The Alberta Tory talent pool in 2014. Shallow, and not much fun for the guy in charge. Actual Alberta PC leaders may not appear as illustrated. Below: The real Mr. Jim Prentice. Main photo grabbed from the Internet.

Never mind the transition team. What about the cabinet?

It’s not just a question of who will be in Alberta Premier Select Jim Prentice’s minimalist new pre-general-election Progressive Conservative cabinet – Ken Hughes, c’mon down! – but who won’t be.

It’s also a question of who gets stiffed, regionally speaking: Calgary, Edmonton, or the countryside – which has already gone over to the Wildrose insurgency?

Cabinet making before the high-profile candidates Mr. Prentice has promised can step up to the plate is a serious political problem for the new Tory leader, made no easier by his promise to keep the size of his cabinet small.

All small-c conservative leaders make this promise at the start of their terms, by the way, because it seems fiscally responsible to people who aren’t paying much attention, a large cohort of citizens otherwise known as “voters.”

All of them eventually break it, because it’s hard to run a cabinet government with a ministry that’s too small, and because the exigencies of the Westminster single-member system demand regions and voter groups get their voice in cabinet. In the end, it’s easier to try to deke out voters than offend special and regional interests.

Disgraced former premier Alison Redford was atypical in that she actually attempted to game the electorate, by having a big cabinet but pretending it was small by not counting so-called associate ministers who (allegedly) reported to a senior minister. It was all pre-captured carbon smoke from a diminishing supply of dry ice, and mirrors that were later requisitioned for the use in two bathrooms of the Sky Palace.

For Mr. Prentice, it’s going to be the second big challenge after getting a seat as an MLA for himself, which won’t be easy since voters are itching to teach his Tories a thing or two and the Opposition parties are likely to waive the traditional free ride given to a new government leader.

So, getting back to the cabinet – the one he has to put together from the current extremely shallow pool of talent…. Mr. Hughes will likely be in it because he’s competent and because he did Mr. Prentice a favour by dropping out of the leadership race when asked to do so by the Prentice campaign.

But the other three members of the Legislative 4H Club – Dave Hancock, Doug Horner, and Fred Horne – together pose a bigger problem for the new premier.

They’re all reasonably competent, and this is not something you can say about a majority of the members of the current PC caucus. Indeed, with two or three exceptions, they may be about the only competent people Mr. Prentice has got left. So, in that regard, he can hardly afford to do without them.

On the other hand, they’re all politically tainted, having played big roles in the Redford Government, so he risks big trouble if he has anything to do with them.

When he took over as premier pro tempore after Ms. Redford was fired by her own caucus, Mr. Hancock became the chief excuse maker for the sins of the Redford Regime. Everybody wishes him well on the bench or wherever he ends up post election, but at this point he’s hardly an asset to the party he served for so long.

Mr. Horne’s the man who canned the entire Alberta Health Services board, an error of judgment so grave Mr. Prentice made complaining about it and promising to fix it major plank in his platform. He can hardly invite Mr. Horne back, especially to the health portfolio, without looking like a genuine pratt.

Mr. Horner’s the fellow who came up with Alberta’s novel method of making confusing separate Finance Department reports for operating expenses, capital expenses and savings, which almost everybody else seems to hate … even Mr. Prentice. On the other hand, he’s been loyally supporting Mr. Prentice’s campaign – loyal support being something Mr. Horner seems to specialize in.

What to do? Mr. Prentice can hardly throw the old crowd under the bus at the same time as he’s putting some of them back in the driver’s seat. Maybe he’ll pick one and symbolically toss out the other two

If he keeps many of the 4H crowd around, it’ll certainly be hard to distinguish Mr. Prentice’s cabinet from Mr. Hancock’s – which was all but identical to Ms. Redford’s until the leadership race began and infrastructure minister Ric McIver and labour minister (and former deputy premier) Thomas Lukaszuk dropped out to run against Mr. Prentice.

So what about those two? They did poorly in the leadership race because they were tarnished with the sins of the Redford Government – Mr. Lukaszuk for his “Bitumen Bubble” cuts to post-secondary education even before the details of his cellular phone bill hit the fan mid-campaign; Mr. McIver for his murky role in the Sky Palace affair (did he approve it, or stop it?) and the hinky feeling his social conservative connections obviously gave a lot of party members.

With Messrs. McIver and Lukaszuk, Mr. Prentice is damned if he does and damned if he doesn’t. If they all kiss and make up, cabinet will look like the same old sinners. If they don’t, the new premier will look like a graceless winner. I’d say the second option’s the better one from an optical perspective.

