Underdog Liberal MP Justin Trudeau lands a punch on Conservative Senator Patrick Brazeau in their March 31, 2012, charity boxing match, which the future prime minister won convincingly (Photo: Screenshot of YouTube video).

Danielle Smith comes out swinging. 

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith (Photo: Alberta Newsroom/Flickr).

Justin Trudeau’s Liberals do the rope-a-dope. 

Remember, though, in addition to being prime minister, Mr. Trudeau is an actual boxer, and the son of a judoka to boot. So he understands the rope-a-dope strategy, about which there is nothing dopey. 

The rope-a-dope is a famous boxing technique in which one contender leans against the ropes of the ring, covers up, and draws harmless punches until the other is exhausted enough to defeat. 

How better to describe the federal Liberals’ response to the Alberta premier’s hysterical sallies against the federal government’s “just transition” program and just about everything else that happens in Ottawa?

You must stop saying Just Transition, Ms. Smith bellowed in a performative letter to the prime minister posted to the Alberta Government’s website yesterday. 

Edmonton MP and Liberal Tourism Minister Randy Boissonnault, with Mr. Trudeau in 2014 (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

After all, just transition implies there will be a transition and a rare point of agreement for the disunited United Conservative Party is that there must be no transition from oil and gas, no matter what, forever and ever, amen. 

“Immediately drop the verbiage of ‘Just Transition,’” the premier’s letter demanded. “Rename the ‘Just Transition Act’ to the ‘Sustainable Jobs Act.’” (Never mind the iffy grammar here folks; there’s no time tonight to go down that rabbit hole.)

Ottawa’s response, delivered via social media: Sure. OK!

“Dear Premier Smith,” came the prime minister’s response, channelled by Natural Resources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson, Labour Minister Seamus O’Regan, and Tourism Minister and Edmonton MP Randy Boissonnault. 

“We thank you for the letter. Much of what you outlined is very much in line with what the federal government will bring forward – including the preference for the term ‘Sustainable Jobs.’”

Federal Natural Resources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson (Photo: JonathanWilkinson.ca).

The premier’s punch lands softly, leaving no bruise. 

Ms. Smith further demands: Ottawa must “vow that all provisions of any forthcoming legislation will be designed to incentivize investment” in the oil and gas sector. 

Ottawa’s response: Sure. OK.

“We will always support and make sure Alberta continues to be a global energy leader, now and for generations to come,” the letter from the federal trio says soothingly. 

The premier’s letter also claims, falsely, that the Just Transition program if implemented “will risk a full 25 per cent of Alberta’s economy and 187,000 jobs in Alberta.”

The federal letter responds gently, “as many of Canada’s and Alberta’s major unions and industry have said, if we work together and get this right, it will create huge opportunities for workers across the province.”

Federal Labour Minister Seamus O’Regan (Photo: Facebook/ Seamus O’Regan).

The premier’s letter: Dammit! I want a meeting with you about this! Right away! In February! (OK, that’s your blogger’s summary of what she said.)

Ottawa’s response: Hmmmm maybe … 

“We have been working productively and closely with Ministers Savage and Guthrie,” the federal message gently notes. (Environment Minister Sonya Savage and Energy Minister Peter Guthrie, that is; some emphasis was added to make the three Liberals’ point perfectly clear. Sly smiles not shown.)

“We look forward to continuing our ongoing work with you, your cabinet, unions and all partners on this important work.”

No provincial Conservative’s head has exploded yet. But one imagines that the pressure in building. If that happens, there may be no need for anyone in Ottawa to “execute devastating offensive punches,” as the Wikipedia entry on the rope-a-dope puts it, for the win. 

Just remember, though, as Senator Patrick Brazeau can tell you, if Mr. Trudeau decides to get off the ropes, he’s got a pretty good right, and a pretty good left too. 

Tyler Shandro conduct hearing to go into overtime

After hours of testimony and many delays yesterday, Tyler Shandro’s Alberta Law Society conduct hearing will have to continue later. Scheduled to end yesterday, the clock ran out on the three-day hearing into three complaints of unprofessional conduct in 2020 with more cross-examination of the Alberta justice minister required. More dates will be announced later by the Law Society. 

Join the Conversation

29 Comments

  1. Danielle Smith doesn’t comprehend what is within her limitations as premier. She makes all kinds of demands, that are not aligned with any type of logic, or reason, and she ends up looking stupid. She will face off with people who are far smarter than she is, and will end up conceding defeat.

