The Alberta government’s new “oilsands growth program” announced yesterday turned out to be pretty much as anticipated: We’ll slash the province’s already low royalty rates in the hope oilsands companies will promise to create enough new jobs to give voters a reason to re-elect the United Conservative Party.

Janetta McKenzie, the Calgary-based Pembina Institute’s oil and gas program director (Photo: Pembina Institute).

We won’t quite be giving the stuff away, but as the salesmen on the beach in Mexico say about their T-shirts, a 2-per-cent royalty for five years will be “practically free.” After that, the royalties paid by some of the most profitable corporations in the world will climb ever-so-slowly by a percent a year until they reach a maximum of 6 per cent.

As Janetta McKenzie, director of the Calgary-based Pembina Institute’s oil and gas program, put it yesterday: “This new royalty system will return even less of the oil’s value to Albertans and even more to corporate shareholders.”

“At a time when families are enduring an unprecedented cost-of-living crisis, many will ask why even more of their tax dollars are to be gifted to oil corporations that are enjoying historic profits,” Dr. McKenzie said.

Of course, UCP strategists are counting on it that Alberta voters will do no such thing. They may very well be right.

Needless to say, unlike the clean-energy think tank’s analyst, the phalanx of Big Oil bosses that lined up at the government’s news conference in Calgary yesterday afternoon to support Premier Danielle Smith, Energy Minister Brian Jean and Finance Minister Jason Nixon practically cheered themselves hoarse, metaphorically speaking, during the hour and five minutes of mutual admiration and happy talk.

Indeed, the whole production yesterday looked a bit like a Broadway Musical, with the smiling premier at the podium, flanked by her ministers of energy and finance, in turn supported by a chorus line of oilpatch bigshots. All it really needed was for the lineup of anonymous workers behind them in UCP-blue coveralls and white hardhats to start singing!

But the claims made in the government’s press release that this big giveaway will potentially generate “approximately $205 billion in cumulative additional revenues by 2040 and over $1.3 trillion by 2060” sound fanciful, as did Mr. Nixon’s suggestion in response to a reporter’s question that the resulting investment could create as many as 600,000 new jobs.

All the theoretical benefits for taxpayers are years down the road, as always turns out to be the case in such matters as these. The big payoff for giant oilsands corporations will be closer at hand. The question is whether voters will believe the hopium peddled by the premier and her ministerial sidekicks.

Could happen. It’s been known to work before.

Premier Smith claimed during the news conference that Alberta will just be putting off receiving its cut for a little while. “It’s just delaying the amount of additional new revenues that will come in,” she chirped. Readers are invited to believe that if they please.

To return to Dr. McKenzie’s analysis, she noted that “Alberta taxpayers are already footing the bill for large investment tax credits, a $43-billion pipeline that private investors wouldn’t touch, tens of thousands of inactive and unsecured wells, and hundreds of millions of dollars in unpaid municipal taxes from the energy sector.”

“Now,” she continued, “taxpayers are being asked to further subsidize the oil industry to fill another taxpayer-subsidized pipeline.”

“The provincial government has not presented any evidence that indicates the existing royalty system is an obstacle to investment in the oil sands or in conventional production,” Dr. McKenzie added. “At a time when the industry is amassing billions in windfall profit due to the conflict in the Middle East, the private sector is absolutely capable of financing production expansion if they believed in sustained long-term oil demand.”

Ah, but do they? The current conflict in West Asia may in fact have something to do with this. While the giveaway – pardon me, investment enhancement – aims to create a stable environment that will encourage oil companies to stick around in Alberta while Ms. Smith achieves her ambition of doubling our oilsands output, its success still hinges on sustained demand and continued high prices.

One of these days, perhaps sooner than later, the United States’ war on Iran will draw to a close and prices may settle down thereafter. Moreover, when the Ukraine conflict ends, Russian energy may again go unvexed to the factories of the Rhine.

Given the factors Dr. McKenzie touched on, some of the oil giants now making bank on high oil prices to prop up the high-cost extraction of oil from the oilsands may be tempted to quietly pack up their profits and slip quietly out Alberta’s side door.

Is the UCP brain trust nervous that could happen on their watch?

Join the Conversation

40 Comments

  1. “Is the UCP brain trust nervous that could happen on their watch?”

