This blog marks the beginning of its 18th year of publication today.

Your blogger, in his favourite hat, as portrayed by Ryn Climenhaga in the style of Ralph Steadman (Image: Ryn R. Climenhaga).

That, as I observed last year on this date, makes it something of an institution in Alberta political commentary. 

That post wasn’t a bad piece, if I may say so myself, and the questions I was entertaining about revenue and the most appropriate platform for political commentary in the form of old-fashioned newspaper columns that would be at home in the age of lead type and printer’s ink remain largely unchanged and largely unanswered. So here’s a link

On a positive note, if I got anything wrong in last year’s Dec. 27 post, it was my gloomy prediction about the ability of the social networking site known as Bluesky to deliver readers. A mass migration of Twitter users to Bluesky during the week after the U.S. election, and the kindness of strangers who added my account to a couple of lists of Canadian commentators worth following, resulted in a much larger number of followers in a much shorter period of time than I expected. 

Unlike Twitter, Bluesky does not seem to throttle progressive opinions – not yet, anyway – so the number of readers who now come to AlbertaPolitics.ca through that site is also higher than expected. For that reason, I do urge readers who enjoy this blog to follow me there – I can be found at (@djclimenhaga.bsky.social).

Of course, more than my number of Bluesky followers changed as a result of the U.S. presidential election. As Andrew Coyne of The Globe and Mail put it in what has to be the gloomiest column of all on this topic, “we are living in the time of Nero” and “all of this will wash over Canada in various ways.” (Spoiler alert: None of them good.)

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, soon on her way to Washington to pay obeisance to the Don (Photo: Alberta Newsroom/Flickr).

Indeed, our little Nero in Alberta has been emboldened by Donald Trump’s victory and she will be off to Washington next month for the Big Nero’s inauguration, to which, the U.S.-owned National Pest has informed us in breathless and awe-inspired tones, “Premier Danielle Smith has scored tickets” … “thanks to Alberta’s trade office in Washington.” (So I guess that means we, fellow Alberta taxpayers, will be paying for them.) 

Perhaps as the premier says, she will have an opportunity to meet “energy groups, congresspeople, and various officials” and, as she surely plans, further undermine the Team Canada response to the new old U.S. president’s zero-sum approach to trade. That would be on-brand for Ms. Smith, whose loyalty to the neoliberal internationale apparently leaves no room for loyalty to Canada. 

Regardless of whom she manages to meet, we have already seen the inspiration of the first Trump “revolution” in how Alberta politics are practiced – from open red-baiting on social media, to the promotion of hatred for political opponents, lawfare against critics, and of course to the government’s glib official gaslighting.

From the perspective of any independent commentator, just keeping up with the stream of tendentious announcements from Ms. Smith’s United Conservative Party Government, and hopefully providing some worthwhile analysis, becomes a problem.

Who has time to analyze and deconstruct individual announcements as the sheer volume of misleading, contradictory and deceptive official statements continues to flood the zone on an almost daily basis? What’s left of media could, but mostly doesn’t. The Opposition in the Legislature could. But so far mostly won’t. 

Globe and Mail columnist Andrew Coyne – why didn’t he say Caligula, one wonders? (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

Example: the government assures us in a press release that Calgary’s Green Line LRT is “back on track.” Well, not really. Actually, the UCP appears to be trying to blackmail Calgary City Council into accepting an opaque, more expensive, shorter, and still incomplete version of project that will take years longer to build. Who benefits? 

Another presser says “Alberta’s government is putting the environment first with the Alberta Coal Industry Modernization Initiative.” It sure looks, though, as if this is just an effort to provide some green cover to the Grassy Mountain open pit coal mine in the Crowsnest Pass the UCP is determined to permit. After all, there’s an Australian billionaire that wants to build it. 

And then there are the policies almost no one wants but that it sure looks like we’re getting anyway: municipal political parties (already a done deal), the Canada Pension Plan takeover, the Alberta provincial police. 

How does a blogger keep up?

All we can do is try.

Join the Conversation

31 Comments

  1. Congratulations on 18 years of fighting the good fight. We appreciate your hard work.
    If Marlaina wants to prostrate herself before her idol, she should pay for the junket herself, but grifting is what she does second best (after lying).

    1. Hey there, CX. By coincidence I was chatting with your other half, Hot Xena, and she is very tired of that Princess Warrior poster on your bedroom ceiling. I tried to remove it but it was stuck on bigly. Anyways best wishes to you and her for 2025. As you say, you’re gonna need it! Oh, and check out My Life Is Murder.