  2. Yes, Smith might believe she is throwing hard punches at a hapless unpopular opponent, but the Federal government has its own strategy in dealing with over the top complaining Premiers. Smith might be one of the more problematic for them currently, but they have already outlasted or stared down several others.

    If you do not respond to the shouting, the person shouting starts to either tire or look ineffective, or possibly both. Of course the best response to Smith’s meeting request is to say you realize an Alberta election coming soon and you would be glad to meet with whomever wins that and gets a mandate from Albertans, shortly after that. This will probably make her head really explode!

    I feel the words Just Transition pose two different problems. One is with the word transition for those politically opposed to any sort of transition. The other is the word just. Those who feel their jobs threatened probably don’t consider it just. So the Federal government has figured out which problem should be addressed and which should not. They are now using the words Sustainable Transition more instead. Yes, it is only semantics, much like the name of an Ottawa parkway road, but words do matter in politics. So ironically the ones using the words Just Transition the most now are Conservatives.

    One of the Premiers Trudeau outlasted was the belligerent and confrontational Kenney and Trudeau seems to be dealing with Smith in a somewhat similar way.

  3. As the retired lawyers, and oilmen in our circle of friends have said over and over again while these stupid reformers hurl their sarcastic comments at anyone who doesn’t support them it’s obvious that they never consult with our oil executives. We don’t see any oil executives supporting any of their stupid remarks do we? The internet is full of articles from oil executives saying that Global Warming is a serious problem and wanting to do something about it. Lougheed certainly agreed and so did Dr. David Swann and Klein had him fired for suggesting that we need to do something about it. Just like Daniel Smith with doctors for daring to say vaccines would prevent deaths. Oil executives were the ones who wanted the carbon tax implement, because they know it works and were pleased that Notley and Trudeau would help them do it after Stephen Harper refused to.

  4. Since this easterner subscribes to his local Postmedia morning paper, for better or worse I’m allowed to access editions of sister papers including the Calgary Herald. The news and opinion sections offer two columns outlining Ms. Smith’s letter the blogger cites above.
    The news reporter painfully reconstructs her letter and I made to to the bottom of the column somnambulant but still awake. In the opinion section, the often pugnacious Mr. Braid, referring to Ms. Smith’s letter writes, “It’s loaded with conditions that will make Trudeau choke over his coffee.” I had to think he was putting us on.
    Neither piece refers to the government’s response. Not newsworthy maybe? Alberta Politics to the rescue!

  5. Careful there, David. You’re starting to channel Rick Bell.

    Speaking of channelling, what has possessed Tyler Shandro? He seems to have gone far beyond his usual level of red-faced rage. From the threat to unleash a security unit on a member of the public that brought him to this place, he’s gone on to expose confidential information about them in front of the panel reviewing his conduct. This transgression went unnoticed by that panel of lawyers, until called out by a member of the media. It’s hard to have faith in this process at all. Now the proceedings have been delayed, possibly until after the provincial election. Lawyers reviewing lawyers. What could come of that?

    If anyone wants to take a trip on the loop-de-loop of Tyler Shandro saying “conspiracy theory!”, “AMA” and “CBC” at every turn, Jonny Wakefield’s Twitter feed sums it up.

  6. If I was advising Trudeau, I certainly would recommend he use the rope-a-dope strategy, otherwise known as winding down the clock.

    Why engage when her time is running out anyway? If not the election at the end of May, then it is still possible she may not survive an internal revolt. I certainly wouldn’t take the bait. Who the fuck listens to her at all at this point. She just keeps putting her foot in her mouth constantly. Heck, she can’t even lie properly.

    Trudeau has the luxury of ignoring her, so use that.

  7. This looks like the “year of Danielle’s silliest season ever”. I guess it will continue until (hopefully) she will get jettisoned back to the talk show crowd.

  8. It just goes on, and on, with the inept Shandro. This:
    “Alberta Justice Minister Accused of Privacy Breach in Law Society Hearing. Shandro’s testimony allegedly violated the privacy of a witness by referencing secrets he gained in an official role. Shandro revealed highly personal information about a witness’s family, stalling a review of his behavior by Alberta’s law society.”
    http://www.thetyee.ca

  9. Say what will about PMJT, he’s a skilled operator — maybe too skilled for his own good, but skilled nonetheless.

    Standing and watching everyone lose their heads and fall into ranting hysterics is often the best strategy for looking like the only adult in the room. We can see that this was successful in negotiating with the provinces over the additional health care funding. Not do the feds not trust the provinces with the additional funding without the oversight, it seems that the residents of the respective provinces don’t trust their own provincial governments to do the right thing. That’s why B.C. hopped on immediately to the proposals; if Alberta wants to do to their crazy shite, let them. They wanted and need the funding and accepting the reasonable oversight isn’t too much to ask for.

