Photos of shredded documents in Legislature Building prompt fears of PC document destruction spree

Posted on May 14, 2015, 12:51 am
4 mins

Were shredders like this at work in the Alberta Legislative Building this week? Actually modern document destruction equipment may not appear exactly as illustrated. Below: Alberta Freedom of Information Commissioner Jill Clayton and Public Interest Commissioner Peter Hourihan (CBC photos).

If serious document destruction has actually been taking place in Alberta, chances are good it happened well before Albertans marked their ballots, let alone before their votes were counted.

jill-claytonFor one thing, if the outgoing Progressive Conservative government led by Jim Prentice had access to quality public opinion polling – as it most certainly did – it would have been pretty obvious to it a few days before May 5 what was going to transpire on that day, and that the likely beneficiary would be Rachel Notley’s New Democratic Party.

For another, nowadays documents are not destroyed with paper shredders as effectively as with their digital equivalents – giant horseshoe magnets or something.

Just the same, it was the sight of bags of shredded documents in the hallways of the Legislature Building that seems to have set off a flurry of activity yesterday, with Alberta’s Freedom of Information Commissioner Jill Clayton and Public Interest Commissioner Peter Hourihan holding a joint news conference in the morning to say they’d be investigating complaints that records were being improperly destroyed at Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development.

For her part, Premier Designate Notley asked the province’s top civil servant to order a halt to all document destruction forthwith.

peter-hourihanThe facts the photos were circulating on social media and the public is in a cynical and distrustful mood about the outgoing PCs spurred everyone to respond to the reports with a certain amount of gravitas.

Seriously, though, with the PCs securely in power for close to half a century, you can count on it that some of the most outrageous deals were done with a nudge, a wink and no written records whatsoever – over gins and tonics in the clubhouses of pricey Rocky Mountain golf resorts and the like.

So it was a bit unrealistic for incoming Wildrose Opposition Leader Brian Jean to bleat that Ms. Notley didn’t act quickly enough when the official final vote counts won’t even be completed and announced until tomorrow.

Then again, you can hardly blame the Wildrosers for trying to establish the narrative that they’re on the ball, looking out for Alberta taxpayers, while getting us to forget that their caucus has about the same proportion of inexperienced MLAs as that of the new government.

Alberta Party Leader Greg Clark, that party’s only MLA, joined in too, having already told the media he’d be submitting numerous Freedom of Information and Privacy information requests in hopes of stopping the shredding, not that it’s clear how that would stop a determined document destroyer.

Voters can take comfort from the facts everyone – except perhaps the small Legislative cadre of PC survivors – is anxious to uncover as much Tory dirt as possible from the past 44 years, and moreover that there’s too much stuff that happened over a span of time that long for all records to have been destroyed in a few days.

If the Notley Government wants advice on where to start looking, it could always call the CBC’s estimable investigative journalist Charles Rusnell, who has made a career of uncovering records the former government would have been just as happy to leave undisturbed.

This post also appears on Rabble.ca.

7 Comments to: Photos of shredded documents in Legislature Building prompt fears of PC document destruction spree

  1. Sam Gunsch

    May 14th, 2015

    Many huge PC failures to serve and protect AB citizenry remain in plain sight.

    Shredding can’t erase the big ticket failures:

    A short list:

    Failures to provide for seniors housing. Subsidies for unecessary powerlines for major coal/powerline corporations’ profit. Abetting fracking that poisons drinking water. Allowing tarsands to pollute. Royalty giveaways since Getty. Turning AB into a banana(oil) republic that would re-elect PCs to infinity. etc. etc.

    http://www.edmontonjournal.com/Advocates+raise+questions+about+profit+margins+seniors+facilities/10912168/story.html
    http://thetyee.ca/Opinion/2014/09/16/Fracking-Suit-Supreme-Court/
    http://calgaryherald.com/news/politics/power-transmission-costs-in-alberta-expected-to-nearly-double-over-next-decade
    http://thetyee.ca/News/2013/03/02/Tar-Sand-Pollution-Refugees/
    http://www.edmontonjournal.com/opinion/editorials/Thursday+Editorial+victory+little/10375680/story.html
    http://nationtalk.ca/story/woodland-caribou-herds-declining-toward-extinction-in-alberta
    http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/national/Alberta+continues+sell+caribou+habitat+despite+federal/9910692/story.html
    http://m.thetyee.ca/News/2015/05/02/Royalty-Miscalculation-Cost-Alberta-Billions/
    http://m.thetyee.ca/News/2011/02/08/AlbertaElectricity/
    http://thetyee.ca/News/2014/06/05/Canada-Leaky-Energy-Wells/
    http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2014/04/02/3345311/tar-sands-cancer/
    http://thetyee.ca/News/2014/03/05/Alberta-Regulator-Halts-Steam-Bitumen-Mining/
    http://thetyee.ca/Blogs/TheHook/2014/02/21/Tailings-Waste-Athabasca/
    http://thetyee.ca/Opinion/2015/04/14/Reasons-to-Norwail/
    http://thetyee.ca/Opinion/2015/01/19/Alberta-Oil-Bender/
    http://thetyee.ca/Opinion/2011/04/13/HarpersBigQuestion/

    Reply
  2. Val Jobson

    May 14th, 2015

    The point of Clark making all those FOIPs may have been because it’s illegal to destroy documents in order to avoid an FOIP, so anyone who carried on shredding would know they were breaking the law. Or it brings them under the privacy commissioner’s jurisdiction or something like that.

    Clark says he has worked in records management, so he should have a good understanding of how the documents should be handled.

    Reply
      • Val Jobson

        May 15th, 2015

        Another bad law written by incompetent federal legislators which will have to be struck down by the Supreme Court, after costing us all who knows how much moneyu.

        Reply
    • David Climenhaga

      May 14th, 2015

      Some of us still think “back up” is two words. Justsaying.

      Reply
      • anonymous

        May 14th, 2015

        I was using the noun form. I always defer to the great hive mind of Wikipedia.

        “The verb form is to ‘back up’ in two words, whereas the noun is ‘backup’.”

        Reply

Leave a Reply

  • (not be published)