    Notwithstanding the validity of your hypothesis, it is repugnant to me to see you place “brain” and “trust” anywhere near “UCP”.

  2. The current oilsands royalty formula already discounts capital costs on new investment, meaning new projects and expansions already pay a lower rate.

    Everyone is falling over themselves to give these companies more money, and I imagine it’ll be crickets from the NDP on this because nobody can ever speak ill of big oil.

    1. James:

      I judged the NDP’s response to be so pathetic and embarrassing that I deemed it unworthy of quoting. Nevertheless, since you have accurately predicted what in fact had already happened, here is the entire Nov. 13 statement, reproduced below:

      “Nagwan Al-Guneid, Alberta NDP Shadow Minster for Energy and Minerals, issued the following statement:

      “Every significant change to Alberta’s royalty structure in the past has gone through a public and transparent review process with recommendations from experts.
      “The UCP government is pushing through critical changes that impact all Albertans without talking to them first.
      “This new structure is now designed without considering whether this is benefiting Albertans or good for the responsible development in the province.
      “We welcome the renewed engagement of Alberta companies in this work.
      “We will review the new structure and understand its impact on long-term jobs, on government revenues, and on meeting the conditions of the MOU with the federal government.”

      1. David: This is the measured response of a government in waiting not the shrill response of a political party satisfied with being in perpetual opposition. What did you expect the Alberta NDP to say in the absence of having a chance to review how this new royalty structure will function and impact provincial revenues, jobs and the environment? I could be wrong but this new royalty regime seems to apply to future investments in oil sands expansion, not to existing production which will continue to pay royalties under the existing formula.

      2. No doubt, this timid, meek, unassertive, spineless, wishy-washy, bland, lacking in vigor statement was workshopped to the Nth degree. This is why I stopped donating to the Alberta NDP. Welcome to the Alberta NDP, please check your spine at the door.

      3. Of course. Everyone remembers the promised review of Albertas Royalty Rate under Notleys NDP…. That they subsequently used to decide hey the rates are fine after all.

        If anyone can name a bigger gangster than oil companies I will wait. They’ve been killing folks for profit so long now it’s second nature.

        This province sits comfortably in their pocket. As far as Danielle Smith it’s been clear from the jump that her loyalty lies with oil and gas, I’m surprised she didn’t just sign over Alberta’s mineral rights entirely to the Rockefellers.

      4. Gawd! The AB NDP are so lame and useless. I bet they’d hire David Eby if he decides that his next gig will be as a freelance strategy advisor!

      5. Where is the ghost of David Lewis when we need him. Corporate welfare bums maybe, you of the ANDP? Remember that?

        1. Or at least the ghost of Peter Lougheed – a Calgary oil man who told the companies he used to work for to stuff and pay up.

  3. So Marlaina is going to give away our resources so that the oil companies can grow their already record profits? The only way this makes any sense at all is if she’s been promised lucrative board positions or somehow profits from this. She doesn’t care about Alberta. She only ever does something if it benefits her or her cronies.

    1. Here is a good place to repeat that Smith is a destroyer, not a builder. She destroyed a Calgary school board and two provincial political parties (one a legacy). Then she tried to destroy a province and a country with her separation referendum. Albertans need to repeat these facts ad nauseum.

  4. It is the same old sunk cost fallacy economic shoot-em’-up and the same old political rodeo that involves the promise and lure of a 6 figure annual income for individuals coming straight out of high school. (Where, “Promise the moon means to make extravagant promises that are impossible to fulfill. It often refers to offering something great or wonderful that one cannot actually deliver.”)

    Yet the reality is one where,

    “Employment in Alberta’s oil and gas industry is falling, even as companies are “swimming in money” with elevated prices and the industry awaits a lift from new pipeline access. . . . “We see a lot of royalties, but we don’t see a lot of jobs created in the oil and gas sector specifically because they’re not expanding,” Kent Fellows, an economist at the University of Calgary, said.”

    https://calgaryherald.com/business/alberta-gaining-jobs-just-not-in-oil-and-gas

    In Alberta, more of the usual personal profit privatization and socialized costs and losses continues to be a a core ideal for state sponsored private capital accumulation, even though; “we” are told that: “We do not spend a lot of time thinking about how government should intervene to protect legacy industries.” Apparently it is one of the only things “we” think about.