  2. My appreciation for Alberta Politics is unwavering. DJC makes Alberta life sparkle for good or ill without a paywall and I’m honoured each time he includes my comments. Congratulations on seventeen years of top notch, professional analysis.

  3. On the subject of Trump and how Canada needs to respond to him, allow me to recommend a podcast: David Herle’s “The Herle Burly”, specifically a recent episode of his semi-regular “The Chiefs”, in which he interviews a panel of former Canadian head-of-government Chiefs of Staff: Tim Murphy (former PM Paul Martin), Ian Brodie (former PM Stephen Harper), & Brian Topp (former Alberta Premier Rachel Notley).

    Topp in particular is most insightful about what The Donald is really up to and where he is taking his country — and it’s not an attractive prospect.

    https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-herle-burly/id1280218816?i=1000681174228

    1. Thanks for the link to the Herle-Berley podcast. Excellent discussion. Looking at their words at one point, ‘I don’t think Canadians are paying attention to this as intensely as they should’, I completely agree that that’s the case. Smith, Ford, the Liberals and everyone else, seem to think tightening our border will make that man happy and that will end the threat of tariffs but like these guys seem to agree, it’s not going to satisfy Trump at all.

      I watched one of his interviews and he said in effect, ‘all that tariff money coming in, we’ll be rich!’ He’s looking for ways to pay for tax cuts to his rich friends and tariffs will pay for that. And that is the one of the reasons that he’s doing this to Canadians and Mexico and China.

      When he put tariffs on China last time and China responded by cutting their agricultural imports, it turned out that he spent almost every nickel of those ‘Chinese’ tariffs on paying off the farmers to keep them from revolting. This time he’s going for a bigger pot of cash and the goal is to make more money so that the tax cuts can happen and (hopefully) he doesn’t add so much to their debt like he did last time so doesn’t have to answer for that failed promise. Because that’s one of his promises, cutting the debt. Canadians have to wake up and our politicians need to be prepared to play hardball and hit them with enough curve balls to make it hurt right back.

  4. Happy anniversary and all the best of the holiday season to you. This follower is especially grateful for all the great work you do to keep us informed. Thank you!!

  5. Congrats on such a long tenure as chief Chapel head! Best wishes in very trying times what with our little Nero in lockstep with the big Orange Julius ruling from somewhere in Florida.

  6. It looks like Alberta’s premier will bend the knee. Donald Trump intends to take over Greenland, Canada and the Panama Canal to pave the way for what — shipping and market access for Russian oligarchs and China? How does Alberta’s own Danielle Smith fit into this grandiose scheme?

    There’s more than one way for the U S. to take over a country: ruinous 25 percent tariffs on all imports (already threatened), annexation or how about a staged coup à la Chile (not to be confused with Ottawa and Coutts in 2022)? I think Albertans and Canadians could heed a warning here:

    https://lucid.substack.com/p/republicans-have-crashed-a-national-804?utm_medium=android&triedRedirect=true

  7. ‘The time of Nero…”

    Now that the Mango Mussolini has made it his intention to annex Canada, buy Greenland, and conquer the Panama Canal (Again) it maybe that these times could quickly degenerate from Times of Nero to Times of Caligula. Nero was bad enough, but Caligula was outright hilarious. Now that Trump’s assorted allies (Musk, Ramaswamy, and RFK Jr.) appear to be having their own meltdowns and foul-ups with the MAGA white-supremacists, we have so much to look forward to.

    Keep in mind that both Nero and Caligula may have been smeared by their political enemies (which they had many) it’s also important to remember that both met sad and bloody ends.

  8. Thank you, David. Your work is most appreciated and eagerly anticipated!

    Happy New Year to you and yours, as well as to all your readers!

    Wes

  9. Congrats on the milestone, DJC! The Steadman-esque picture is fabulous…although these days I’m sure many an Albertan wished they had Raoul Duke’s briefcase, just to momentarily escape the constant torture of the UCP and their efforts to turn this province into a quasi-fascist American satellite state. Either way, keep up the good fight and hope to see many more posts in 2025.

