This is a frenzied moment for Danielle Smith and her United Conservative cabinet and caucus as they attempt to pacify the party’s influential and unhappy separatist faction and distract from both the failure of the separation referendum that for months the premier did everything she could to enable and the metastasizing health care corruption scandal that appears to be back on the front burner again.

UCP Red Deer-South MLA Jason Stephan, who won’t be seeking re-election in the next provincial election, with separatist leader Keith Wilson, who doesn’t want separatist UCP members to try to skid Premier Smith (Photo: Facebook/Jason Stephan).

Accordingly, there have been so many performative announcements to distract voters, keep rebellious MLAs in line, and shore up the party base that at times it appears to be an exercise in throwing spaghetti at a wall to see what sticks. From the look of it, at least some has.

At any rate, Ms. Smith and her allies in the party appear to have fended off an attempt by separatist cadres to take over the UCP’s elected administrative positions by requiring all candidates for the party board at next month’s annual general meeting to sign a loyalty oath to the leader before they can run.

OK, it’s not an oath. It’s just a declaration. But seriously, potayto-potahto.

Ms. Smith’s wrathful intramural archfoe, separatist leader and UCP member Jeffrey Rath, circulated a copy of the form on the social media site previously known as Twitter. The pledge states that the signer acknowledges they understand the party’s returning officer “will not certify me as a Candidate” unless they agree to abide by the decision of voters for Alberta to remain in Canada.

Last night, The Globe and Mail reported that UCP President Rob Smith sent an email to party members stating that “there will be NO UCP leadership review before our next general election.” He also said at least 65 of 87 UCP constituency associations have passed motions stating their loyalty to the premier.

Lac. Ste. Anne-Parkland UCP MLA Shane Getson, who is quitting immediately (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

That “at least” from the Globe’s report is doing a lot of work, seeing as a minimum of 22 CA votes are required to force a leadership review. Five CAs are known to have voted for a leadership review. So don’t bet against the possibility that a couple more pledges will have been signed by the close of business today.

So, no separatist takeover and no leadership review.

Meanwhile, a couple of separatism tinged UCP MLAs also appear to have been persuaded to walk the plank. Leastways, Red Deer-South MLA Jason Stephan, who had admitted he voted for Option 2 in the premier’s separatist referendum, the let’s-have-a-binding-vote option, announced last week he wouldn’t be seeking re-election.

And yesterday, Lac. Ste. Anne-Parkland MLA Shane Getson, a Convoy supporter and COVID skeptic, announced he was quitting immediately for personal and family reasons. He too hadn’t been planning to run again, but for some reason accelerated his departure schedule.

With a provincial election scheduled next year, a by-election in the riding won’t be required by law, but this does give the premier an opportunity to call one in a constituency northwest of Edmonton that is unlikely to elect a New Democrat.

Energy Minister Brian Jean, who has a walk-on role in this story (Photo: Alberta Government/Flickr).

On Monday, the premier and Energy Minister Brian Jean published a joint statement demanding that Ottawa repeal the Oil Tanker Moratorium Act. “Repealing the ban would open the door to crude-by-rail exports through Prince Rupert, giving Alberta another route to reach customers around the world,” the statement says, side-stepping the UCP’s real goal of getting a pipeline to the North Coast approved.

This was timed to coincide with the introduction in Parliament today of a Conservative MP’s Private Member’s bill calling for the same thing. But it clearly picks up on the election of a Conservative government likely to be more sympathetic to pipeline development in British Columbia on Saturday.

The federal Liberals will probably be more cautious, since they appear to actually want to get oil flowing through B.C. and not just pick a needless fight with some of the First Nations Ms. Smith snubbed on Monday by not attending the historic Ottawa meeting of first ministers and First Nations leaders.

Wrathful separatist leader Jeffrey Rath, who is going to have trouble skidding Ms. Smith now (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

Meanwhile, yesterday, it was time for the UCP to announce it will declare culture war on what the political right likes to call Diversity, Equity and Inclusion policies. This will be done to ensure white guys who already hold all the advantages get preferential treatment when it comes to being hired for public sector jobs. Or, as the government described that concept in its news release, “to ensure hiring and promotion decisions in public institutions are based on merit.”

The legislation proposes that the enforcement of these “fairness” rules – which we all understand are not intended to be fair in practice – will be enforced by the province’s Human Rights Commission, which in future will presumably therefore need to be printed in scare quotes and preceded by the words “so-called.”

If this reminds you of the Trump Administration’s use of U.S. civil rights legislation to target legal protections against discrimination and promote bogus claims of “reverse discrimination” against white bros, there’s probably a pretty good reason for that.

This policy is part of a broader attack by the political right on social justice research and programs that include social justice education in the academy.

We can expect more of the same as soon, as the UCP will now need to scramble to distract from the latest reports in The Globe and Mail about corruption in health care procurement.

In stories yesterday, the Globe reported that the RCMP is investigating “fraud, breach of trust and money laundering” in its probe into the procurement scandal, and that Premier Smith is determined to prevent a real judge-led public inquiry into the circumstances.