    Of course, for the sake of FreeDUMB, Danielle Smith goes the other way and goes all Posse Comitatus and go all convoy crazy over whatever her bases obsesses over. Alberta is now seen as the Karen of provinces, whining endlessly about being cheated, all the while earning higher incomes than the national average, and boasting about the next ATV or bigger and more blinged-out pickup truck they are going to buy.

    May as well say out loud what everyone is thinking: Danielle Smith is the white trash premier for a white trash province.

  10. This is the typical change the channel move by the UCP. Turn up the hate on both the CBC and the PM. Easy targets. Truth does not matter as long as the UCP supporters buy into into.

    Much as Danielle Smith wants the pesky ‘interfering in justice’ issue to go away I do not think it will be overshadowed by anything else.

    IMHO, anything other than an independent inquiry that she does will only hurt her. In her shoes, I would call for an independent inquiry. I would select the chairman by mid Feb and have the members selected by the end of Feb. One month gone. I would ensure that the tentative date for the report is after the next election. Preferably in the summer. I would keep Tyler Shandro around until the report is tabled. Then throw him plus one of two of her staff under the bus.

  11. I was a big fan of Cassius Clay, later known as the great Mohammad Ali, the heavy-weight champion of the cosmos. His Rope-a-Dope was devastating because not only could he deliver a flurry of bout-ending punches (check out his 13-punch combo, while training for “The Rumble in the Jungle” in the excellent doc, When We Were Kings—just check it out), Ali could take round after round of absolutely monster body shots (and, after nearly eight rounds with George Foreman, that had to hurt; a lot) before bursting out of nowhere and rendering fight-commentator Howard Cosell almost unintelligibly drowning in saliva, the hulking Foreman almost unconscious, and everybody else watching slo-mo reruns for years and years just to figure out what happened.

    Not quite the royalty of Ali or Foreman (“Rope-a-Dope” was coined by this match), JT deftly employed the same strategy inside— and now outside—the ring, the former an easy dispatch of the pudgy-tatted blowhard, Harper-appointed Senator Patrick Brazeau that presciently rattled the HarperCon government, the latter driving Freedumbites mad with frustration with his perennial “sunny ways, sunny days” demeanour which they’re sure is cocking a snook at them, no matter what they throw at him. (I wonder if the PM read Ali’s book of wisdom? I would recommend it to anyone—even Danielle Smith—especially Danielle Smith. I like to think no one is beyond redemption, anecdote notwithstanding.)

    The principle is simple: a missed punch takes more energy than a landed one (notice Tyson never threw missed punches, nor ever used the Rope-a-Dope strategy). Indeed, the rarity of a fourth term for any Canadian PM (it’s been over a century since the last one) might prove Trudeau the master strategist by letting his partisan rivals exhaust themselves with poorly-landed body-shots only to find themselves swinging and missing at the air when he steps down like a tag-team All-Star wrestler and the fit and fresh Marco Mendocino bounds into the ring (or whoever—but that’s a fight I’d sure like to see!) Surely the Liberals’ enemies fret about this possibility.

    It’s the dysUCP/CPC/PPC/PP frustration-Schadenfreude that’s so delicious (I bet they’re praying JT rides the Rainbow Railway through the Wild Rose province while arrogantly flipping Freedumbites the finger—“just once, please, Lord!”) The fact that Smith’s dysUCP base is so easily baited doesn’t diminish the joy of toying, but despite the jaw-dropping ridiculousness, and especially the preposterousness of Danielle Smith and her rabid corner, one has to snap out of it and realize: this is really very serious stuff. Alberta’s in a fix right now, what with longterm prospects of its dominant bitumen-boiling industry looking as infeasibly noir as charcoal-burning eventually became, and a paralyzed government now led by the Princess of the Peter Principle only the most bizarre of political circumstances could produce, Canadians are bound by national patriotism to help however they can. Even after the UCP is unelected to sort it-selves out. That’s what federalism is all about—Smith just doesn’t know that yet.

