A political party that has completely lost its mind is no laughing matter, but I’m going to start with a dad joke. 

The author’s late father, Dr. J.L. Climenhaga of the University of Victoria, with a telescope and his trademark snap-brim hat (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

Since my late dad was an astrophysicist and one of the founding members of the University of Victoria faculty, his dad jokes could sometimes take a scientific turn, like the one he used to tell his first-year astronomy students. 

We know that tiny people live on the moon, he’d explain. (That, presumably would perk up a few laggards in the room who thought Astronomy 100 was going to be an easy science course.) We’ve developed extremely powerful telescopes, you see. We’ve scoured every part of the moon. And yet we’ve never seen any evidence of life. So … (beat, beat) … the people who live there must be really small! 

I assume that elicited a chuckle or two from some of his more alert students. 

God only knows what would happen if a real astrophysicist told a joke like that at a members-only UCP meeting like the ones Premier Danielle Smith has been going to all around the province to ensure her most loyal supporters don’t skid her like they skidded Jason Kenney in her leadership review at party’s AGM in Red Deer on Nov. 1 and 2. 

The UCP base may not believe in tiny cultural Marxists from the moon – yet – but they certainly believe in chemtrails, the loony* fairy tale that someone is using jet contrails to spray us with secret chemicals to do something to us, presumably something at least as bad as COVID vaccines, possibly to control what’s left of our collective mind.

Alberta journalist Katie Teeling (Photo: Twitter/@teelingkat).

Thanks to Katie Teeling, the former editor of the University of Alberta student newspaper who has been showing up at Ms. Smith’s constituency meetings and live-tweeting them, we know that the premier was asked a question about chemtrails in the airspace over Edmonton at a meeting in Alberta’s capital. 

And thanks to someone, there’s even a poor quality video with iffy but serviceable sound showing how Ms. Smith responded, an answer that has caused some controversy since the premier failed to say to her questioner, Now look, madame, there are no chemtrails. So just stop it! 

The conventional wisdom is that Premier Smith feels the need to take anyone who might question her suitability to lead the UCP seriously, and placate them if possible. This is strategy we are all forced to adopt from time to time at family dinners, so it passes an initial credibility test. 

“The best I have been able to do,” Ms. Smith began her response, “is to talk to the woman who is responsible for controlling the airspace, and she says no one is allowed to go up and spray, anything, in the air.”

This on its face is troubling, since it suggests that Alberta’s premier has already been asking people with serious jobs questions about something that is taken seriously only in the most deranged corners of the Internet. (Take note, regular readers, we will likely be hearing from some of those people in the comments section of this blog. Probably at length.)

“We have a…,” Ms. Smith continued as some groans and gumbles begin to be heard from the audience. According to Ms. Teeling, some members of the crowd even booed. “…Nope,” the premier resumed, “she told me!” 

Ms. Smith then goes on in this short clip posted by @disorderedyyc, an unidentified self-described purveyor of video clips who is worth following if you follow Alberta politics. 

“The other person told me that if anyone is doing it, it’s the U.S. Department of Defense,” she said, apparently completely serious. “And, you know, like, I, I, I have some limitations in what I can do in my job. I don’t know that I would have much power if that is the case, if the U.S. Department of Defense is spraying us.”

Now, who can know what’s in another person’s mind? Not me! But this certainly suggests – does it not? – that Ms. Smith really does think someone is misting us with chemtrails unknown, and that the only hard part is figuring out who? (To be completely clear, no one is spraying us – at least not with contrails from passing airliners. And that skunky smell you smell on Edmonton’s streets? That’s neither from chemtrails nor actual skunks.)

“So, I will do what I can to investigate,” the premier promised, “but, I, everywhere I have gone, I have found no evidence that there’s any private sector company involved, my environment department’s not involved, my airports tell me that they have a record of every single plane that goes up, so … (she shrugs) … “I’m kinda dead-ended here.”

“If you have some special lead that you wanna give me afterwards,” she concluded, “please let me know and I’ll track it down.”