The information seems to have come to light in a letter filed by lawyers for former Alberta Health Services CEO Athana Mentzelopoulos, who was fired last year when she tried to investigate political interference and dodgy contracts in procurement work at AHS and is now suing for $1.7 million in damages for wrongful dismissal.

The premier argues that there has already been a judge-led public inquiry, the only problems with that being that the judge in question had retired and lacked any power to compel testimony, and most of his work wasn’t conducted in public.

Indeed, in his report, Raymond Wyant, late of the Manitoba Provincial Court, said he was unable to clear the government of any wrongdoing.

NOTE: This story has been updated to fix a few typos and clarify a couple of passages. DJC

Join the Conversation

20 Comments

  1. If you have to get to the point of having people sign loyalty oaths or declarations, that is not a good sign. If the intention was to get rid of the separatists, it seems to just driven some of them underground for now while they stubbornly stay in the UCP, but perhaps that was all Smith wanted or could hope for. It also doesn’t sound like the still vocal Rath is going away, although for whatever reasons two MLAs are. So the resistance or whatever they will call themselves continues.

    A bigger problem may be the health care scandals Smith tried to distract us from, with months and months of referendum talk, have not gone away and are popping up again at this inopportune time. So the spaghetti on the wall approach is a culture wars smorgasbord from anti DEI initiatives to talk about bathrooms again and the tanker ban.

    The latter seems to be coordinated with the CPC, but too much red meat is what got the BC Conservatives in trouble before and their new Premier doesn’t seem keen on talking about the tanker ban as he tries to focus on governing.

    It feels like the UCP is trying to recreate a MAGA convention in Texas. However, I doubt there will be as much enthusiasm for Smith as the separatists show up with their fingers crossed behind their backs and their signed forms regardless. I also don’t feel this will appeal much to any more moderate members left.

  2. This DEI stand by the UPC, just re-enforces my opinion that, Smith and the UPC are racist and race entitled. “fight for those, without your privilege.” A sticker, that I saw at a store. Smith and her team, need to be investigated by the RCMP, because they can’t be trusted with our Public healthcare, it’s too big of a money grab, for them to ignore. And with our public education system, screaming for assistance, we have Smith and the UPC giving private schools 26 mil., to expand. Why? Lastly, I honestly have more respect, for the rats jumping ship, than the simps signing their declaration of love, to a leader and a party that needs to be tossed and tossed quickly.

  3. Progs playing along with the culture war scam. White guys don’t hold all the advantages, capitalists do. The Great Substition is the swapping out of class war for identitarian nonsense. White guys wouldn’t have advantages over people of colour if capitalism didn’t pillage the places where brown and yellow men and women live. Immigration wouldn’t be a thing because the former(?) colonial possessions would be developed rather than plundered for all manner of capital, including the human variety. Progs seem to miss the point that capitalists don’t have to apply for jobs in the Master/servant common law scenario. Immigration is a capitalist, imperialist and colonial phenomenon. That’s how the pre-European-contact residents of Canada lost their land. There was no reformation of the fundamental nature of the phenomenon. Women, whether teal, mauve or fluorescent yellow wouldn’t be subjugated if the basis of power wasn’t exclusionary property laws. Why do you think the greatest export of the Philippines is humanity and the greatest source of their GDP is remittances from overseas workers? Silly ol’ progs, still peddling capitalist nonsense.

  4. David, you’ve assembled a remarkable set of photos in this piece!

    The majority of these guys look like members of a distinctive physiognomic type. I’m struggling for a suitable name, but perhaps we can use ARWG (Alberta Right Wing Goon) as a placeholder for now.

  5. This one just can’t be let alone. No more stark example of White Privilege exists than the Home Children. All those starving and illiterate waifs in London and Liverpool, scheming with their partners at Barclays Bank to get to the colonies and assume their places as the rightful masters of the land. As a boy, I revelled in the tale of my great, great grandfather arriving at 14 with his younger brother in tow from Bedfordshire and being handed their special Future White Man package of Bank of Montreal shares and sack of gold coins.

    1. Murphy, maybe toss your word salad once again, and perhaps it will land in a more intelligible form.

  6. The lies and hypocrisy are astonishing. “The bill covers public agencies, Crown corporations, post-secondary schools, school boards and municipalities. However, government officials said provincial employees are already hired based on merit.”

    And what “merits”, exactly, did Sam Mraiche’s relatives have when they were hired by our provincial government.

    This quote is from Peter Guthrie who was certainly up front and personal with Smith’s style of operation , “A fun fact: Companies associated with the Mraiche family continue to bid on Alberta government contracts including Health, while relatives of that same family continue to work in government ministerial offices—offices where staffing decisions are ultimately made under the authority of the Premier and the Premier’s Chief of Staff. Those facts raise legitimate questions about the adequacy of conflict-of-interest safeguards and the public’s confidence in the integrity of Government decision-making.”