Other than that, well, there’s West Yellowhead MLA Robin Campbell, who has already been appointed to Mr. Prentice’s transition team. It never hurts to have a little union common sense in your cabinet, something Mr. Campbell can provide as a former local president of the United Mine Workers of America union.

Also look for Calgary-Greenway’s Manmeet Bhullar to remain in cabinet, and maybe rise up a notch or two – after all, he’s seemed like a bit of a comer for a while now, and he jumped onto the Prentice bandwagon even before Mr. Prentice was on it!

But after them, who’s left? Peter Sandhu? Mike Allen? David Xiao? Neil Brown? No, scratch the last two – the former plans to run for the federal Conservatives next year and the latter has agreed to step aside so Mr. Prentice can run in a by-election in his Calgary-MacKay-Nose Hill riding.

And Mr. Prentice’s high-profile celebrity candidates? They won’t be around until after the election, and the worse it looks for the Tories, the harder they’re going to be to recruit.

Well, as George W. Bush’s secretary of defence, Donald Rumsfeld, famously observed: “You go to war with the army you have – not the army you might want or wish to have at a later time.”

This post also appears on
+ + +

Who’s likely to be in, and to be out…

Here are some educated guesses – mine and those of some friends with similar interests – on whom Jim Prentice might remove from cabinet, plus those he’ll leave in or add to his first (and possibly last) pre-general-election ministry. No bets on what portfolios they might get, though. That’s just asking too much, even of a “pundit.” DJC


Jonathan Denis, Calgary-Acadia – Minister Jono? Shurely not!

Dave Hancock, Edmonton-Whitemud – he’s already been the premier (pro tempore), he wouldn’t want the job anyway, but others say he’ll stay in his old Education portfolio, a la Joe Clark

Fred Horne, Edmonton-Rutherfordgone from Health for sure, probably from cabinet as well

Doug Horner, Spruce Grove-St. Albert – certainly as finance minister, probably from cabinet

Thomas Lukaszuk, Edmonton-Castle Downs – he is from Edmonton, but nobody who matters in Edmonton likes him, and with fewer than 3,000 votes in the leadership race, he has no leverage


Manmeet Bhullar, Calgary-Greenway – he’s performed well and, as noted, jumped on the Prentice bandwagon before Mr. Prentice did, so he can expect a big promotion to one of the top posts

Robin Campbell, West Yellowhead – he’s on the transition team, he’ll also get an important portfolio

Ron Casey, Banff-Cochrane – the former mayor of Canmore is the only rural PC MLA south of Drayton Valley

Ken Hughes, Calgary-West – the man for whom Alison Redford cleared the decks, and who cleared the decks for Jim Prentice

Matt Jeneroux, Edmonton-South West – young, different, looks good on TV and is pretty smart

Donna Kennedy-Glans, Calgary Varsity – quit the Tories, assailed Ms. Redford and now wants back in, plus she has high-level connections with the oil industry

Jason Luan, Calgary-Hawkwood – new face, well liked, former public employee

Ric McIver, Calgary-Hays – they like him in south Calgary, so he may squeak in

Dianna McQueen, Drayton Valley-Devon – at risk, but probably to be kept around with a demotion

Steve Young, Edmonton-Riverview – a congenial former cop, bashed Alison Redford publicly, welcome to cabinet

Join the Conversation


  1. Mr Xiao, my MLA, seems to also be jumping to federal politics. Maybe running to replace Rona Ambrose. Massive overlap of the two ridings. Sounds like a politically genius thing to do.

    To my great annoyance this morning’s CBC radio spent hours reading messages about an unelected cabinet member! Shock! They ultimately admitted it would still be legal, constitutional and not unprecedented. They failed to suggest that a popular former Edmonton mayor could totally parlay the exposure into successfully winning a seat as a tory.

  2. Jim Prentice simply got the “Old Gang” back together like they Premier Kline did back in June 26, 2006
    Ralph Kline, Mayor Stephen Mandel, Doug Horner Agriculture Min., Gary Mar, Gary Lunn, Clint Dunford, Gene Zwozdesky, Jim Prentice Minister for Indian Affairs, Gary Lunn, Lloyd Snelgrove, Denis Herard, Honourable Denis Ducharme, Greg Melchin, Dave Rodney, ex-Calgary Mayor Dave Bronconnier, anti-gay MLA crusader Victor Doerkson, Cindy Ady, MLA Janis Tarchuk. The only people missing from the new Premiers gang is Dick Cheney and Mulroney’s old pal Michael Wilson.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.