    What would the “Rumble in the Jungle” or the “Thriller in Manila” have been like in the internet age? Would the Covid Age have stolen Foreman’s mojo like that training injury did wayback when in Zaire? I dunno, but the irrepressible Ali prob’ly woulda loved Twitter—or maybe not (he virtually invented rap—possibly with the help of Percy Mayfield). But as clownish as he was, he was a very serious champion of peace, love and human rights. Rendered speechless by cumulative concussions and nerve-wasting disease, he wrote sincerely of his prescription for a fair and healthy future for all—and without a trace of bitterness for all the injustices and cruelties he endured in his transition from prize-fighter to silent sage.

    All funning aside, it should be said that although many wanted Foreman and Brazeau to win, it was apparent that more cheered at their respective losses. And, possibly due to these popular expectations, either way, both Foreman and Brazeau were rocked by what should have been for either of them just another fight, whether in the ring or the beer parlour, and both were thrown into such deep, introspective depressions that it could be said, as indeed both did in their turns, that they were spiritually as well as sportingly stung by defeat. But—and this is important in even the crazy politics of Alberta right now—both Foreman and Brazeau eventually had epiphanies which turned their personal griefs around and toward helping others, not least by confessing their Blues, perhaps inspired by the monolithic icon of the stoic Ali as he meditated in shambling silence and wrote of a better world to come.

    We would wish the same for Tyler Shandro who might not have experienced such crushing defeat yet, but who would do well to take a lesson from the ultimate redemption of these boxers: once they were kings, then they became living, human assets for their respective communities— and for us all.

    We wish the same for the great province of Alberta. Once its citizens crash and exit the wreckage of neoSoCon redoubterism, hopefully they’ll see, 20-20 in hindsight, that it was just a transition after all. It’s the beginning of the 8th Round in the Parry on the Prairies, JustinCase you were wondering.

  12. You made my day David Climenhaga! I don’t remember when I last laughed a good belly laugh reading a news media article. Thank-you! Looking forward to more!
    Lydia

  13. Did the Federal response really mention consulting with unions? More than once? I can sense blood vessels pounding in Rob Anderson’s temple.

    1. Neil: Yes it did. I had the same thought. In fact, I was even going to try to search for a photo of the blood vessel throbbing in Louis del Grande’s head in Scanners (1981) to illustrate the point. I’m sure it was intentional. DJC

  14. RE: Mr. Sandro getting his day in court – probably not a good sign when your trial has to be unexpectedly extended. I get that Mr. Sandro is a wealthy white male, so our judicial system would normally want to rule “boys will be boys,” but that would be a super bad look. Hopefully one of the big brains is listened to when they point out that the quiet part is being said out loud an awful lot lately, perhaps if they want to keep their positions of power they ought to lie low for a while.

    RE: Ms. Smith – here’s a completely true fact that I just made up and take no responsibility for (because apparently that’s the world we live in now) – “rope-a-dope” was originally a political term that described giving a dope more rope with which to hang themselves.

    I’ve heard it said that in politics having strong friends is best, having weak enemies is next best (life is easier, plus they build your confidence), having strong enemies is third best (they’ll force you to be strong), and having weak friends is a complete disaster (every time you turn around they’re grabbing your ankle).

    Ms. Smith and her pathetic clown car full of kleptocratic gas-huffing culture warriors are giving Trudeau and the liberals the second best gift a politician can get. If I was him, I’d keep on smiling and giving more rope to the dope. If I was a conservative I would be beyond angry at “my side” – they keep making Trudeau look good! Seriously, they know they’re going to have to persuade at least some people who don’t watch Tucker Carlson and Alex Jones religiously to vote for them in order to get a majority government, right?

  15. CHILD: Daddy, where did the UCP come from?

    FATHER: Well son, sometimes when a tire fire and a clown car love each other very much…

  16. I recognize this strategy, as the let your opponent tantrum until such time as everyone realizes the opponent is a total moron. It’s more likely to prove most effective the more hysterical your opponent becomes. Albertans appreciate calm, reliable and predictable government, with a slight centre right bias. I suspect Discord Danielle as she becomes more frantic will do more and more damage to the United Confusion Party. I am also sure that the UCP must be missing ‘ole JK by now. At least he was a steady, albeit strange pair of hands when he wasn’t AWOL in parts unknown.

    1. “Albertans appreciate calm, reliable and predictable government …”

      I’m not sure what Alberta you’re referring to here, certainly not any Alberta that has existed in the previous couple centuries.
      I guess ‘former’ can refer back a long time ago. A really long, long time.

