PHOTOS: Former Progressive Conservative Premier Alison Redford smiles sadly as she leaves Government House in Edmonton on March 13, 2015, the day her Progressive Conservative caucus made the first steps toward firing her. Below: NDP Premier Rachel Notley, CBC morning show host Mark Connelly and NDP Status of Women Minister Stephanie McLean.
Alison Redford was certainly right when she told a radio interviewer yesterday we need as a democratic society to have a mature conversation about the treatment of women in politics outside the limits of a particular policy debate.
Alberta’s 14th premier, who led the province’s government from October 2011 to March 2014, was also right when she warned it’s hard to separate a discussion of how a politician is treated from the passions aroused by entirely legitimate disagreements over policy. Making that kind of separation takes time for reflection and requires the passions of the moment to fade.
But, as Ms. Redford said, this is not simply a question for the judgment of history – the problem is with us here and now, and not much has changed about the role of misogyny in Alberta politics between when she was premier and the present moment with another woman at the helm, Rachel Notley of the NDP.
“I don’t think things have changed,” Ms. Redford told CBC interviewer Mark Connelly, host of the broadcaster’s Edmonton morning drive show. “I think the only thing that’s changed is we’re talking about it now, if you look at, say, my experience, or what Premier Notley’s gone through.”
Understandably, we’ve not heard much from Ms. Redford since she was in effect driven out of power by her own Progressive Conservative caucus in March 2014. As she observed, the short time she was in power was “a very hairy time in Alberta politics.”
She briefly resurfaced yesterday to try to put to rest one of the controversies that dogged her short-lived government, the role she played in 2012 in selecting the legal consortium conducting the province’s health care cost-recovery lawsuit against the tobacco industry. The consortium she chose – and it seems clear Ms. Redford did the choosing – included a law firm in which her former husband and political confidante was a partner.
On Monday, she was cleared of conflict of interest allegations by the second of two ethics inquiries, the first by Alberta’s former ethics commissioner, and, after new information came to light, the second by British Columbia Ethics Commissioner Paul Fraser.
“Of course my family is pleased with the results,” she told Mr. Connelly yesterday. “It’s something we’ve been living with now for three years, and we’re glad to have that over.”
However, she went on, “if you enter public life you have to have a certain understanding that you will be open to public criticism and that’s entirely appropriate. … It’s the to and fro, the cut and thrust of political debate.”
But there is little question, she argued, that women politicians are held to a different standard than men. “There is a different understanding of how women conduct themselves in politics and what is the public expects of women. Characteristics, you know, that are normally considered attributes in men are not considered to be attributes in women and are sometimes referred to in a derogatory way.
“What I think is hopeful right now is that we’re talking about it,” she told her interlocutor, “that you’re asking those questions, and that there are people thinking about it.
“What I would like us to be able to do is to talk about that outside of the heat of the political debate, and think about it in a way that’s wider. … It’s not necessarily wiser when we’re right in the middle of … a policy debate, to start asking whether or not the political leader who is raising the issue is being treated fairly or unfairly. But after the fact to take a look at those sort of considerations I think is important.”
Certainly, Ms. Redford offered an appealing and persuasive new face to Albertans at the start of her run toward power in 2011. She picked her initial campaign team well, and she placed herself for campaign purposes in the sweet spot of the political-economic psyche of most Albertans – the socially progressive, moderately economically conservative centre.
Alas, once her first government was safely elected in 2012, Ms. Redford, by all accounts a brilliant person, turned from the progressive policies that attracted so many of her supporters, and, worse, became mired in a series of ethical controversies that included not just the so-called “Tobaccogate” affair, but inexplicable schemes like the fakes-on-a-plane passenger-booking scam, excessive spending on travel and the mad decision to secretly build a $2-million private “Sky Palace” residence for her and her daughter atop a government building.
Given all that, I don’t know if history will be kinder to Ms. Redford’s government than commentators were at the time she was in office – it very well may be, as she surely hopes – but it is too soon for that assessment.
It’s not too soon, though, to take her advice to do more than just talk about the deplorable treatment on women in politics by certain actors in Alberta.
Premier Notley’s NDP Government will do just that at 10 a.m. today, when Status of Women Minister Stephanie McLean launches a series of new videos and a second #ReadyForHer tour designed to encourage more women to run for municipal councils and school boards in Alberta’s municipal elections this October.
This post also appears on Rabble.ca.