Ontario, for example, who in February 2025 called an early election only three years into his mandate, and won a strong majority government.
https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/const/page-12.html
However, David Eby’s writ after only two years seems to have been a writ too far.
I suppose, given the slimness of his majority, he could have engineered a defeat in the House instead — although that would have taken too long — or he could have dropped the writ even a week earlier and campaigned against the odious KLF.
But once she self-defenestrated from the BC Con leadership, the iron had already been plunged into cold water, and striking it would only have given one a sore arm. He should have waited.
Apparently the BC Cons have come up with all sorts of idiotic bills in the past including one declaring March 11 Freedom Convoy Day which passed first reading.
Are they capable of governing like grownups?
Probably not. DJC
With the tide turning against Queen Danielle’s continued premiership, she may just threaten the nuclear option of a snap election. After she had a mandate to yaada yaada yaada.
But this is the nonsense that Alberta is headed for. So, Smith will just go the voter and say help me keep the UCP a federalist party. Funny this is that the UCP is overwhelmingly separatist, so I don’t think they are inclined to change their collective minds on that issue. And since the UCP membership are largely in the End Times camp, I suspect many are inclined to force the issue and await divine judgment, operating under the weird belief that Jesus will manifest the Alberta republic in his image…so sayeth the Lord.
He came, he saw, he squandered
or as Eby himself might say:
Veni, vidi, perdidi