Throughout this short video clip, “Red Tape Reduction” and Service Alberta Minister Dale Nally stares off into space, occasionally squirming, as if wishing he could be magically transported somewhere else. And – who knows? – maybe if someone in the Premier’s Office notices the expression on his face when his boss is talking, he will be!

So, in case you’ve been wondering, while our health care system collapses, while no one is looking for teachers to staff those empty schools the government promises to start building, our peerless leader will be trying to figure out who’s responsible for the invisible, undetectable chemtrail mist slowly settling over Edmonton – perhaps explaining to credulous UCP supporters why so many of their neighbors here vote for the NDP.

Meanwhile, while the premier is preoccupied with the question of who’s controlling our minds with chemtrail pixie dust, who is going to figure out the vital question of what the heck kind of miniaturized Alberta-Bill-of-Rights-protected weapons we’re going to need to stop the invasion of Alberta by pint-sized illegal aliens from the moon?

*Derived from the late Latin, lunaticus, in turn derived from Roman Latin, luna, or, the moon, which was thought to cause temporary lunacy. 

Join the Conversation

52 Comments

  1. As I recall, a while before he was booted by his party, Kenney said something about the lunatics taking over. Well that seems kind of prophetic now, doesn’t it?

    It’s always hard to tell with Smith how much she really believes what the extremists in her party say, because during her previous life in talk radio she often seemed to drink the Kool aid, and how much she is humouring them. I am going to give her the benefit of the doubt here and say in this case it is likely more the latter.

    Speaking of talk radio, I remember years ago tuning into late night am radio and there was a strange program going on and on about chem trails. I couldn’t quite understand what they were so fascinated about and it seemed kind of boring to me so I didn’t listen too long. But I suspect there are people who actually get what they think is real news from shows like this which are the radio equivalent of the Enquirer.

    And now these people are the bedrock of support for the party of our current Premier. So their preoccupations now seem to often be hers.

    1. The “news” sources those people consume makes the Enquirer look like the BBC by comparison. It’s more like the Weekly World News. By the way, whatever happened to that old rag? I haven’t heard an update on Bat Boy in years….

  2. I’m having trouble believing the UCP has a mind to lose in the first place—and I’m not joking, although I’ll laugh anyway. And I won’t start with a dad joke since my dad wasn’t organically funny. For example, he laughed when I told him I was going to be a comedian when I grew up—well, he’s not laughing now! (Since he died many years ago, you can see it runs in the family.)

    No, I couldn’t remember a joke if my life depended on it so I instead have a fairly good reference library —like, with real books in it—like “1001 Jokes,” “The Ogaden Nash Pocket Book,” and “The Book of Mormon.”

    But, Little people, eh? Hmmm…

    How’s about this Official Citation:
    ‘THE IG NOBEL BIODIVERSITY PRIZE WAS AWARDED TO Chonosuke Okamura of the Okamura Fossil Laboratory in Nagoya, Japan, for discovering the fossils of dinosaurs, horses, dragons, princesses and more than 1,000 other extinct “mini-species,” each of which is less than 1/100 of an inch in length.’

    Okamura, a palaeontologist, believed he’d “discovered evidence that all modern living creatures are descended from tiny organisms resembling, in all but size, the big ones we see today.” His greatest claim to fame is the discovery of the mini-man, Homo sapiens minilorientalis, with a stature only 1/350 of modern humans. Although not having produced any new papers on the subject since 1987, Okamura won his prize in 1996 in the field of biodiversity. (RE: The Ig Nobel Prizes by Marc Abrahams, 2002, Plume Books, USA.)

    Consider one of Okamura’s observations: “All the [fossilized] women in Figure 70 have closed mouths and [are] seen to be undergoing pain by being buried alive in boiling mud, while the older woman in Figure 1 has a wide open mouth, looking like one who has lost her senses.”

    I shall leave it—and any pithy punchline anyone might want to apply—right there so’s to get back to the election campaign in my home province where we have a Conservative Party leader who has his own suspicions about shadowy government forces trying to secretly “control society” —this time by way of vaccines. See, we got the same thing here in BC—you prob’ly just gotta look closer than in Alberta. John Rustad might not be quite Okamura-like tiny, but his rival, NDP Premier David Eby, stands six-foot eight inches so one might have to look a little closer for the Conservative contender.