    Finally, one wonders if the public is going to be responsible for financing the clean up in addition to subsidizing pipelines and further overall industry expansion (Where it is already the case that: “Negative externalities in the oil and gas industry are indeed considered social costs, as they impose costs on society that are not reflected in the market prices of the products. These costs can include environmental damage, health impacts, and loss of welfare for affected communities.”):

    https://globalnews.ca/news/4617664/cleaning-up-albertas-oilpatch-could-cost-260-billion-regulatory-documents-warn/

    1. Indeed the precipitous drop in oil sands employment has nothing to do with profits or investments; it’s automation, the same as every other industry. Less workers doing more work and making higher profits that are then sucked out of the county.

  5. Massive production increases and long-term employment opportunities in Alberta’s oil sands are very much a pipedream. The push to double output to 8 million barrels per day ignores hard market realities: surging Venezuelan supply is capping U.S. demand, rapid EV adoption in Asia—projected to hit 80% by 2030—is eroding fuel growth, and investors are demanding cash returns over costly megaprojects. Even if modest growth occurs, it will come from highly automated Steam-Assisted Gravity Drainage (SAGD) facilities rather than open-pit mines. That means any job surge will be brief and confined almost entirely to construction, requiring only a skeleton crew once operational. Meanwhile, the days of labour-intensive mining are fading fast too, as autonomous haul trucks and ongoing automation steadily shrink the permanent workforce at existing sites. We are being presented with a picture of the oilsands future that is far more political than it is realistic.

  6. Former Premier Lougheed said that we needed to act like owners of our resources, when it came to setting royalty rates. So he increased royalties in the early 1970s and it worked.

    Our current Smith UCP government seems to be doing the opposite now perhaps in desperation to try bring back another boom before the next election which is coming up soon.

    It may work, but the hesitation of energy companies to expand significantly now is due to concern that the current high prices will not last if the Middle East conflict ends or settles down soon. Also it could be years before more pipeline capacity is ready. Previously they got burned by getting ahead of themselves, expanding before that capacity was there. I don’t think they are going to repeat that again.

    There is a saying in economics about pushing on a string. Of course there may be smiles and nice words, but energy companies are not going to expand significantly until they feel it makes economic sense.

    The lack of job growth in the energy industry is a big problem for the UCP now. The looming election has finally started to focus the minds of the chaotic Smith UCP regime which has been more focused on its culture wars and political fights than the economy. However, the energy industry does not necessarily operate on this same short timeline.

    1. Dave: Oil companies also employ competent accountants and tax lawyers. Money and investment will move from one kind of extraction to another to take advantage of the best royalty rate. When the dust settles, a decade from now, neither the promised revenues nor the promised jobs will have appeared. DJC

  7. Disappearing oil patch jobs and no money to pay for public services?

    Don’t worry, now Danielle Smith is dumbing down public education. Now your kids can graduate from high school without the basic knowledge needed to enter a trade. Want a better education that includes Grade 12 Math, Sciences, English and Social Studies? Not here, bumpkins. Pay for higher education (Grades 11 and 12) yourself at a private school, probably. Or, fantastic opportunities await somewhere else if you become a temporary foreign worker in another country.

    The Alberta government didn’t consult anyone on this, except by a straw poll at a high school somewhere and they’ll figure it out as they go along. Never mind. Count your blessings that the premier didn’t shut down the airspace and go on TV to demand $50B. Stupid is as stupid does.

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-high-school-grad-requirements-9.7421027

  8. It is very clear Smith wants to keep pumping millions of barrels into the atmosphere without any regard for the environment or where things are heading as fossil fuels are on their way out. The floods and wild fires of late should be a wake up call but remain secondary to Smith.
    “All it really needed was for the lineup of anonymous workers behind them in UCP-blue coveralls and white hardhats to start singing!” What might be appropriate would be a revised version of the Vikings singing the J.G. Wentworth: “I have a structured settlement and I need cash now”.
    I certainly hope those dumb ass voters wake up and send a big message to Smith and the UCP, it’s not about what you are doing for the oil industry, but what you are not doing for Albertans like building hospitals and rather spending time and money coming up with stupid band aid solutions like an 11:00 check out / discharge time, urgent care centers and privatizing everything associated with health care, just to mention a few.