  10. Entirely OT but possibly important. Elon Musk has been trying to buy Wikipedia. If “Twitter” is any indication, I would say that’s bad, on many levels. As we slouch towards corporate feudalism, please consider that our new “barons” are buying our governments along with every media outlet they can. Maybe a donation to the commoners? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1180

    1. Personal anecdote: I once tried to edit a Wikipedia article and was told I could not do so without a link to an article published on the internet from the time of the event. I responded that the internet did not exist then, so by this standard, all of world history prior to the internet was negated because articles were not published on the internet at the time. My edit was published without further correspondence.

      Imagine if Elon got his hands on it.

  11. Happy anniversary Mr. Climenhaga.

    With Graeme Thomson mostly retired (and usually behind a paywall), you’re my first stop for Alberta political commentary.

  12. As the saying goes, imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. However, there is also a saying that the copy is never as good as the original. After all US politics has already had a number of Trump imitators who have fallen flat. So I feel while Smith may currently aspire to be Trump, it is quite likely she will end up being more like DeSantis, a parochial leader with national aspirations who ended up falling very flat.

    Of course in Canada we also already have a national Conservative leader who seems to be doing fairly well politically now and Smith hasn’t really indicated she has national aspirations other than constantly fighting with Ottawa and the current Federal government. However, I do feel that the UCP myth making machine is in full gear now, trying to turn Smith into something more invincible. They also tried the same with Kenney, but at least he had considerable national political experience. And lest we forget, Smith’s electoral record is decidedly mixed, I believe so far she won 25% or so of all the elections she ran in to be Premier. But of course these days it is very unfashionable to bring up the past. Certainly the UCP spin masters would like it to be best ignored.

    I suspect regardless of her attempts at careful studied imitation, Smith will likely go the way of many of the other Trump imitators and cheerleaders.

  13. With her track record on protecting children I’d be surprised if she didn’t go celebrate a man who’s close lifetime friend was a convicted child grooming, child trafficker who bragged about sexual interfering with children.

    1. And she is doing it on the taxpayer’s dime. If she is going to celebrate trump, well he did loose that court case with the writer who he sexually assaulted. Now why any one would want to purchase tickets to an event to celebrate a pig like him, makes you wonder about her values. Perhaps some one ought to send her a copy of his comments to the Bush kid, about groping women, while they were on the bus.

  14. Thank you for looking towards Blue Sky(s). There are concerns expressed about the present body that oversees it, due to their financial perspectives, and the monetization of the users, much as we saw with Twitter (prior to it’s present ownership). This is a concern that is often raised by Mastodon users.
    I also am appreciative of your involvement with Tyee.

    1. Dfjo: After our experience with Twitter and Facebook, I assume as do many others that the best we can hope for with any social media platform is for a good time, not for a long time. Right now, Bluesky works better than anything else. Six months from now? A year? Who knows? As for The Tyee, it is a great institution and should be supported with clicks and cash. DJC

  15. The people of Alberta voted for her, so what ever happens, its their own fault. Of course it will impact other Canadians, but such is life. Yes, it truly is time for the Alberta NDP to stand up and say a few words. if the new leader isn’t up to it, perhaps some enterprising other NDP MLA or party member might want to start working on the file.
    It is really not in Canada’s interests to have some Australian open coal mines here. They aren’t good for the enviornment and we have enough forest fires, hurricane winds off the B.C. coast, droughts, floods, etc.
    As to the Canadian Press, not that Canadian. They don’t even really do a decent job of reporting and when the express an opinion, their suggestions aren’t of much benefit to most Canadians.

  16. David: Congratulations on the 18th anniversary of Albertapolitics. It’s an absolutely top-chair publication, essential for understanding politics in this dynamic province, and appreciated by a great many. What an accomplishment!

    Wishing you many more years of success.

    Meanwhile: onward 2025!

  17. I am a senior on a meagre pension, I have been an active New Democrat since running in 1971. I refuse to consume the thrash of media in Alberta, I have removed all American News from my cable. It is far too dispiriting. You offer a glimmer of insight and hope, so I will be forwarding my contribution before year end. We need you more than ever. All the best in the New Year.

  18. Congratulations Dave, on your 18 years kicking against the pricks! As someone who has known you since your heady days with the Uvic Martlet in the 1970’s, I am continually amazed at your energy, commitment to high journalistic standards, and uncompromising ability to speak truth to power, bullshit and political shenanigans.

    B.C. misses you, but Alberta needs you more. Enjoy the ride in ’25!

    1. Thank you Bruce. Kind words from an old friend. Happy New Year to you! DJC

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.