Notwithstanding serious concerns raised about Collin May’s past praise for a tendentious book denigrating the Islamic faith, the United Conservative Party Government proceeded on Thursday with his controversial appointment as chief of the Alberta Human Rights Commission.
The Calgary lawyer who served as a human rights tribunal member for three years was appointed to a five-year term as the commission’s chief by Justice Minister Tyler Shandro despite the public revelation on July 7 of his 2009 book review in a right-wing online magazine in which he expressed views that should have disqualified him from any role on the commission, let alone as its chief.
According to a statement sent by justice minister’s office to The Progress Report when its reporter asked about Mr. May’s book review in C2C Journal, Mr. Shandro didn’t agree with the soon-to-be-appointed human rights chief’s publicly expressed opinions. Mr. Shandro has not had anything more to say on the topic.
At the same time, Mr. May sent a not-very-reassuring statement to The Progress Report about his 2009 review – which has been sitting in plain sight on the C2C Journal website for 13 years. In it, he said he has changed his views about Islam and Muslims. He too has not been heard from since.
It is unknown whether Mr. May’s past literary efforts were simply missed in the vetting process for his new job, if any, or if they were ignored.
Regardless, the only official mention of the man since then was a message on the commission’s website last Wednesday by departing commission chief Kathryn Oviatt that concluded, “I will pass the baton to Collin May on July 14, and trust that he will uphold these principles as he leads the Commission into the next chapter.”
Meanwhile, when the CBC finally got around to reporting the story yesterday, rather like the proverbial farmer who remembered to shut the barn door after the horse had gone, both Messrs. Shandro and May declined to be interviewed.
Instead of talking to the CBC’s reporter, Mr. Shandro’s press secretary trotted out what appeared to be the same statement used before Mr. May’s appointment.
As for Mr. May, he didn’t speak about his past publicly expressed opinions on the fatuous grounds passed on by a commission functionary, as described by the CBC reporter, that the commission’s “policy mandate prevents a chief from giving media interviews in order to maintain neutrality, given the nature of the position.”
This is obviously preposterous. Mr. May was not being asked to comment on a complaint before the commission, but to speak to his own suitability for the job in light of his past statements that can fairly be described as Islamophobic and offensive.
Rather like Mr. Shandro’s office, the commission passed on Mr. May’s July 7 statement.
So now that it has had almost nothing to say on this topic, we can assume the UCP Government will have nothing more to say.
We’re No. 1! Just not in a good way …
No one should be surprised by the revelation the Kenney Government appeared mainly to be motivated by a desire to be the first Canadian jurisdiction to drop COVID-19 mitigation measures rather than the health and wellbeing of the province’s population.
This information is found in documents ordered made public by a judge in a suit brought by the Alberta Federation of Labour and the parents of five immunocompromised children challenging the government’s decision to remove the school mask mandate and block schools from developing their own masking policies.
A Feb. 8 slide presentation prepared for Chief Medical Officer of Health Deena Hinshaw, one of the documents the government fought hard to keep confidential on grounds of cabinet secrecy, was pretty clearly tilted in favour of lifting the restrictions as soon as possible.
“Embedded in what I would expect to be a scientific discussion were considerations around political concerns and economic concerns,” University of Calgary health law professor Lorian Hardcastle told the CBC. “One of the ‘pros’ listed in this presentation was to have Alberta be a leader in reopening.”
“That has nothing to do with science.” She observed. “That’s politics.”
Joe Anglin, former Wildrose MLA, vows to appeal dismissal of lawsuit against Elections Alberta
A judge may have tossed out his lawsuit saying Alberta’s Chief Electoral Officer maliciously prosecuted him for a minor election sign infraction, but former MLA Joe Anglin has vowed to continue his Quixotic seven-year fight come what may.
Mr. Anglin, renowned for his colourful stories about his experiences as a United States Marine and his often bumpy political career in Alberta, was ordered last week by Court of Queen’s Bench Justice Michael Lema to pay Elections Alberta’s costs in his long battle against a $250 fine levied after the 2015 election for having print that was too small on his election signs.