    Yep, them’s chem-trails, alright, although some might see among the tiny crystals of condensed water vapour and CO2 exhausted from jet engines millions of microscopic parachutists in the van of an invading force —but they ain’t nuthin Danielle Smith can do ‘bout it anyhow.

    Sleep well, my Alberta friends!

    1. Scotty: Evidence of an unsuccessful invasion by minuscule Marxist moon men, possibly squashed by Neanderthals. DJC

      1. DJC & Scotty— as they call them in Scotland: knats , though that might just be the accent; and back east, you could actually buy miniature leg-hold traps for those nasty little “vampires”…..

        PS to Scotty — Believe it or not, the ‘hawk’ finally made a positive contribution to the people of BC…..
        PRESS P- Sept 27th
        “Leaked dossier of 200 pages of conspiracies and controversial statements from JRustad’s conservative candidates.”

        As our host said, it would be funny if it wasn’t so serious.
        I.A.T.O F.T.S., pardon the language.

  3. Danielle Smith needs all the deflectors she can to turn people’s thoughts away from her abysmal leadership.

  4. There’s no end to the craziness these days. It cuts across the political spectrum, sparing no one. During the trucker’s protest in Ottawa a couple years ago, Liberal MP Ya’ara Saks got up in the House of Commons and claimed the phrase honk honk was really an acronym for “Heil Hitler.”

    https://youtu.be/7pkIm5lguZc?si=uDyvKoC_z5OlOP_n

    Ms. Saks is now the Minister of Mental Health. Crazy.

    1. Ronmac: Beep! Beep! Beep-beep-beep! was used by right-wingers in France during the Algerian war of liberation to signal “Algérie française,” so it’s not impossible or even unlikely that people who use “88” as a code (you can figure it out, readers, if you don’t know) would also use Honk! Honk! to indicate HH, don’t you think? DJC

        1. Jo: My French is execrable, but I do know how to pronounce ‘al-gé-rie fran-çaise’. Maybe I was momentarily seduced by “Shave and a haircut, two bits,” or something. Anyway, you’re right and I got the rhythm wrong. Nevertheless, it remains credible to me that the Ottawa occupiers could well have been sending a symbolic message with Honk! Honk! DJC

  5. Unbalanced journalism! Skunks are real! Even in my 15 minute Edmonton neighbourhood. I suspect they spy on my cat though… Never mind, Doug Main and Sheila Phimester are here to save us from the bicycle trails (trails- get it?) with PACE. Couldn’t help but notice, as she delivered her tract to my clearly marked ‘no junk mail, no flyers’ mailbox, (Are these people able to read?) she was clearly AVOIDING THE CRACKS in my walk! Most likely to save her own back, but it was… interesting. In the meantime, there’s quite a lot to worry about with the stuff that’s coming out of the rear end of those flying machines, Department of Defense or not. https://www.cbc.ca/newsinteractives/features/ultrafine-particles
    As for the mind control, yes indeed it is there, and Charlie Angus knows it.
    I don’t think I knew you existed in 2016, so I would like to thank you and your father retroactively for your support of public education.

    1. Emily: This blog was first published on Dec. 27, 2007, under the name St. Albert Diary. I subsequently changed the name to Alberta Diary and later to the present title when I was able to acquire the AlbertaPolitics.ca domain name. DJC

  6. Wowza! If we ever needed any evidence of just how illogical she is and how firmly she and her party are planted in an anti-science perspective – this would be it. Although, of course this isn’t the first time the party has shown just how nut bar they are. Strange days!

  7. Beautiful tribute to your dad, David. I had no idea when your blog started as I only discovered it quite recently, in astrophysical terms.

