Alberta Politics
A not-uncommon Edmonton scene (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

Criticism of John Carpay, who compared pride flags to swastikas, called the work of a ‘left wing mob’

Posted on November 20, 2018, 2:28 am
7 mins

According to an increasingly influential segment of the United Conservative Party’s social conservative base, Albertans who have taken to social media to assail an ally of party leader Jason Kenney for the bigotry evident in his comparison of the pride flag to the Nazi swastika are nothing more than “the politically correct, thought policing, left-wing Twitter mob.”

That’s the word from the so-called Wilberforce Project, the anti-abortion group previously known as Pro-Life Alberta, which has been working hard below the radar since at least the end of last year to nominate as many UCP candidates as possible to, in its own words, engage in “political advocacy on behalf of the pre-born.”

Social conservative warrior John Carpay (Photo: CBC).

But apparently the group casts its net a little wider than its principal effort – which has nothing to do with slavery, by the way, despite the group taking its name from William Wilberforce, the 18th and 19th Century British anti-slavery campaigner.

The recent troubles of Mr. Kenney’s friend John Carpay, for example, were apparently just too much for them to resist.

Accordingly, the group has launched a NationBuilder page under the heading “I stand with John” that includes a petition demanding the UCP “maintain John Carpay’s membership in their party, and stand strong in the face of the left-wing, politically correct, Twitter mob’s attacks against him.”

According to the campaign, when the activist litigator for various social conservative causes said “it doesn’t matter whether it’s a hammer and sickle for communism, or whether it’s the swastika for Nazi Germany, or whether it’s a rainbow flag, the underlying thing is a hostility to individual freedoms” … it was just an accident us liberal snowflakes took it the way we did.

United Conservative Party Leader Jason Kenney (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

In his speech to a rally in Calgary organized by the alt-right Rebel Media video blog, the NationBuilder pitch explains, Mr. Carpay “accidentally gave the impression to some that he believed the Swastika and the Rainbow flag were comparable.” (Emphasis added.)

Wouldn’t you know it, those “leftists” just ignored him when he “issued a statement clarifying that he did not intend to communicate that comparison.”

Mr. Carpay is a bright man, and seems like the sort of fellow who carefully thinks about every word he utters. So whether or not the leak of a video of his remarks took him by surprise, it seems unlikely he intended to say anything other than what he did say.

That of course is not the way the former Pro-Life Alberta sees it. “The aim of the radical left in attacking Carpay is simple: hurt the reputation of a good man in order to damage the work that he is doing … and all those associated with him,” goes the group’s argument.”

I imagine right now that Mr. Kenney would have been just as happy if the Wilberforce Project had dropped the public manifestations of its support for Mr. Carpay, which soon found its way into general commentary on social media.

Behind the scenes, though, not so much, perhaps. Increasingly, it appears as if the Wilberforce Project is the activist heart of the UCP. Which is why, of course, Mr. Kenney is unlikely to tell Mr. Carpay to move on.

The Envoys – not a musical group – to seek bold oil price solutions

Recently appointed bold-ideas envoy Brian Topp (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

Premier Rachel Notley announced yesterday that her NDP Government has appointed three “special envoys” to “work with key energy leaders on bold solutions for closing the historically high oil price gap that is robbing the Canadian economy of more than $80 million a day.”

They are Robert Skinner of the University of Calgary School of Public Policy, former Alberta Energy deputy minister Coleen Volk, and the premier’s former chief of staff, the often-controversial Brian Topp.

It was Mr. Topp, who managed the 2013 campaign for then B.C. NDP leader Adrian Dix with less than stellar results, who nevertheless attracted most of the shots from UCP supporters on social media.

The envoys will report back soon. “All available options are on the table.”

Kerry Diotte set to sue U of A student newspaper

Edmonton Griesbach Conservative MP Kerry Diotte (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

Kerry Diotte, the Edmonton Griesbach Conservative MP who recently threatened a defamation suit against several young people who criticized him on Twitter, is now suing the University of Alberta student newspaper over a pair of related articles that appeared on its website.

The former Edmonton city councillor and Sun Media columnist filed a statement of claim against the Gateway Student Journalism Society yesterday. Unlike the earlier letters, this development was covered comprehensively by mainstream media.