The judge indicated he thought Mr. Anglin was abusing the legal process.
But the former Wildrose Party and Independent MLA for Rimbey-Rocky Mountain House-Sundre, who was seeking $2.2 million in damages, said he intends to appeal.
Mr. Anglin trained as a lawyer at a U.S. institution after his term ended in 2015 with the election of his former constituency staffer, Jason Nixon, as the riding’s Wildrose MLA. Mr. Nixon is now the finance minister in Jason Kenney’s UCP government.
I have read that book, but not written a review of it. Does just having read it make one Islamophobic?
More than likely in your case. Nobody posts a comment in that pugnacious and challenging way unless they’re being a complete prat of the hearty har har kind.
Well, I rose to the bait. Prove me wrong.
Kenney’s Klown Kar is sure full of gas.
“It is unknown whether Mr. May’s past literary efforts were simply missed in the vetting process for his new job, if any, or if they were ignored”.
Maybe I am biased [you think!!!], but I would rather “follow the money” rather than any ‘vetting’ process that would be joined by some ethical political party.
This does not bode well for the Human Rights Commission. What a straight white male Christian heritage moment for Alberta. Freedom means being able to say whatever you want and get rewarded for it, if you are one of those. Hate speech? What’s that?
As for Covid, it’s nice to know for a fact what was obvious at the time. Science doesn’t matter to the UCP government. This should concern us all as wave seven hits our province. People under 70 who want a fourth vaccination cannot, for the most part, get one. There’s no sign of age limits being dropped. Britain will be allowing third boosters for those 50+ in the fall. B.C. has made the decision to drop the limit to 18+. Will Albertans have to travel out of province for vaccination?
But hey, free Covid RATs are finally readily available in the local pharmacy, where they been dumped in a self-serve bin. Never mind that they are close to expiry, and apparently not very good at detecting the new variants. With PCR tests only available by doctor’s order, this may be the only accessible testing option for many. Yes means yes to the RATs, and no means maybe. Freedom means being able to spread Covid everywhere and anywhere. Repeat after me, “It’s just the flu”; “I have a sinus infection”; “The seasonal allergies are bad this year.”
You and the leftist “news” have written so much about this yet none of yall have even published what he even wrote!!!!! So lazy and arrogant. Anyways here is the book review he wrote on a right-wing opinion site, the same way this is a left-wing opinion site. It is about IMPERIALISM!!!! Shouldn’t the head of a “human rights” commission have a deep understanding of colonization and imperialism? And in 2009 as well!
Cornelius: There is a link to Mr. May’s C2C Journal article, which I read in its entirety and from which I quoted, in the original July 11 post on this situation published on this blog. The article that broke the story, by The Progress Report, also quoted extensively from Mr. May’s article and provided a link. A subsequent post on this blog quoted a lengthy defence of Mr. May’s book review in C2C Journal, and provided a link to it. In addition, it is important to note that this is an opinion blog and, as such, does not purport to be a news source. So, I would say, you are quite wrong on all points. Of course you are, as they say, entitled to your opinions. You are not entitled to your own facts. DJC
The appointment of Collin May as chief of the Alberta Human Rights Commission has generated serious concerns due to his past opinions expressed in a book review denigrating the Islamic faith. Although Justice Minister Tyler Shandro appointed him to the position, his publicly expressed opinions on the C2C Journal website should have disqualified him from any role on the commission, let alone as its chief. It is unknown whether Mr. May’s past literary efforts were missed in the vetting process for his new job, if any, or if they were ignored. As a legal professional, it is essential to uphold ethical principles that promote equal rights and justice for all individuals regardless of their religion or background. As an advocate for equal rights and justice, I urge the commission to investigate this issue and take appropriate action if Mr. May is found to have violated the ethical principles of his role. If you need legal assistance from a law firm that upholds ethical principles, please visit our website at https://verkhovetslaw.com/.
Leave a comment