PHOTOS: Finance Minister Joe Ceci at yesterday’s news conference, in a government of Alberta photo, imparting the happy news that former premier Jim Prentice’s Tories left $1.1 billion lying around and didn’t bother to tell anyone about it. Below: Opposition Finance Critic Derek Fildebrandt and PC Leader Ric McIver.

Presumably it will be a Happy Canada Day today for Alberta Premier Rachel Notley with the news now out there the province has a billion dollars more in its kitty than we’d been led to believe in the final days of Progressive Conservative dynasty.

As NDP Finance Minister Joe Ceci said of the Government of Alberta annual report published yesterday, the extra billion sure isn’t going to hurt, although we will have to wait for the government’s next budget in the fall to see how this will all actually play out.

By the tone of Mr. Ceci’s remarks to the media, notwithstanding the windfall, he is not all much more optimistic about the province’s mid-term financial future than was PC finance minister Robin Campbell before the vote. Expectations management, I suppose. So no one should count on the NDP turning away from its plans to find new ways to raise revenue that don’t involve praying for higher petroleum prices.

In recent years under the PCs, the province used two different bookkeeping systems, which resulted in different numbers for the same thing, so everyone seemed confused yesterday as to how much unexpected cash is actually lying around. The conventional wisdom seemed to be about $1.1 million. Regardless, this suggested the old saw is right, that the purpose of accounting is not to enlighten, especially when the books are cooked up by Tories.

Wildrose Finance Critic Derek Fildebrandt demanded that the government produce a budget a month or two earlier than it plans, which just seemed like an effort to be heard saying something.

PC leader Ric McIver tried to argue the extra dough is the result of good Tory management, a story that could have had legs if the previous government hadn’t been so busy trying to hide the good news when it might have helped it. Presumably it did this to help persuade us all there was no alternative but another sour dose of austerity.

The Tories under the hapless Jim Prentice, then the party’s great hope for salvation, must have imagined they could do whatever they pleased because they just couldn’t lose. Well, it was Ms. Notley’s good fortune, and perhaps the province’s too, that the electorate had other ideas.

At any rate, the Tory nest egg, which had to be reported yesterday because a couple of pieces of Tory legislation, nevertheless became the NDP’s good news story. If nothing else, this proves that timing is everything.

We can argue about whether May’s NDP victory in Alberta was the result of an insightful strategist making her own good fortune or, as Norman Mailer put it, “a random play of vulgar good luck.” Perhaps it was a bit of each.

But either way, the timing of the discovery was also fortunate for the NDP in light of the joint effort yesterday by the Wildrose Party and loony-right commentator Ezra Levant to publicize old court documents showing the environment minister’s new chief of staff was convicted of a violent assault at a high school party more than 20 years ago.

Notwithstanding the fact Brent Dancey was only 18 at the time of his conviction, and later seems to have been pardoned, not to mention the Wildrose Party’s tendentious effort to tie the circumstances to violence against women, although there was no connection, this revelation nevertheless caused a ripple of unease in die-hard Alberta Dipper circles.

There has been some quiet grumbling about the number of candidates from outside Alberta who have been hired for senior political staff positions when there are many qualified Albertans who bleed orange. As blogger Dave Cournoyer observed and as premiers Alison Redford and Jim Prentice seemed to prove, “filling senior political jobs with outsiders who may not be familiar with the provincial political environment can alienate party loyalists and MLAs and lead to embarrassing mistakes.”

At the very least, the easy-to-discover revelation about Mr. Dancey suggests to the grumblers the government’s vetting process left something to be desired. If nothing else, that needs to be fixed.

Also yesterday, in the hours leading up to today’s holiday, the government announced Carl Amrhein will become deputy minister of the province’s most expensive and troubled ministry. Mr. Amrhein has been serving temporarily as the official administrator of Alberta Health Services in lieu of the independent board fired by Tory health minister Fred Horne two years ago for acting too independently.

Mr. Amrhein, a former provost of the University of Alberta with a reputation as an administrative tough guy, will take over as DM in August, replacing Janet Davidson, Alberta’s highest-paid civil servant and a former health care consultant recruited by Mr. Horne.

What Mr. Amrhein is paid is bound to be of some interest in light of Ms. Davidson’s controversial package of salary and benefits, worth about $644,000 a year to the Vancouver Island resident.

Mr. Amrhein’s appointment was part of a shuffle of deputy ministers, mostly non-political professional civil service managers with low profiles, that saw former University of Alberta law dean Philip Bryden appointed DM of Justice, and Tim Grant, the former Justice DM, shuffled out to Service Alberta.

While the Service Alberta appointment for the former major general seems like a clear demotion, if not exactly the equivalent of being busted back to buck private, Mr. Grant’s continued presence as a senior official in any ministry will cause no joy at the Alberta Union of Provincial Employees.

In 2013, after an illegal strike by jail guards, the union’s president accused Mr. Grant of “threatening a hard-won labour peace with taunting, threats and other goading behaviour on the Edmonton Remand Centre worksite, only the day after a promise was made to protect members from retaliation for strike activity.”

Mr. Grant’s continued central role under an NDP government appears to have come as an unpleasant and complete surprise to leaders of the province’s largest union, which represents approximately 22,000 of Alberta’s civil servants.

This post also appears on

Join the Conversation


  1. The Conservatives had cash stashed all over the place. My guess is Notley is uncovering the stash.
    Hospitals as one and one of the more popular examples would have a quarter million dollars in surplus in their budgets. They couldn’t touch it without permission from the minister.

    I’m pretty sure dam near every department in Government had the same stash and Notley found the keys to the safe.

    It’s so refreshing to have an honest government!

    1. Dear God. First Prentice is criticized as Grim Jim, supposedly exaggerating the bad news. Then apparently the books were worse than what the Tories led people to believe, supposedly underplaying the bad news. Then there are apparently stacks of cash lying around unaccounted for, again exaggerating the bad budget news. Can people at least be consistent in their criticism?

  2. Can we please start a write poll to rebrand (dog I love business school jargon) the CTF as “Ezra Levant’s Underwear Drawer of sock puppetry”, and Derrick Fildebrandt as a common gauleiter whore of whatever institute Preston has conned enough rubes to fund lately?

    Bonus track for Canada day mofos!

  3. I like the fact that the new healthcare dm is described as an administrative tough guy, but hopefully they also have senior people in the department who are well versed in healthcare policy.

  4. Heck David, AHS has a budget line of $1 Million for “Informal Recognition.” That’s where all the sporting event tickets, floral arrangements, expensive trinkets, etc. come from. This budget line is not used for Seasonal Parties, Retirement Dinners and all them there other regular events that the largest employer in the province has in the plans, hence the title ‘Informal Recognition.’

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.