PHOTOS: Premier Jim Prentice bowls a strike … as Fred Horne, last of the Alberta legislature’s fabled “4H Club,” goes flying along with Ken Hughes, Dave Hancock and Doug Horner. Well, that pretty well puts paid to the Redford era, doesn’t it? Below: The only known flattering photo of the real Fred Horne (photo by Dave Cournoyer); Horne with Janet Davidson.

Former Alberta health minister Fred Horne, the last of the once powerful “4H Club” of Progressive Conservative ministers in key cabinet portfolios, has announced his intention to retire after the next election.

The Edmonton-Rutherford MLA’s announcement yesterday morning followed by hours that of former finance minister Doug Horner, MLA for Spruce Grove-St. Albert, who pulled the plug on provincial politics Thursday. Alert readers will be aware this development was predicted in yesterday’s post.

The first of the 4H’ers to go was Calgary-West MLA Ken Hughes, who served as both energy and municipal affairs minister and quit without much fanfare on Sept. 29 last year. Former premier pro tempore Dave Hancock, MLA for Edmonton-Whitemud, departed similarly swiftly on Sept. 12 immediately after Premier Jim Prentice was sworn in as premier.

Mr. Horne’s anodyne departure statement thanking the usual suspects gave few hints as to why he picked this moment, or how he felt about the end of his political career. However, it doesn’t require a PhD in political science to see that Premier Prentice is clearing the decks for an early election, likely before what’s left of the Opposition Wildrose Party can pick a leader on June 6 to replace the political-cross-dressing Danielle Smith who joined the Prentice PCs with 10 other Wildrosers last month.

Mr. Horne did say, “I look forward to supporting Premier Prentice, my colleagues and our Party in the years to come.” Forgive me, but one could almost hear the notes of Under the Spreading Chestnut Tree as this was read. Well, Mr. Horne, 53, has worked as a health care consultant for large private-sector health companies in the past, and may again someday, so it makes sense for him to exit as gracefully as possible.

All four 4H’ers were closely identified with the catastrophic government of former premier Alison Redford, and three of the four at various times had exhibited an interest in the premier’s job themselves – Mr. Horne being the only exception in that regard. As such it may well be the rumours are true and Mr. Prentice made it clear to all four that he didn’t want them ’round no more, no more.

The premier quickly removed Mr. Horne from cabinet as soon as he took over in September 2014. At the time, this was described in the media as a symbolic break with the past.

Mr. Horne’s departure right on the heels of Mr. Horner’s should surely lay to rest the preposterous theory floated by a professional political columnist yesterday that Mr. Horner might have timed his departure to force the premier to hold a by-election before a general election.

No, it’s much more likely Mr. Prentice is calling the shots, reasonably enough under the circumstances. Perhaps certain prominent Alberta politicians – including the four whose last names began with the letter H – have been instructed to fall on their swords, metaphorically speaking. Be that as it may, the premier clearly wants all candidates nominated and in place in time for an early vote.

Despite having been handed his hat, no one can say Mr. Horne does not leave a significant legacy that will not be as easy for Mr. Prentice to erase as it is for him to scrub some of Ms. Redford’s other signature pieces of legislation … like the fixed-election date law that is about to be flushed down the Memory Hole.

Mr. Horne’s signal accomplishment – whether intended or not – was the complete destruction of carefully fabricated story the humongous province-wide public health care agency created in 2008 by premier Ed Stelmach, Alberta Health Services, operated at arm’s length from the government.

Mr. Horne did this by firing the entire AHS board one day in June 2013 because it refused to obey his demand it break legal contracts with the organization’s senior executives and revoke their salary bonuses, which had become a huge embarrassment to the Redford Government.

Thereafter, it was much harder for the government to pretend it did not directly run AHS, which employs close to 100,000 Albertans, a convenient fairy tale that had served the government well.

Subsequent advice from the government’s lawyers persuaded Mr. Horne that, notwithstanding the board’s dismissal, AHS was going to have to pay the bonuses. His efforts to persuade the executives to forgo the pay for the sake of the province were not particularly successful, with only one of them agreeing to voluntarily return the cash.

Mr. Horne replaced the board with a single administrator, former KPMG health care consultant Janet Davidson, at a salary of about $580,000 plus another $64,000 in cash benefits and a car allowance. (By comparison, the prime minister of Canada is nowadays paid a base salary of $327,400.)

Ms. Davidson now serves in a slightly different role, as the Deputy Minister of Health, at the same salary, about double what other Alberta DMs are paid. So it is not entirely unreasonable to wonder if Ms. Davidson will soon follow her former colleague and boss and return to her Vancouver Island home.

While Mr. Horne is said to be an avid debater and debate coach, he was never a natural politician in the manner of Mr. Horner or Mr. Hancock.

Although as an MLA only since 2008, Mr. Horne will not receive the generous transitional-fund payout a veteran MLA and minister like Mr. Horner can expect, reported to be above a half a million dollars, he is certain to have a comfortable semi-retirement.

No doubt plum health care consulting assignments in the private sector beckon.

It remains to be seen if any of the loyal 4H’ers decides it is his public duty to write a tell-all book about the Redford years.

This post also appears on

Join the Conversation


  1. Now that the PC 4H club is gone, who will be next over the side? Will it be “the hairdo that walks like a man” (apologies to Allan Fotheringham), aka Thomas Lukaszuk?

    This is a bit reminiscent of Kaiser Wilhelm II dropping Otto Von Bismarck in the years leading up to the First World War. It has been argued that Bismarck’s successors as Chancellor were too weak to stand up to the petulant and impulsive Kaiser, and this may have been one of the contributing factors to the outbreak of war in August 1914.

    1. I almost mentioned Mr. Lukaszuk in this post and then decided to try to follow my own advice, “to stick ruthlessly to one topic.” Mr. Lukaszuk has a rebellious streak, and Premier Prentice does not strike me as a man who tolerates rebellion. But Mr. Lukaszuk is more of a fighter than any of the 4H’ers, and may push back, which could be interesting. He may be the man to write the tell-all book. One certainly hopes so.

  2. Slave Lake residents have Mr. Horne to thank for the dismantlement of our own health services. At Ms. Redford’s urging, Horne introduced the widely touted Family Care Clinic model, which led to the loss of more than half our doctors who have not yet been replaced. Despite loud protests from residents, Horne repeatedly told the press our needs were being met. Today, three doctors serve over 12,000 people. Wait times at the one and only AHS run clinic are frequently five hours. Babies, cancer patients and elders are turned away when wait times get too long. This model, which was to be implemented province-wide, has slipped mysteriously away into the night along with Redford and Horne. But their legacy remains to haunt us.

    1. The whole story of Family Care Clinics has never been properly told. Who came up with this idea? What was the point? What exactly was an FCC? (The concept seems to have been as easy to explain as early Social Credit theory – A + B, anyone? That is to say, it COULDN’T be explained.) Is it true the original intention was to try a very small number and the promise was vastly expanded as an election gambit. And so on. The whole mess deserves more attention.

  3. “As such it may well be the rumours are true and Mr. Prentice made it clear to all four that he didn’t want them ’round no more, no more.”

    Somebody cue the band….

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.