    1. Lefty: This blog was first published on Dec. 27, 2007, under the name St. Albert Diary. It had about six readers. I subsequently changed the name to Alberta Diary and to the present title when I was able to acquire the AlbertaPolitics.ca domain name. DJC

  8. Perhaps Dani missed out going to Disneyland as a child, dementia is setting in and memories of Pixie dust and magic are popping into her head from her childhood where she missed out on all of that? The UCP better start a real focus on mental health because it looks like the Premier desperately needs treatment. The next thing we could hear from her is how all these new immigrants are eating our dogs and cats. That would pretty much do it I think.

  9. Great article. Tiny edit for missed preposition.

    “Ms. Smith then goes on in this short clip posted by @disorderedyyc, an unidentified self-described purveyor [of] video clips who is worth following if you follow Alberta politics.”

  10. All while our benighted province now has the lowest minimum wage in all of Canada!!! The ‘luna’ bunch sure has its priorities straight from somewhere, maybe that little extra moon that will be in and out of orbit for a little while this fall.

  11. Thanks for writing another great column, David, illustrating once again the sad state of politics in Alberta, and the dangers of grassroots involvement.

    While the issue of chemtrails, and Danielle Smith’s apparent willingness to take them seriously, really illustrates how an unhinged minority seems to be able to direct the direction of our provincial government, there is another issue in the same category that I personally find considerably more concerning: the UCP’s banning of vote counting machines in municipal elections.

    Municipalities have used these machines for several elections without any real problems, especially since the paper ballots the machine counts could be re-counted by hand in a recount scenario. Then, when Donald Trump lost the 2020 election, one of the things he blamed was the vote counting machines for not producing an accurate count, and he convinced his loyal followers that the machines were unreliable. The followers in Alberta have now pushed Danielle Smith to ban the machines in next year’s municipal elections.

    The chemtrail issue, while entertaining in its silliness, is not doing any real harm. By comparison, the cost of counting ballots by hand will cost the municipalities several million dollars. Worse yet, it has to be paid by the cities running the election, not the provincial government that caused the problem.

    Opposition to governments wasting money is a meat and potatoes issue for true conservatives. Where are the non-MAGA conservatives on this issue?

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/edmonton-s-2025-civic-election-will-cost-an-extra-4-8m-under-bill-20-changes-city-says-1.7338155

    1. Bob: Personally, I think there is legitimate concern that U.S. elections could be, and have been, stolen through the (mis)use of computerized voting machines, although the majority of the cheating seems to have been done by Republicans, not Democrats. Be that as it may, the vote tabulators used in Alberta are not voting machines, they are ballot counters, and all ballots can be retained for use in a judicial recount. Given things David Parker has said, and the UCP’s history, there should also be concern that there will be efforts by the TBA right to intentionally miscount ballots to steal municipal elections for the UCP’s new municipal wing. DJC

      1. I witnessed improper procedure at the advance polls during the provincial election last May. An Elections Alberta employee took my ballot out of its cardboard privacy cover before putting it in the ballot counter. I objected and got the response, “It doesn’t matter. You could be voting for anyone.” It does matter, otherwise why bother with privacy covers? It matters to me. Duly reported to the authorities. Because I am tenacious, I went to the polls on election day. The worker was still there, but registering voters instead of handling ballots. I wonder how many times she did this. This is the equivalent of an official taking a ballot from a voter and unfolding it before putting it in the ballot box. Election rule-bending can take many forms, not the least of which is removing an individual’s right to privacy. Surely training for the workers handling ballots includes proper ballot handling. Not a serious enough breach to merit dismissal, I guess.

  12. We are one step away from cats, dogs and pets. The next step after that is geese. I challenge any of these people to find “Haitia” on a map.

    TBA is in charge now.

  13. Hello DJC and fellow commenters,
    I have the same concern as DJC about ballot counting by hand. Also more opportunity for UCP “scrutineers” to claim that totally legitimately marked ballots are not legitimate..

  14. Oh come on! I have no love for Daniel Smith but if the transcript is even close to correct, she is toying with the question. Yes, she should have shut it right down but then somebody would be offended (boohoo). I bet they had a big laugh in the office after. That someone would actually ask the question is the scary part. Creepy even.