    1. Lori: Dr. McKenzie’s observations were well thought out, coherent and make sense. As far as I noticed, they appeared in none of the media coverage of the announcement. However, that may not have been the result of malice so much as the success of the UCP’s use of an “embargoed technical briefing” complete with short-term NDAs to keep reporters from approaching potential critics. DJC

  9. Once more these Reformers are treating Albertans like morons while they give away billions more of taxpayers oil wealth cutting royalties from 3% down to 1% and we are expected to be dumb enough to accept it.Helping the rich become a lot richer is all these Reformers care about.
    Yet over the past year our provincial debt has increased by $11 billion while the oil companies have bragged about record profits.
    Is it any wonder why the American Oilmen I was involved with called us the dumbest people on the planet for allowing this to happen. We know Albertans have been screwed out of $1.4 trillion and as one oilman said to me “Don’t you people know it’s non-renewable”.
    Giving away billions more is just plain stupidity, isn’t it?
    Make certain you let these Reformers how you feel about it.

  10. More subsidies for Big Oil? Oh yay. This sound way too familiar.

    Ralph Klein did this in the early 2000’s. He cut royalty payments to 1% while the bitumen companies were paying off construction costs on their big expansion plans. Ralph’s giveaway recently ended; remember the UCP promises of more spending, thanks to the increased revenue from new, post-construction royalties of 25%? (Hysterical footnote: Lougheed-era royalty rates were around 40%. Thanks, Ralph.)

    So Ralph spurred on a construction boom—not, repeat, NOT an oil boom—from about 2004 to 2007, aka “the Crazy Years.” That ended in 2007, after a global spike in oil prices to $147 per barrel crashed to less than $30. By 2008, bitumen extraction was overbuilt.

    That’s how we got stuck with “not enough pipelines” in the 2010’s. It wasn’t “not enough pipelines”; it was “too much bitumen.” Nobody gave a thought to getting all that tar to somewhere people would refine it. Then Rachel Notley saved ‘em from their lack of foresight by convincing Justin Trudeau to buy, and complete, the Trans Mountain Expansion.

    Now, our glorious leader, Danielle “Oil is God” Smith, has made the opposite mistake. Both oil companies and pipeline companies told her they don’t want another pipeline. Let me repeat: THEY DON’T WANT ANOTHER PIPELINE. They don’t want to build more extraction. Why? Bitumen extraction is a cash cow. It’s profitable. It’s a mature industry. They’ve been cutting production costs for years; they don’t WANT to invest in anything but cost-cutting.

    Oh sure, they’ll take another pipeline; they’ll consider “investing” in more extraction. But only if Danielle and her new BFF Mark pay for it all. Just like they “invested” in carbon capture for the last 10 years.

    1. They also don’t want a pipeline because they control the refineries the pipelines are currently feeding. Why would they want competition from Asia ?

  11. I watched an analyst on the telly this morning, saying that this will bring 10 years of good growth……… Then what happens, we’re back to square one, whining and crying and throwing all sorts of cash at a dead horse? Smith is so short sighted, that her and her merry little breezes are willing to ignore diversifying our economy and forego better energy options, in favor of putting everything into one basket.

  12. The oilsands companies will take the money and like a Lily Allen refrain they will say, “f@#k you, very very much”. Our taxpayer subsidies will go to bonuses, stock buy backs and dividends.

    Say what you like about Smith, convincing the majority of citizens of an entire province to vote against their own best interests, now that’s leadership!

  13. Looks like Fraulein Schmidt is taking a break from coddling rednecks and separatists and going back to what she does best: lobbying/shilling for her oil masters. Despite flirting with disaster this year my fear is she’s found the winning formula for next year.

  14. Of course this is what Smith and the UCP have decided to do because in their worldview the only appropriate use of public funds is self-enrichment and enrichment of one’s friends which, through reciprocity, leads to greater self-enrichment. In the past, subsidies and tax breaks to oil and gas companies have been used for stock buybacks and dividends to shareholders and I see no reason to believe that this latest g(r)ift will be treated any differently.