This time, Mr. Diotte does not appear to be represented by Arthur Hamilton, the high-profile Conservative Party of Canada lawyer who sent letters to Bashir Mohamed and several other young people demanding a full retraction of comments suggesting that by posting photographs of himself with prominent white nationalist Faith Goldy, Mr. Diotte was supporting her views.

Mr. Mohamed’s lawyer said his client “will vigorously defend any attempt by Mr. Diotte to restrict his right to free expression, particularly on matters that are the very heart of his right to political and democratic expression.”

In the action against the Gateway, which became public yesterday, Mr. Diotte is represented by Jonathan Denis, who was minister of justice in Alison Redford’s Progressive Conservative cabinet.

7 Comments to: Criticism of John Carpay, who compared pride flags to swastikas, called the work of a ‘left wing mob’

  1. Sam Gunsch

    November 20th, 2018

    Obvious to everyone, left, right and centre, that they want to restore their ‘freedom’ to discriminate against LGBQT people and abortion rights as per their religious views.

    And ‘we’re going to do our very best to help elect a UCP gov’t to get laws restoring our ‘freedom’ to discriminate, so help us ____!’

    Reply
  2. David

    November 20th, 2018

    I am not sure Mr. Carpay’s “sorry if you were offended” non apology counts for as much in the real world as in the one his social conservative supporters seem to live in. They also seem quick to invoke martyrdom – “golly gee, we don’t understand why you are angry and found his remarks so insulting and upsetting”. I suppose though the UCP’s failure to discipline or expel him says a lot about how the party’s large social conservative base sees the world.

    Good luck to the envoys in finding pipeline capacity where it appears to be in such short supply. Of course, Kenney and the UCP also are not magically able to create new pipelines, although it appears they are trying to give voters the impression somehow they can. Pumping more bitumen in not in the best interest of the industry, it seems to me that is up to the companies to figure that out themselves and not go running to the government. It also seems industry opinion is quite divided on this issue, with those companies that own refineries in Alberta that can process bitumen not wanting government action. Perhaps it would be easier and wiser to increase refining capacity here, as the refined product seems more wanted than raw bitumen. It wouldn’t be cheap, but it might be better than relying on other jurisdictions who we can not force to do what we want for pipeline approvals.

    Reply
  3. Expat Albertan

    November 20th, 2018

    Speaking as a member of the politically correct, thought policing, left-wing Twitter mob, at least we don’t have the gall to sue people to try and shut them up.

    Reply
  4. Mike

    November 20th, 2018

    Can someone please tell me what value Brian “Anti-Oil, Anti-Alberta” Topp would bring to this envoy?

    Reply
  5. Farmer Brian

    November 21st, 2018

    As far as John Carpay goes what he said was no accident, it was in a written speech, realistically indefensible.

    I agree with Mike 100%, Brian Topp has been very public in his opposition to oil developement, certainly a questionable choice.

    I read a very good article on the Financial Post’s website this morning by Gwyn Morgan former CEO of Encana: “A great national energy champion is leaving Canada, thanks to Trudeau.” Now there is no doubt David that most of your readers will scoff at my suggestion to read this article but here you have a company that was started in Canada, grew in Canada and became the largest Canadian owned oil and gas company in Canada, headquartered in Calgary. A quote from the article:” Reluctant to state that stark reality in so many words, Encana’s CEO has instead said the company will now be headquarter less. But with half its board of directors, 60 percent of its production and the vast majority of its capital program south of the border, it is impossible to deny that Canada’s flagship energy company has now been Americanized.” This change has mostly occurred in the last 3 years and both Notley and Trudeau are complicit in the gutting of Alberta’s energy industry. Notley has changed her tune of late but horses have already left the barn! Enjoy your day.

    Reply
    • anon

      November 22nd, 2018

      don’t you think it is a bit patronizing to assume readers will refuse to read the Financial Pest? We all love a bit of fiction now and then.
      If you think the oil and gas sector has just been Americanized you might want to consider all the companies from Atlantic Richfield in the 1950s to Imperial Oil to Syncrude that are American owned or controlled. There never was any trend for Canadians to take control of the industry. Hell we can’t even regulate it to protect farm land or water, let alone take a fair share of the proceeds as Norway has done so well.

      Reply
  6. Bob Raynard

    November 23rd, 2018

    Press Progress has been reporting periodically how Right Now, an anti-abortion group, is working behind the scenes to embed anti-abortion candidates in the UCP. They were successful the other night when Tunde Obasan won the UCP nomination in Edmonton South.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

  • (not be published)