    Naheed Nenshi asked Smith in the Legislature why she hired FIVE of Sam Mraiche’s relatives into the provincial government. (SIX he said, if you count Micky Amery). Smith muttered something, something, about listening to the “business community” blah, blah, threw in the word “Muslim” .. and that was it. Not only did she not answer the question she acted so indignant about it! The clip is on The Breakdown, but probably elsewhere, too. The corruption is so in-our-faces. And they are pilloring Athena Mentzelopoulos because she couldn’t look the other way. That woman deserves a medal. And thank God for the Globe and Mail reporters for bringing all this to the public eye. If the Mounties don’t “get their man” after all this we are in so much trouble. The Land of the Lawless.

  7. Uhhh, wasn’t the sane NDP government excoriated by Alberta’s Maple MAGAs for oil by rail plans? Something is seriously wrong with modern conservatives.

    1. CX: Well, they are inconsistent, but, as they might say, that was then and this is now. DJC

  8. As for Smith and the Seppies (lol … bad 60’s band name), well math is hard for Alberta conservatives. 4 of 22 required associations (2 in Calgary, High River, and Bonnyville) on the record calling for review of her vs a “claim” that 65 of 87 support her. We’ll see over the next 5 weeks whom is FOS.

    One thing I am sure of – Smith won’t punt anyone out of caucus. Her majority is razor thin, 46 of 87. Hmm, wait a minute, math is hard for Alberta conservatives … but Seppies might welcome the chance at a non-confidence vote.

  9. So Danielle Smith is wasting another $26 million on creating another 5 private schools but can’t be bothered with helping our public schools with sufficient schools to house our Public School System.
    That’s exactly why us true conservatives refused to support her as leader of the Wildrose Party we knew she was all about privatizing our healthcare and education systems and that’s what she is doing.

  10. With the referendumb questions behind them, it looks like the UCP is following the aphorism attributed to W.C. Fields, “”If you can’t dazzle them with brilliance, baffle them with bulls**t”. I guess we can look forward to multiple press conferences announcing strategies and strongly worded statements to solve the great challenges of 2026 (DEI, reverse discrimination, bathroom access). Meanwhile, let’s sweep those other distractions (health care procurement, relations with First Nations, the Animal Farm like “AI Data Centres good, solar panels and wind turbines bad” messaging, gerrymandering of ridings, cost of car insurance) under the rug. While Ms. Smith is too busy to attend a first ministers and First Nations leaders’ meeting, she will find time to immediately schedule a by-election in Mr. Getson’s riding. Representation is important don’t you know (past behaviours notwithstanding).

    On a side note DJC, I do appreciate you taking the time and effort to sprinkle photos (many taken by you) throughout your blog posts. For the one of Mr. Stephan, as per the attribution, he willingly posted that one on social media himself. Looking at the photo, and Mr. Stephan’s get up, he is really bottoming out.

    1. Thanks regarding the photos, Dave. I first worked in 1973 for a daily newspaper, the Victoria Daily Times. Or maybe it was 1972. Whatever, at that time, it was assumed that people reading about someone in the news would like to know what they looked like. I assume that is still the case and try to oblige. It was also an opportunity for a certain amount of editorial mischief, such as that presented by the picture of the two great separatists. A few years before, “Flying Phil” Gaglardi of Kamloops had served as B.C.’s minister of highways. He was known for frequently exceeding the speed limit. Accordingly, whenever he was mentioned in print in that context, a Vancouver Sun photo of him in a helmet and the seat of a racing car was always used as his thumbnail mugshot. That photo can be found here: https://vancouversun.com/news/local-news/this-week-in-history-1956-flying-phil-gaglardi-shows-off-his-highway-program One has the feeling that photo of Messrs. Stephan and Wilson will prove to have similar utility. DJC

  11. Really think that hiring should be done on attributes only
    list the duties
    respond with experience
    and leave all the color, gender issues, religious , handicapped, religious crap etc. out of it.
    Make it blind to everything but ability
    hire a savant if he can sort all the mail in a timely manner
    or a guy in a furry costume if he can dig the ditch you want

  12. Ugh, Danielle. If pledging one’s allegiance to Canada was so damn important, it would have been required before the results of the referendum. What a brazen, self-interested opportunist.

  13. I always wonder how true, to the core, hardcore ranchers feel about politicians making their working lifestyle nothing more than a cosplay costume choice. And now that the world is witnessing the unraveling of history’s greatest global empire due to the privatization of all things society needs, that means by 2160 all Canadians should be able to figure out it’s actually not a good idea. Just 123 years to go and we’ll be all over it.

  14. Well well, Rath’s 15 minutes are expiring; Smith had enough party executive support to revoke his membership. Who’s next? Sylvestre? Parker?

  15. So-called “merit” hiring also cuts the legs out of the concept of seniority, which is a common and objective criterion applied in many unionized environments.

    “Merit”, being subjective, leaves open opportunity for all sorts of mischief, like nepotism, cronyism, and hiring or promoting only a$$-kissing sycophants that won’t challenge their managers.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.