    1. AA: I made the transcript from the recording that appeared on Twitter. No question that those are Ms. Smith and Mr. Nally in the in the video, I’ve met them both and I am confident the recording is the real McCoy. As for the accuracy of my transcriptions, well, any errors as they say, are entirely my fault. I’m quite confident of everything except one word, the word exclaimed by the premier after she encountered grumbles from the audience, which I transcribed as “Nope.” (As in, “Nope, she told me.”) It sounded like Nope to me, and that made sense in context, and if it was another exclamation, it wouldn’t change the meaning of the passage. As for the rest, I’m confident I got it right. DJC

      1. DJC I wasn’t questioning your transcript. I just couldn’t understand how anyone could make those ridiculous statements and not be joking.
        “The best I have been able to do,” Ms. Smith began her response, “is to talk to the woman who is responsible for controlling the airspace, and she says no one is allowed to go up and spray, anything, in the air.”
        Like Former Albertan said…Weird!

      2. On the premier’s left hand side at the presser was (1) Nate Glubish, who looked equally dumbfounded, but then neither he nor (2) Nally are the sharpest knives in the drawer.

        Perhaps the voters in (1) Strathcona-Sherwood Park and (2) St. Albert-Morinville will have seen enough of their gormless representatives and vote better, by choosing better.

    2. She posited that it was the United States military doing it, because she could find no evidence it was a private or government plane from CANADA.

      Meaning that SHE LOOKED. Toying with the question, you give her too much credit. She’s the fairweather premier, she goes whichever way the TBA blowhards are blowing

  15. If Dani is serious about climate change, she must share her secret about curbing her farts and her burps.

  16. What amused me was that Queen Danielle was being egged on by the lunatics to ‘do better’. That means do better at being a lunatic, like us. Or…the door!

    I suspect that there will soon be legislation up for vote which will …

    Officially recognize that Stanley Kubrick faked the moon landings.

    That the Sasquatch, Mothman, and Ogopogo are real.

    Crop circles are proof of extraterrestrial visitations.

    9/11 was an inside job

    * The Simpsons is a portal into a future where all events can be predicted.

    * Most likely true.

  17. No surprise whatsoever.

    It fits.

    The TBA group must be in 7th heaven. They have complete control over the Premier, the Cabinet, and the UCP Party without electing one member to the Legislature. It surely is a coup.

    One has to wonder if Ms. Smith realizes just how much she is embarrassing herself and embarrassing Alberta?

  18. Update from Press Progress–

    The Pentagon and NORAD respond to Danielle Smith : Nope, we’re not spraying chemicals over Alberta.
    “US Dept of Defense and NORAD deny Danielle Smith’s suggestion they are responsible for chemtrails over Alberta.”
    (LMAO!!!!)

    Reminds me of when the makers of Clorox had to put out a statement/ warning– Do not drink the bleach.

    So, first Scott Moe said he was going to have his office look into the chem-trail thing ; and had a wishy washy walk back. JordanKealy – new Conservative candidate for PeaceRiver N,** & now Marlaina.
    **from the dossier PressP.

    Just what did Marvin put into that ray-gun ? He must be really, really angry.
    Wait until those people get wind of Skippy’s Xweet (Sept 28th) about the ‘nuclear winter” because of JT&JS.

    Or, with my very own $shop ‘thin foil’ cloche, this could all just be Marlaina going out on the proverbial limb, to help take off some of the heat from fellow Albertan : Garnett Genius, who has proven once again that names are not necessarily indicators of merit or fitness to hold public office.
    ——————————
    Just as a sidenote- My sister in Edmonton asked me an interesting question today about Marlaina’s UCP members only town halls.
    Q. As Premier, representative of all Albertans, how can she restrict these T.H./ rallies to UCP members only? And I mean besides the obvious one of she doesn’t follow….hmm ? regular procedures, shall we say.

  19. Someone should ask her what is the shape of the earth? Because that is the next stop on this train, mark my words.

    1. D&G: Everybody knows the answer to that one: It’s round. AND it’s flat. Like a plate. DJC

  20. I think they said something in the movie Tropic Thunder about “never go full UCP.”
    I keep thinking the Con’s have hit a high tide mark when it comes to becoming a maple coated surrogate of USA’s MAGA movement. They continue to shatter my expectations as well as my faith in humanity.