    Recently I’ve watched a number of videos on Markham Hislop’s Energi Media YouTube channel and he has stated repeatedly that the data he has reviewed clearly shows that the demand in Asia that Smith’s beloved pipelines to the coast are purported to meet is shrinking. China and India are electrifying rapidly, at least compared to North America, and China has a stable land-based supply of fossil fuels so its need for the product that Alberta produces is lessening all the time. Furthermore, Max Fawcett in an interview with Hislop suggested a scenario for the proposed Pacific Link pipeline where the governments who have promised public funds for the project would need to incentivize producers to increase production in order to fill the pipeline at a time when demand and corresponding price are forecast to be in decline. He rightly suggests that oil company CEO’s would be opposed to this idea. Perhaps yesterday’s announcement is Smith simply getting a headstart on incentivizing companies to fill a pipeline that, as of today, exists only in the same dreamland as the 600,000 new jobs.

    Remember that earlier this year the UCP tabled a budget that projected a $9.4B deficit, the only salvation of which came as a result of Donald Trump’s ongoing Middle East debacle. Once that conflict is resolved and oil prices return to their pre-war levels our provincial revenue, duly assisted by our newly reduced royalty rates, will fall off a cliff. After that, I expect we will see the mother of all austerity budgets that will affect most Albertans in one or more unpleasant ways unless voters here are able to unite as they did for the separation referendum and vote the UCP out decisively. That might be hard to imagine, but Texans flipped their state from Red to Blue and Mississippi elected a Black senator in the midterms and no one saw either of those things coming. If Texas and Mississippi can create a political sea change then there’s no reason why Alberta can’t do the same. Enough is enough.

  15. at present extraction rates between 3.5 – 4.5 million barrels of bitumen, it takes 4 barrels of water to produce a single barrel of bitumen. to achieve the regimes goal of doubling production the operators will need almost 6 times more water. the 4 major oil sands operators consume 200 billion litres of water now, and have no safe way of disposing the toxic waste water accumulating in the current lakes.
    any guesses as to the potentate and her bootlicks intend to manage this consequence of their goal?

  16. One would have thought that Queen Danielle would have just abolished the Royalty program in favour of a provincial sales tax. After all, why should the O&G industry pay for anything? They are already guaranteed profits, subsidies, and a host of other benefits and other industries can only dream of. But that’s the task of the next government.

    As for the next election, I predict that Alberta will not be going to the polls until 2028 or 2029 for reasons.

  17. The taxpayer owes Alberta Big Oil nothing. The oil companies have more tax loop holes, then, there are holes in a block of Swiss chesse. What is the point of a tax structure that allows the oil companies to deduct more than they pay? Stop Alberta Big Oil from looting the taxpayer.

  18. When a pipeline has to be publicly backstopped and the oil inside it has to be royalty-discounted to get pumped, the “public return on investment” ceases to exist.

  19. Sweet. Fair is fair eye for an eye and all that.
    Whatever the revenue loss is from this poor decision. Dollar match that for personal income tax credits!!!

    FAIR IS FAIR DANIEL!!!

    STOP STEALING FROM US!!!

  20. Wasn’t the main point to hamper future democratic decisions to raise the lowest royalty rates on earth?

    Would you be interested in a model of the solvency of every oil & gas well in Alberta, David?

  21. Oh, but if Alberta revenues go south, don’t look here – look at those in Quebec and Ottawa that steal out money and make Alberta poorer. We could have nice things if not for those people out east.

  22. Ah, the magical one-sided ledger trotted out again. Silly me, I thought Rick Bell was going to ask a real question. Glenn Norman has interesting and blunt things to say about the other side of the ledger and provincial and federal governance. The NFU region 7 coordinator discussed provincial and federal mis-management of our water, aquifers and dams, water basins, surface rights, land contamination, the orphan well liability, the danger of CO2 pipelines, job elimination, data centres including their ruinous water use and the inevitable consumer price hike for gas and electricity they will bring about, green washing. All the things Rich Kruger doesn’t want to discuss of course because he’s ‘not a politician’. Anyway, interesting listen. https://substack.com/@th3gravitywell/note/p-224612173?r=2di3z9

  23. Political cartoon suggestion: inspired by Oliver Twist.

    A trio or quartet of obviously very wealthy oil barons, all dressed in white tie and tails, all holding out their top hats (upside down) to Mme Smith and Jason “Lurch” Nixon, saying in unison to Nixon, “Please, Sir, may we have some more?”

    1. Jerry: With a world globe in the background, with a map of Alberta showing, marked “The Tarsands.” Right? DJC

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.