  17. Oh my!

    Mrs. Smith, you’ve been outplayed by Mr. Trudeau who reacted to your demands by acting like an adult and being both reasonable and cooperative. Oh my. What a shock that must have been when you’ve been spoiling for a fight! Striking first is not always the best strategy because as you can now see, Mr. Trudeau has easily disarmed you by countering with a calm, polite parry, and a willingness to listen and…. cooperate. Why don’t you just riposte with a shocking and daring willingness to listen, even if just for a moment?! Is it because he might say something helpful for Albertans but counter to your policies, something so sensible that you don’t want to hear it, or have others hear it ? Is it because you aren’t strong enough to survive the “heat” or embarrassment if can’t “prick him” to draw first political blood? Do you (loudly and blindly) protest just to feed the anti Liberal political fires? Are you being, no, I don’t dare think it, mmmm spiteful? No, surely not, because you care about Alberta and Albertans, right?

    Presently, a great many Albertans have become very upset and frightened. They are “possibly” being mislead or “misinformed” by fear mongering and by people fabricating the consequences of a great many unknowns, some half truths and possibly some outright lies? All, just to feed the flames of discontent, and so score political points? Surely not. Cynical me.

    There may be an opportunity here, and certainly Cenovus’ CEO, Alex Pourbaix thinks so. He’s big oil in Alberta and since he is willing to listen, then why not you, our leader?

    Mrs. Premier, Cenovus has got a lot of skin in the game and Mr. Pourbaix believes that if done properly, these ideas and supports could lead to another great boom like we had in the 80s and 90s. I doubt he’s a Liberal either Mrs. Premier, just sayin’ ! But, he does appear open minded enough to listen, and, he also knows that since change is inevitable, it is much better to lead than to be dragged along by force, or left behind in the ditch.

    If Alberta is going to stay vital and current with worldwide attitudes and policies we’ll require someone to help us change in order to fit in, someone who also supports the technology to combat ‘climate change suicide’. We’ll need a leader who plans ahead, because the old horse is startin’ to flag. No longer will all of the 20/20 “rearview mirror” style “planning” keep the “old steam engines” stoked enough to get us by. Alberta needs someone who is able to look both backwards and forward in order to understand the whole picture.

    Part of that picture may include the many petroleum workers who might just be better served by taking advantage of the “rumored” free or subsidized re-training funds proposed by our federal government… no wait, the Liberals? No way. Those workers would be enabled to remain vital, healthy and valued tax paying citizens. Or, do we want politically inflamed, uncooperative people who’re allowed to become embittered and sidelined, a tax burden?

    But no! Surely that’s not possible for the feds to want to help? These must all be lies, because “they’re the Liberals” who only want to shut us down, right? Maybe not? Maybe, first listen, ok? After that, if adjustments or amendments need to be made, then you can talk it out and be part of the process. But meanwhile please, please, please don’t outright condemn it without knowing the facts, plans and whole content ! You know, like you loudly accused Mrs. Notley of the NDP of doing with your Sovereignty Act? Something about a pot and kettle comes to mind.

    For now the “evil Mr. T” seems willing to talk, and maybe you should be too.
    Adulting is hard work isn’t it, but aren’t we Albertans worth the effort? Damned right we are!

  18. I mostly just enjoy this blog by reading but I must say, this one is exceptional.

    I’m not fond of combat itself but have marveled at the philosophy in descriptions like Bruce Lee’s ‘Broken Rhythm’ and now after reading ‘Rope-a-Dope’ strategy.

    Combined with this piece and the insightful comments herein, the effect begs the term ‘The Tao of Political Commentary’.

    1. Al: You brought a smile to my face. Broken rhythm is a thing in the martial arts, but it’s very hard to do, and most of us can’t. More Zen than Tao, though, methinks. DJC

  19. There is not much on t.v. this evening. thank you for this post. better than anything on t.v. Perhaps a t.v. series could come from this. Between this and the previous post, I’m having a good evening and thank you for the entertainment.

    If Smith is going to ‘argue” with Trudeau at least do over something important.

    Yes, he does know how to box. I temember that fight and whenever people make comments about him, I do remind them of that boxing match. After that fight it was clear he is way tougher than people thought he was.

    1. e.a.f.: Smarter than people thought a “drama teacher” ought to be, too. He found a good boxing gym and trained for a year for that fight. Then folks who weren’t paying attention were surprised that he won, by a TKO, no less. DJC

      1. I’ve always wondered what would happen if another world leader really insulted him or “upset” him. Perhaps he might be a good person to send to deal with Putin. Its nice to have a P.M. who can take care of himself.
        People I think forgot exactly who his Father was. Trudeau Sr. always came across as some one you would not want to tangle with.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.