  21. The difference between reality and science fiction is science fiction has to make sense. In the world currently there are so many things that a person can question and not get a satisfactory answer.
    Why is it always a happy ending for the rich people?
    Bail out the banks , throw out the people. If you bailed out the people they could have paid the banks . Win. Win.
    Covid 19 became the largest transfer of money from the poor to the rich in the history of money. Just luck, eh?
    The human mind needs to make sense of the world and add lack of information, hardship and a need to blame and here we are.
    You don’t have to think in the terms of conspiracy to recognise there are people in the world that never had to do anything but sit around and figure out how to make more money and gain more control of everything. It is a human attribute and failure.
    There has been tons of deception and secrets over the years.
    Even Coke formula is a proprietary secret. Arial aerosol dispersal is on record as a patent from the 80s. The US government did develop an atomic bomb with nobody catching on. Security now is more strict.
    Contempt prior to investigation is as errant as belief prior to the same. We are out here. POTUS couldn’t get an answer on UFOs.
    No one has a vested interest in telling the truth to the people but there is a spark of truth in all of it. I watch for parapraxis. Sometimes that’s only truth you find.

  22. I’ve always thought it was amazing people believe in chemtrails because uh, why wouldn’t they use them to pacify populations that pose an actual threat ? Like in Fallujah, feels like they actual prefer Willy Peter for that.

  23. chem trails, don’t know where people get those ideas..
    When I started living in the Comox Valley did read some articles about people believing in them. Then blogs became a thing and some bloggers believe in them also. The Comox Valley does have an air base, but really, we’re being sprayed by some sort of chemical by either Canadian or American entities. But on the other hand, there are people who believe the world was created in 7 days, lots of people believe their religion is the only “true” religion. It boggles the mind. Even as a 10 yr old back in the 1950s I didn’t believe that stuff. O.K. I believed in Santa Claus until I was about 8 or 9, after that not so much. Chem trails are in the same category. If smith wants to believe in them, good luck to Alberta. Perhaps Smith might be one of the first to go into “treatment” when she has the addicted go to “treatment”.
    Do like the idea of tiny people on the moon though. That’s cute. I have 3 two year old neighbours. I’ll check with them.

  24. “To be completely clear, no one is spraying us”. Just for the sake of absolute accuracy, this isn’t 100% strictly true. Alberta’s property insurance industry is engaged in an initiative to seed clouds with silver iodide to limit the formation of hailstones. Receipts here: https://www.ibc.ca/news-insights/in-focus/weathering-the-hailstorm-preparing-for-the-season-ahead#.

    That said, there is nothing nefarious about this, and as you said, this cloud seeding is “at least not with contrails from passing airliners” – in fact, it involves much smaller utility aircraft.

    Oh, and once again, we see one of Daniellezebub’s most offensive speech habits when she says, “I have found no evidence that there’s any private sector company involved, my environment department’s not involved, my airports tell me that they have a record of every single plane that goes up, so …”. “My” environment department? “My” airports? Who is she, a “tin-plated dictator with delusions of godhood”? (How many here will catch that reference?).

    The Ministry of the Environment is not the Premier’s personal property, and neither are Alberta’s airports. The Ministry belongs, if it can be framed in that fashion, to the people of Alberta, while the airports belong to the municipalities or airport authorities that operate them, and the land on which they sit belongs to the Government of Canada and is leased to those airport authorities or municipalities.

  25. Because you’re much more polite than I am, I will put a name to Smith’s “apparent” interest in contrails “apparently” predating the question on contrails from the floor. It is called lying. Very likely not even Smith has any interest in contrails. At the same time she is very interested in being seen to be in sync with her supporters at all times. Hence, the preposterous claim that she talked to a woman responsible for the airspace over Edmonton about contrails. Let’s just say I am wrong about this and Smith’s morals have been impugned unjustly. Is that really any less unsettling?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.